Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
09THEHAGUE598
2009-10-05 07:42:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy The Hague
Cable title:
NETHERLANDS: COURT ORDERS TOP BITTORRENT SITE MININOVA TO
how-toVZCZCXRO1398 RR RUEHIK DE RUEHTC #0598 2780742 ZNR UUUUU ZZH R 050742Z OCT 09 FM AMEMBASSY THE HAGUE TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 3332 INFO RUEHAT/AMCONSUL AMSTERDAM 4265 RUCNMEM/EU MEMBER STATES COLLECTIVE RUCPDOC/DEPT OF COMMERCE WASHDC
UNCLAS THE HAGUE 000598
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EINT ECON KIPR NL
SUBJECT: NETHERLANDS: COURT ORDERS TOP BITTORRENT SITE MININOVA TO
REMOVE LINKS TO COPYRIGHT MATERIAL
UNCLAS THE HAGUE 000598
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EINT ECON KIPR NL
SUBJECT: NETHERLANDS: COURT ORDERS TOP BITTORRENT SITE MININOVA TO
REMOVE LINKS TO COPYRIGHT MATERIAL
1. (SBU) SUMMARY: A Dutch court has delivered another blow to
BitTorrent web-sites operating in the Netherlands. The decision
requires Mininova, reportedly the world's top BitTorrent site, to
remove links to copyright material or face stiff fines. Dutch
anti-piracy watchdog BREIN, which initiated the case, is pleased
with the ruling and the legal precedent set. END SUMMARY.
2. (U) The Utrecht District Court ruled on August 26 that the
Dutch-hosted BitTorrent site Mininova must remove links to all
copyright-protected material. According to the court, although the
site itself is not actually infringing copyright laws, it is helping
and encouraging others to do so. The court gave Mininova three
months to remove all the links from its site or face fines of 1.00
euro (USD 1.46) per link per day, up to a maximum penalty of 5
million euro (USD 7.3 million). The court also ordered Mininova to
ensure no new links to copyright-protected material are added to its
site.
3. (U) Mininova has until late November to decide whether to appeal
the decision. Erik Dubbelboer, Mininova's co-founder, reacted to
ruling in the press: "This means that we have to change our business
operations. What this change will be, we cannot tell yet, we have
to study the ruling in more detail. We are considering appealing."
4. (SBU) Tim Kuik, BREIN's director, told Econ Specialist the
court's ruling was exactly what his organization had hoped for. He
said Mininova has to remove all the links to content that "with
reasonable doubt contains copyright-protected material." BREIN has
also provided Mininova a title list of entertainment products
(films, games, music) currently being sold in the Netherlands.
Mininova has to investigate whether links on its site with similar
names contain copyright-protected material.
5. (SBU) Kuik added that the ruling was important because the court
held the BitTorrent operator itself responsible for searching links
on its site for illegal material. He said "it would be great if
this ruling could be an example for other countries, including the
United States." BREIN continues its battle against BitTorrent sites
and has sued The Pirate Bay in a case to be heard on October 8.
LEVIN
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EINT ECON KIPR NL
SUBJECT: NETHERLANDS: COURT ORDERS TOP BITTORRENT SITE MININOVA TO
REMOVE LINKS TO COPYRIGHT MATERIAL
1. (SBU) SUMMARY: A Dutch court has delivered another blow to
BitTorrent web-sites operating in the Netherlands. The decision
requires Mininova, reportedly the world's top BitTorrent site, to
remove links to copyright material or face stiff fines. Dutch
anti-piracy watchdog BREIN, which initiated the case, is pleased
with the ruling and the legal precedent set. END SUMMARY.
2. (U) The Utrecht District Court ruled on August 26 that the
Dutch-hosted BitTorrent site Mininova must remove links to all
copyright-protected material. According to the court, although the
site itself is not actually infringing copyright laws, it is helping
and encouraging others to do so. The court gave Mininova three
months to remove all the links from its site or face fines of 1.00
euro (USD 1.46) per link per day, up to a maximum penalty of 5
million euro (USD 7.3 million). The court also ordered Mininova to
ensure no new links to copyright-protected material are added to its
site.
3. (U) Mininova has until late November to decide whether to appeal
the decision. Erik Dubbelboer, Mininova's co-founder, reacted to
ruling in the press: "This means that we have to change our business
operations. What this change will be, we cannot tell yet, we have
to study the ruling in more detail. We are considering appealing."
4. (SBU) Tim Kuik, BREIN's director, told Econ Specialist the
court's ruling was exactly what his organization had hoped for. He
said Mininova has to remove all the links to content that "with
reasonable doubt contains copyright-protected material." BREIN has
also provided Mininova a title list of entertainment products
(films, games, music) currently being sold in the Netherlands.
Mininova has to investigate whether links on its site with similar
names contain copyright-protected material.
5. (SBU) Kuik added that the ruling was important because the court
held the BitTorrent operator itself responsible for searching links
on its site for illegal material. He said "it would be great if
this ruling could be an example for other countries, including the
United States." BREIN continues its battle against BitTorrent sites
and has sued The Pirate Bay in a case to be heard on October 8.
LEVIN