RECONFIGURED MINISTERIAL CLUSTERS LEAD TO

C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 PRETORIA 002169 SIPDIS DEPARTMENT PASS USTR FOR BILL JACKSON, DEPARTMENT PASS USTR FOR JED DIEMOND E.O. 12958: DECL: 10/22/2019 TAGS: PGOV SF ECON EFIN EINV SUBJECT: RECONFIGURED MINISTERIAL CLUSTERS LEAD TO QUESTIONS, FEW ANSWERS REF: PRETORIA 2142 PRETORIA 00002169 001.2 OF 003 Classified By: Political Counselor Walter N.S. Pflaumer for reasons 1.4 (b) and (d). - - - - Summary - - - - ¶1. (C) The South African Government on October 19 announced plans to reconfigure ministerial clusters (committees within the Cabinet intended to improve coordination within government). The announcement set off immediate speculation by political analysts and economists over whether the reconfiguration was meant to placate the powerful Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU),which in recent weeks has been increasingly critical of the continued influence of Minister in the Presidency for National Planning Trevor Manuel, and of some of the macroeconomic policies he implemented while serving as Finance Minister in the Mbeki administration. The fact that the realligment of the clusters occasioned the resignation of Joel Netshitenzhe, the long-serving Director-General of Policy and Coordination Services in the Presidency (see reftel) added fuel to the speculation. While we believe President Zuma is engaged in some delicate balancing of the competing parts of his political base, we also think the speculation about the significance of this reallignment is somewhat overblown. Despite the government's decision to place Manuel's ministry in the cluster including Infrastructure Development -- and not in the cluster covering Economic Sectors and Employment -- there is little indication that the largely administrative decision to reconfigure the ministerial clusters is a demotion for Manuel or a move away from many of the government's current economic policies. Next week's budget speech should provide a clearer signal of the Zuma government's economic direction. End Summary. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Government Reconfigures Ministerial Clusters - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ¶2. (SBU) The South African Government is reconfiguring its ministerial clusters, which for several years have been Cabinet-level working groups where policies are discussed and coordinated. The new clusters include: Infrastructure Development; Economic Sectors and Employment; Human Development, Social Protection and Community Development; International Cooperation, Trade and Security; Governance and Security; and Justice, Crime Prevention, and Security. Each government ministry will be a part of one or more cluster and will be chaired by a member of Cabinet. Below is how the clusters will be structured: -- The Infrastructure Development cluster includes the ministries for Communications, Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Economic Development, Energy, Finance, Human Settlements, Public Enterprises, Public Works, the Presidency's National Planning Commission, Transport, and Water and Environmental Affairs. Transport Minister Sibusiso Ndebele will be the cluster's chair and Public Enterprises Minister Barbara Hogan will be deputy chair. -- The Economic Sectors and Employment cluster includes the ministries for Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, Communications, Economic Development, Finance, Higher Education, Labor, Mineral Resources, Public Enterprises, QEducation, Labor, Mineral Resources, Public Enterprises, Rural Development and Land Reform, Science and Technology, Tourism, and Trade and Industry. Rural Development and Land Reform Minister Gugile Nkwinti will be the cluster's chair and Science and Technology Minister Naledi Pandor will be the deputy. -- The Human Development, Social Protection and Community Development cluster includes the ministries for Arts and Culture, Basic Education, Health, Higher Education, Labor, Science and Technology, and Sports and Recreation. Basic Education Minister Angie Motshekga will chair the cluster and Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi will be her deputy. PRETORIA 00002169 002.2 OF 003 -- The Social Protection and Community Development cluster includes the ministries for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Water and Environmental Affairs, Human Settlements, Labor, Public Works, Rural Development and Land Affairs, Social Development, Transport, and Women, Youth, Children, and People with Disabilities. Social Development Minister Edna Molewa will chair the cluster and Public Works Minister Geoff Doidge will be deputy chair. -- The International Cooperation, Trade and Security cluster includes the ministries for Defense and Military Veterans, International Relations and Cooperation, Finance, State Security, Tourism, Trade and Industry, and Water and Environmental Affairs. Defense and Military Veterans Minister Lindiwe Sisulu will chair the cluster and International Relations and Cooperation Minister Maite Nkoana-Mashabane will be her deputy. -- The Governance and Security cluster includes the ministries for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Home Affairs, Justice and Constitutional Development, Finance, Public Service and Administration, and the Presidency's Performance Monitoring and Evaluation. Home Affairs Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma will serve as chair and Public Service and Administration Minister Richard Baloyi will be her deputy. -- The Crime Prevention, and Security cluster includes the ministries for Correctional Services, Defense, Home Affairs, Justice and Constitutional Development, Police, and State Security. Justice and Constitutional Development Minister Jeff Radebe will chair this cluster and Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa will be his deputy. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Reconfiguration Sparks Speculation About Who Benefits from Changes - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ¶3. (C) The reconfiguration, which comes following weeks of public criticism from COSATU that Manuel has too much authority in the Zuma administration, has led to speculation that the government wants to placate its pro-labor and communist supporters. A Business Report editorial suggested that Manuel's absence from the Economic Sectors and Employment means Zuma and the African National Congress believe he has "nothing to contribute on unemployment." The editorial also noted that the realignment of clusters might just be a convenient way of ensuring that conflicts do not arise between those seen as loyal to former President Mbeki (such as Manuel) and those who came into government under Zuma (such as Economic Development Minister Ebrahim Patel). By contrast, Business Day penned an editorial on October 21 that argued Zuma used the new cluster structure to send a message to the pro-labor, communist sides of the ruling tripartite alliance that they are not in charge. Although COSATU-backed Patel will sit in on the Economic Sectors and Employment cluster, he is not the chair. Moreover, Zuma selected Motshekga to chair the human development cluster over Higher Education Minister, and South African Communist Party Secretary General, Blade Nzimande. The editorial also pointed out that Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan sits on four Qpointed out that Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan sits on four clusters while Patel only sits on two, suggesting that Gordhan, not Patel, will be the main player on economic policy. Interestingly, both editorials questioned whether "new and more logical structures will in themselves make government more effective." The Business Day editorial pointed out that "function does not necessarily follow form." - - - - Comment - - - - ¶4. (C) Following Zuma's election to the presidency in May, he did a major reorganization of ministries and departments. The reconfiguration of the ministerial clusters is in part an extension of those earlier changes. After all, ministries PRETORIA 00002169 003.2 OF 003 such as the one for Women, Youth, Children, and People with Disabilities did not even exist seven months ago. Clearly Zuma and his team were careful about how they established the clusters, just as they were when naming the Cabinet. The South African leader is doing a delicate balancing act to keep both the pro-labor and the pro-business sides of the alliance happy with his leadership. How successful this balancing act is remains to be seen. ¶5. (C) We believe, however, that many pundits are reading too much into this decision, and that all the Manuel vs. Patel entrail-parsing is a bit over the top. We note that Patel still only has a staff of seven or eight and some borrowed office space. There is also no evidence that the cluster realignment represents a demotion for Manuel or that his "National Strategic Planning" paper (often referred to here as the "Green Paper") is going away because of COSATU's opposition. Moreover, we believe that Finance Minister Gordhan's budget speech next week will provide a far more important indicator of the Zuma government's economic policies. End comment. GIPS