RUSSIA AND THE VATICAN ESTABLISH FORMAL RELATIONS, FOR

C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 VATICAN 000126 SIPDIS E.O. 12958: DECL: 12/4/2019 TAGS: PINR PGOV PREL KIRF RS VT SUBJECT: RUSSIA AND THE VATICAN ESTABLISH FORMAL RELATIONS, FOR DIFFERENT REASONS REF: A. Vatican 100 ¶B. Vatican 64 VATICAN 00000126 001.2 OF 003 CLASSIFIED BY: Julieta Valls Noyes, DCM. REASON: 1.4 (b),(c),(d) Summary -------------- ¶1. (C) On December 3, Russian President Medvedev and Pope Benedict XVI upgraded Russian-Holy See ties to "full" diplomatic relations. The announcement coincides with a period of warmer relations between the Vatican and Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill (reftel) and the Holy See hopes the move will herald stronger ecumenical relations. The Russian motivation for upgrading relations, however, may have had more to do with domestic politics than a desire to improve inter-Christian understanding. Regardless of the motivation, and at least for now, it appears unlikely the decision will make much of a difference in either Russian-Vatican relations or Catholic-Russian Orthodox ties. End Summary. MEDVEDEV MEETS POPE, ANNOUNCES "FORMAL" TIES -------------- ¶2. (U) Following his meeting with Pope Benedict XVI on December 3, Russian President Medvedev announced that he had signed a decree upgrading ties with the Vatican to "full diplomatic relations." (Note: Medvedev did not come to Rome solely to meet with the Pope, he had a bilateral summit with the Italians first. End Note) It is unclear what the change actually means, as Russia has had a de facto embassy -- led formally by a designated "Ambassador" -- to the Holy See since 1990. The decision to open bilateral missions in Moscow and Rome came in 1989, when Mikhail Gobachev and Pope John Paul II met on the eve of the fall of the Berlin Wall. Moreover, there also have been several top-level bilateral meetings in the ensuing years: then-President Putin met twice with Pope John Paul II (in 2000 and 2003) and once with Pope Benedict XVI (2007). This was Medvedev's first meeting with the Pope. RUSSIAN AMBASSADOR OFFERS FRANK VIEWS ON CONTEXT FOR ANNOUNCEMENT -------------- -------------- -------------- ¶3. (C) On December 1, two days before the Medvedev-Benedict meeting, Ambassador Diaz met with Nikolay Sadchikov, the Russian Federation's Ambassador to the Holy See. Sadchikov foreshadowed -- but did not reveal -- the announcement on upgraded relations. Ambassador Sadchikov, who is battling cancer and has played a low profile on the diplomatic circuit during his treatment, also was unusually frank in his discussion of Russian domestic politics, how they were affecting the Russian government's relations with the Orthodox Church, and how the relationship affected Russian Orthodox relations with the Catholic church. ¶4. (C) Specifically, Sadchikov discussed internal Russian financial projections for 2009 and 2010, saying the Russian government believes next year is going to be much worse than this year due to the global financial crisis. Russian authorities are concerned about internal stability and popular unrest in 2010. Therefore, he confided, Russian authorities are trying to stimulate a "renaissance" of the Russian Orthodox Church as a vehicle to create hope among ordinary Russians and forestall instability in the coming year. Sadchikov said he found this tactic odd given the extremely low numbers of Russian faithful. ¶5. (C) Continuing with his uncharacteristic confidences, Sadchikov directly blamed immigrants (especially Muslims from the Caucuses) for internal government corruption in Russia and for the growth of organized crime. He implied that this is a pervasive view in the GOR. The Russian Ambassador said that "250,000 of the richest Georgians live in Moscow," and that something must be done about the immigrants in Russia. VATICAN 00000126 002.2 OF 003 Sadchikov believes that Muslims only respond to force and spoke admiringly about the Swiss decision to ban minaret construction. ¶6. (C) Although Sadchikov was aware of the then-imminent decision to upgrade Russian-Vatican relations, he dismissed that possibility. Sadchidov said there are no plans in Moscow for the meeting the Vatican has pursued actively for years: one between the Pope and the Russian Orthodox Patriarch. Such a meeting "is not a priority now," according to Sadchikov, but the Russian government would be open to a meeting between Kirill and Benedict later (though not in Moscow). (Note: Vatican officials have privately dismissed unsolicited offers by President Lukashenka of Belarus to "mediate" a meeting with the Russian Patriarch (ref. B),as have Russian-Orthodox representatives. End note.) ¶7. (C) Indeed, Sadchikov confessed, he himself had intentionally maintained a low profile at the Vatican at the request of the now-deceased Patriarch Alexy II. (Note: The former Patriarch, Alexy II , was unwilling to meet the Pope and was not a supporter of ecumenical dialogue. End Note) Sadchikov described his job as "doing basically nothing," citing the extremely small amount of Catholics in Russia and Orthodox suspicions about Catholic proselytizing there. Sadchikov also disparaged the sole Catholic charity in Russia, essentially accusing it of being a front for government corruption. He said the tiny organization receives 100,000 euro per year from the Russian government for "operating costs." COMMENT: WHY NOW? -------------- ¶8. (C) Comment: The decision to upgrade diplomatic relations appears to have had very different motivations on each side. If -- like Gorbachev twenty years earlier -- Medvedev is looking at using organized religion to help Russia confront its many social problems, the Pope will not let this opportunity pass him by. Warmer Roman Catholic-Russian Orthodox dialogue allows the Vatican and Russia to establish full diplomatic relations without offending Russian Orthodox sensitivities or interfering with promoting unity among all Christians -- one of the Vatican's highest goals. In this new context, full diplomatic relations with Russia are a no-brainer for the Vatican. ¶9. (C) The Russians -- or in this case, the Russian -- may have reached the decision to upgrade relations for a different reason. According to knowledgeable observers (a Polish diplomat and a priest who has served in the Pontifical Council for Christian Unity for years),Medvedev's decision had little to do with Russian-Vatican relations and almost everything to do with internal Russian politics. The Russian President (and his wife, who came to Rome earlier this year to inaugurate a new Russian Orthodox cathedral) wants to distance himself in the view of Russian voters from the traditional Soviet atheism of his former mentor, Putin. This is particularly true now that both men may be competing for the Russian Presidency in 2012. At the same time, the move to upgrade relations with the Vatican shows Medvedev to be a more "Westernized" and modern leader outside Russia, boosting his international credibility with little cost domestically. ¶10. (C) Whatever the motives for the upgraded relations, the reality on the ground in Rome (and probably Russia) is unlikely to change much. Both states already had full missions in each other's capitals that basically operated like full embassies. The lack of a formal embassy or nunciature clearly did not make it impossible for Russian secular leaders to see the Pope, or vice versa. While it is possible that the semantic change in relations could eventually ease a meeting between a Pope and a Russian Patriarch, such a meeting is is unlikely to occur in the near future. End Comment. ¶11. (C) Bio Note: Ambassador Sadchikov has served for 40 years in Russia's diplomatic corps, and was previously the USSR's VATICAN 00000126 003.2 OF 003 Counsel General to the UN. He also served as Russia's Ambassador to Sweden. During prior contacts with Embassy officials, the Ambassador has been circumspect about his personal views. It may be that he opened up in his meeting with Ambassador Diaz as a result of increased fatalism due to his treatment for advanced cancer. If his health deteriorates further, he may need to be replaced as Ambassador. End Bio Note and Comment. DIAZ