PERSISTENT ABUSES IN REFUGEE SYSTEM PROVOKE

C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 OTTAWA 000348 SIPDIS STATE FOR WHA/CAN, PRM, AND CA E.O. 12958: DECL: 05/12/2019 TAGS: PREF PGOV PREL SMIG CVIS KFRD MX EZ CA SUBJECT: PERSISTENT ABUSES IN REFUGEE SYSTEM PROVOKE GOVERNMENTAL CONCERN REF: A. 08 OTTAWA 774 ¶B. 08 OTTAWA 645 Classified By: PolMinCouns Scott Bellard, reasons 1.4 (b) and (d) ¶1. (C) Summary. Canada is increasingly concerned about "wide-scale and almost systematic abuse" of its generous immigration, citizenship, and refugee policies. According to a recent report by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR),the number of asylum seekers to Canada in 2008 increased by thirty pct. Mexicans are the largest group of asylum claimants, but the government rejects over 90 pct of their claims. Canada is reportedly considering re-imposing visa requirements on Mexican visitors. Canada has also seen a surge in Czech refugee claimants since abolishing visa requirements for Czech visitors, many of whom are reportedly members of the Roma minority. Absent specific reforms, however, the flow of refugees and asylum seekers -- false as well as genuine -- is apt to continue unabated for the foreseeable future, as neither major political party will want to alienate voters in immigrant communities in advance of a probable federal election over the next year. End summary. EVERY TENTH ASYLUM APPLICATION IN THE INDUSTRIALIZED WORLD -------------- -------------- ¶2. (U) Citizenship and Immigration Minister Jason Kenney has repeatedly spoken of "wide-scale and almost systematic abuse" of Canada's refugee system. A recently released UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) report -- based on Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) data -- showed that the number of asylum seekers in Canada had increased by thirty pct, to 36,900 claims in 2008. (Note: In 2007, there were 28,340 claims; 22,910 in 2006; and, 19,740 in 2005 -- reftels. End note). In 2008, Canada was the second highest refugee receiving country in the industrialized world, after the United States. Canada accounts for every tenth asylum application filed worldwide. Between 2004-2008, 133,390 refugee claims were filed in Canada. A refugee claim can be made at either a port of entry or a CIC inland office. ¶3. (U) The 2008 Canadian increase in asylum claims stems primarily from Mexicans ( 33 pct),Haitians ( 31 pct),and Colombians ( 19 pct). In 2008, the top ten nationalities of asylum applicants in Canada were: -- Mexico (9,413 claims); ;-- Haiti (4,247); -- Colombia (3,069); -- United States (2,308); -- China (1,476); -- Sri Lanka (1,000); -- Czech Republic (818); -- Nigeria (765); -- India (674); and, -- El Salvador (603). ¶4. (U) Critics of Canada's refugee processing system have noted that there were more claims from the U.S. and Czech Republic than from Somalia (441),Democratic Republic of Congo (437),Afghanistan (408),or Pakistan (368). The majority of claims by U.S. citizens were from children of illegal U.S. immigrants, however (ref a). A BACKLOGGED ADJUDICATION PROCESS -------------- ¶5. (U) Minister Kenney has requested that the House of Q5. (U) Minister Kenney has requested that the House of Commons' immigration committee and opposition political parties begin a "dialogue" on ways to reform Canada's in-country refugee procedures in order to ensure that fraudulent claimants face expeditious deportation. The Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB),which has an estimated backlog of 65,000 cases, evaluates asylum applications. Processing times can often take up to two years, during which time applicants can receive social and medical benefits as well as legal assistance. Rejected applicants benefit from a lengthy adjudication process that allows multiple appeals. OTTAWA 00000348 002 OF 003 ¶6. (SBU) According to immigration experts, the number of IRB members has decreased from around 220 in 2004 to 164 now. Even with all its vacancies filled, the IRB would only be able to adjudicate around 25,000 applications per year, leaving an ever-growing case backlog. Minister Kenney has publicly stated that he has no plans to increase the IRB's size or funding, however, insisting that Canada should instead "find more expeditious ways to process false claims and to remove people from the country" rather than dedicating "unlimited increases in funding for processing when the majority of claimants are abusing our system and generosity." The IRB approval rate has reportedly ranged from 42-48 pct in recent years. In 2008, the IRB approved 7,554 refugee and asylum claims. UNHCR and other referral organizations as well as private sponsors referred more than 11,000 additional asylum claimants to Canada for resettlement. VISA REQUIREMENTS FOR MEXICAN VISITORS? -------------- ¶7. (C) Immigration advocates have referred to Mexico as "the elephant in the room" when it comes to discussions of reforming Canada's refugee system. CIC contacts told a U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) representative in Ottawa that the federal government might re-impose visa requirements for Mexican visitors. According to these contacts, Canada initially considered citing the H1N1 virus as a public pretext for the new measures, before backing away from that justification. The contacts added that senior CIC officials are also concerned that current Canadian consular resources in Mexico are inadequate to implement such visa requirements. UPSURGE IN CZECH ROMA REFUGEE CLAIMS -------------- ¶8. (SBU) In mid-April, Minister Kenney called on the Czech government to crack down on unscrupulous for-profit "operators" and "consultants" believed to be responsible for a surge in the number of Czech refugee claimants arriving at Canadian airports. This surge began in late 2007, when Canada lifted visa requirements for Czech visitors, and is reportedly due mainly application from members of the Roma community. The 818 Czech nationals seeking protection in 2008 marked a 993 pct increase from 2007. In 2008, 84 Czech claims were accepted, 96 withdrawn, 11 abandoned, and only 5 rejected. (Note: There were no claims from Czech citizens in 2006. End note.) Minister Kenney stated that "we would like to maintain our visa exemption with the Czech Republic. At the same time, we are obviously concerned about the numbers of false refugee claimants." Kenney added that, while Canada had also waived visa requirements for seven other Eastern European countries in 2007-2008 (including some with significant Roma minorities),no other waivers had resulted in increases in refugee claims. ¶9. (SBU) During his May 6 visit to Prague for the Canada-European Union Summit, Prime Minister Harper publicly QCanada-European Union Summit, Prime Minister Harper publicly expressed concern over the surge in refugee claims by Czech citizens, stating that "unless there is improvement, the government of Canada will have to take some actions." Czech Prime Minister Mirek Toplanek responded that Canada's "very soft" refugee system was to blame, noting that "it's very easy to get asylum in Canada, and for that reason it is being targeted by individuals who seek economic (gain)." ¶10. (C) Comment: Absent so far from the policy discussion of these abuses are concrete proposals for improvements, apart from possible but still unlikely revocation of visa waivers. The ruling Conservative Party has used such exemptions in part as a domestic political tool to court immigrant communities, which have traditionally been more apt to vote for the Liberal Party once they become citizens. Toughening the system across the board, or even targeting Mexican and Czech populations, will face stiff resistance from Canada's well organized refugee rights lobbying groups, including the Canadian Council on Refugees (CCR),which OTTAWA 00000348 003 OF 003 claims to represent more than 180 organizations (many of which are publicly subsidized). The Conservatives also are unlikely to win support from the Liberal Party, as it seeks to rebuild its base under new leader Michael Ignatieff, with eyes on the next federal election, probably within the next year. For the foreseeable future, the flow of refugees and asylum seekers -- false as well as genuine -- is apt to continue unabated. Visit Canada,s North American partnership community at http://www.intelink.gov/communities/state/nap / BREESE