Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
09STOCKHOLM701
2009-11-09 06:15:00
UNCLASSIFIED
Embassy Stockholm
Cable title:  

SWEDISH BANKING SECTOR STABLE, BUT CHALLENGES REMAIN

Tags:  EFIN PREL ECON SW 
pdf how-to read a cable
VZCZCXRO2889
PP RUEHIK
DE RUEHSM #0701/01 3130615
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
P 090615Z NOV 09
FM AMEMBASSY STOCKHOLM
TO RUEATRS/DEPT OF TREASURY WASHDC PRIORITY
RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 4861
INFO RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 03 STOCKHOLM 000701 

TREASURY FOR DAVID WRIGHT

USEU FOR MATT HAARSAGER

SIPDIS

C O R R E C T E D C O P Y (clarification in para 6.)

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EFIN PREL ECON SW
SUBJECT: SWEDISH BANKING SECTOR STABLE, BUT CHALLENGES REMAIN

STOCKHOLM 00000701 001.2 OF 003




UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 03 STOCKHOLM 000701

TREASURY FOR DAVID WRIGHT

USEU FOR MATT HAARSAGER

SIPDIS

C O R R E C T E D C O P Y (clarification in para 6.)

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EFIN PREL ECON SW
SUBJECT: SWEDISH BANKING SECTOR STABLE, BUT CHALLENGES REMAIN

STOCKHOLM 00000701 001.2 OF 003





1. Summary: All four major Swedish banks continued to see
deteriorations to their credit portfolios in the third quarter
primarily as a result of exposure to the Baltic region and Ukraine,
but signs of improvement appeared in the form of decelerating credit
losses. Market commentators continued to express confidence in the
stability of the Swedish banking sector, but also noted that
significant challenges remain in the form of sizeable credit losses.
Swedbank and SEB especially remain at the risk of accelerating
credit losses as a result currency devaluation in the Baltic region.
With its decision to keep the benchmark rate flat and extend
additional loans, the central bank recognized that the situation on
financial markets, while much improved, has not returned to
pre-crisis levels. Amid concerns of a housing bubble, the Central
Bank Governor has warned that rising housing prices are not
sustainable, and called on households and banks to plan for interest
rates to rise over the long run. End Summary

Swedbank Losses Up but Credit Losses Decelerate
-------------- -------------- --------------

2. Swedbank on 20 October was the first to report third quarter
results, which included a before tax loss of SEK 2.582 billion
($369.1 million),an increase of SEK 733 million ($104.8 million)in
losses from the previous quarter primarily due to continued large
loan loss provisions in the Ukraine, Latvia, and Lithuania. The loss
is in stark contrast to the SEK 3.113 ($445.1 million) in profits
from a year ago. Despite the worse than expected loss, Swedbank's
CEO Michael Wolf expressed optimism as credit losses in the Baltic
region are no longer worsening at the same pace as before. Credit
losses in the Baltic region decreased from net SEK 4.0 billion ($572
million) in the second quarter to SEK 3.3 billion ($469 million).
Latvia registered the highest ratio of impaired loans at 19.74
percent, followed by Lithuania (12.33 percent),and Estonia (6.42
percent). According to reports in Stockholm Daily Svenska Dagbladet,
Swedbank expects to seize and administer property in the Baltic
region worth SEK 5 - 15 billion ($0.715 - 2.145 billion) between now

and 2011 through its newly formed Swedbank subsidiary Ektornet.
Swedebank's year-to-date loan losses in the Baltic region amount to
SEK 11.5 billion ($1.6 billion) and gross total impaired loans
amounted to SEK 26 billion ($3.72 billion) vs. SEK 7 billion ($1
billion) at the end of 2008.


3. Swedbank's share of impaired loans in Ukraine increased to 43
percent as of 30 September, compared with 5 per cent at the start of
the year as a result of a large depreciation of the Ukrainian
currency increasing the loan payment burden for many Ukrainians with
foreign currency denominated loans. Impaired losses stood at SEK 6.2
billion ($887 million) since the beginning of 2009 until September.


4. Swedbank continues to profit from its Swedish operations.
Working profits increased by 8 percent to SEK 2 billion ($268
million) in comparison to the same period last year. Another
positive improvement is the decrease in the share of impaired loans
in Sweden from 0.23 percent in the second quarter to 0.05 percent in
the third quarter.

SEB Bottom Line Improves but Falls Short of Last Year
-------------- --------------

5. Rival SEB's third quarter report revealed a plummeting operating
profit and continued provisions for credit losses, primarily in the
Baltic region and Russia. Operating profit in the third quarter
plummeted by 85 percent compared to the previous year, but after tax
the profit margin improved from a second quarter loss of SEK 174
million($24.9 million),primarily the result of SEK 2.394 billion
($340.9 million) in impairment charges related to SEB's investments
in Eastern Europe, to SEK 37 million ($5.3 million). Lithuania is
currently the largest risk country for SEB, its credit losses there
total almost SEK 1.5 billion ($213.6 million) whereas credit losses
in Latvia and Estonia combined only total SEK 1.15 billion ($163.9
million). Provisions for the Baltic region amounted to SEK 2.642
billion ($376.7 million) or 79 percent of the group's total. Credit
loss provision continued to increase in Lithuania and Latvia, but
have decreased in Estonia in comparison to the previous quarter.
SEB's CEO Annika Falkengren also announced that SEB will not apply
for an extension of the state guarantee program, which is to end on
31 October) and stressed that SEB has not previously taken advantage
of the program.

Nordea and Handelsbanken Beat Expectations
--------------

6. Nordea and Handelsbanken reported better than expected results
due to a jump in earnings from basic lending operations and lower
loan loss provisions despite registering shrinking profit margins.
Nordea's operating profit of EUR 832 million ($1.236 billion) was up
by 2 percent, but down by 2 percent when compared to the same period

STOCKHOLM 00000701 002.2 OF 003


last year. Impaired loans, mainly related to Denmark and the Baltic
region, increased to EUR 3.851 billion ($5.721 billion),up by 9
percent compared to the second quarter, but showed signs of
stabilization. In the two previous quarters, the increases were 19%
and 33% respectively. The provisioning ratio increased from 49
percent in the second quarter to 51 percent. In the Baltic
countries, gross impaired loans amounted to EUR 522 million ($776
million) or 7.05 percent of total loans, compared with EUR 418
million ($621.4 million) or 5.5 percent at the end of the second
quarter. The increase in impaired loans was 25 percent from the
previous quarter, compared to a growth rate in the second quarter of
63 percent. Handelsbanken reported an operating profit of SEK 3.255
billion ($464.3 million) down by 6 percent compared to the second
quarter and 13 percent when compared to the same period in the
previous year. With zero exposure to the Baltic region or Ukraine,
the level of impaired loans decreased from SEK 4.385 billion ($625.1
million) in the second quarter to SEK 3.710 billion ($528.9 million)
in the third quarter or 0.24 percent of all lending. Overall loan
losses increased in all of Handelsbanken's areas of operation,
except for Finland, with the most dramatic increase in the UK.

Market and Media Reactions
-------------- --------------

7. The banks' third quarter results caused mixed reactions in the
stock market. While Swedbank's stock remained unchanged following
the announcement of the loss and Nordea's increased by 2.8 percent,
SEB and Handelsbanken's stock lost 4 percent and 4.3 percent,
respectively, on the day of the announcement. Since the beginning
of the year, stocks of the four banks, however, have well
outperformed the OMX Nordic 40 index that tracks the 40 largest and
most actively traded stocks on the Nordic exchange. Year-to-date
figures also suggest investor confidence in the banks' future
position in the Nordic market; their stock price increased by at
least 42 percent (SEB),with Nordea registering the largest gain
with 73 percent.


8. Several commentators pointed out that Swedbank's situation is
much better now than at the beginning of the year. The bank is well
capitalized, and the trend of increasing credit losses seems to have
been broken. The report was further positively received as it tells
about the very low level of credit losses in the Swedish operations.
This further reinforces the message that the banks have tried to
convey, that the banks have managed to handle credit losses much
better this time than they did during the previous, domestic,
banking crisis in the early nineties. Jan Almgren, Columnist and
analyst at Stockholm Daily adopts a more cautious approach
summarizing Swedbank's report "as bad as expected and then some".
Although not all results were worse than expected he advises against
premature celebrations, with 7 billion in losses this year alone,
"Swedbank has a long and winding road ahead" Almgren writes.
Overall, as the Swedbank report is published only days after
Swedbank's Estonian pension-scandals, the general view among
analysts and media reports is that Swedbank has now hit bottom.


9. SEB's results have been less anticipated because it has generally
performed better than Swedbank and has a smaller exposure to the
Baltic region. According to Andreas Cervenka at SVD "the 'Wallenberg
bank' stands on solid ground." Considerations of employee bonuses,
however, are likely to draw widespread criticism in the future as
the bank will have the opportunity to again reinstate the bonus
system once it sheds the state guarantee program. Already talks of
raising the CEO's salary as a result of her giving up her bonus
earlier this year caused quite a stir. Currently SEB has allocated
SEK 1.5 billion to employee bonuses.

Riskbank Keeps Rates Flat, Provides Additional Liquidity
--------------

10. Sweden's central bank, the Riksbank, on 23 October kept the
benchmark interest rate (repo) unchanged at 0.25 percent and
announced its decision to extend new loans amounting to SEK 100
billion ($14.7 billion) to the country's banks to ensure sufficient
liquidity in the market. (The loan auction was held on November 2
and the final amount lent was SEK 95.3 billion.) The loans are at a
fixed interest rate and with a maturity of 11 months and "should
contribute to continued lower interest rates on loans to companies
and households," the Riksbank said. The central bank justified its
decision by noting that while the situation on financial markets was
much improved, it had not yet returned to pre-crisis levels. On
November 5, Riksbank Governor Stefan Ingves told the Parliament
Finance Committee that the Riksbank currently expected to hold the
repo rate unchanged at a low level until autumn 2010 in order to
contribute to a stable economic recovery and attain the inflation
target of 2 percent.


11. Reactions to the Riksbank decision have been mixed. The
decision to keep the interest rate at 0.25 percent was expected but

STOCKHOLM 00000701 003.2 OF 003


most analysts were surprised by the loan offer. Nordea's chief
economist Annika Winsth calls the action both "unexpected and
unnecessary". Cecilia Skingsley, Chief analyst at Swedbank, is also
surprised but maintains that a new loan always was a possibility.
All leading Swedish banks believe that the benchmark interest rate
will be raised sooner than the Riksbank projection of 4th quarter of

2010.

A housing bubble in the making?
--------------

12. Much speculation in Sweden surrounds whether a housing bubble is
in the making. With an interest rate of close to zero percent both
demand and prices are up. Mortgage applications are up 15 percent
for condominiums and 8 percent for houses compared to the same
period in 2008. Even the Riksbank noted in its report that the
current housing-prices are "above a level that is sustainable in the
long-term." In his speech to the Parliamentary Committee on Finance,
Ingves explained that the Riksbank cannot adapt monetary policy on
the basis of individual markets unless they threaten the inflation
target or financial stability. Ingves reiterated that it is "hardly
sustainable" for housing prices to continue their rise of around 8
percent a year since 1996. Since lending and housing prices are
largely beyond the Riksbank control, he said, it is important for
households to make realistic calculations, and banks to make
responsible credit assessments since interest rates will rise in the
long-run. He noted that the Swedish Financial Supervisory Authority
"is prepared to take action if they consider it necessary."

Comment
--------------

13. Although Baltic investments remain a problem for Swedbank and
SEB, there is little fear in Sweden that their losses there will
significantly affect the Swedish market. The fact that Swedbank's
total losses were larger than expected was viewed as less important
than the decelerating trend in expected credit losses, offering hope
that the worst could be over in the troubled Baltic region. Both
Swedbank and SEB have lifted their core tier one capital ratio to
12.3 percent and 11.8 percent, respectively,--among the highest in
Europe, and have the backing of the state guarantee program if
necessary.


14. The staggering absolute level of losses in Eastern European
operations, however, could require recapitalization of subsidiaries
in the future. Political risks in Latvia and Ukraine, combined with
a sharp economic downturn, remain high and credit losses could
quickly accelerate if Latvia is forced to devalue. While Swedbank's
chief risk officer, Goran Bronner, sought to reassure investors and
shareholders that the bank could absorb a 15 percent controlled
devaluation in Latvia, a larger devaluation combined with investor
concern about the Baltic region as a whole-a devaluation in Latvia
would put pressure on neighboring Estonia and Lithuania to
devalue-could result in a confidence crisis and a setback for the
recovery of the Swedish banking sector. End comment.

BARZUN