OIC'S 36TH MINISTERIAL CONVENES IN DAMASCUS:

C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 DAMASCUS 000375 SIPDIS DEPARTMENT FOR NEA/IPA, NEA/ELA NSC FOR SHAPIRO/MCDERMOTT LONDON FOR TSOU, PARIS FOR WALLER E.O. 12958: DECL: 05/25/2019 TAGS: PREL KPAL IS SY SUBJECT: OIC'S 36TH MINISTERIAL CONVENES IN DAMASCUS: TERRORISM, ISLAMOPHOBIA AND ISRAEL Classified By: A/DCM Raymond Maxwell for reasons 1.4(b,d) ¶1. (U) Summary: Syria played host to the 36th meeting of the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) ministerial meeting May 23-25. As in past sessions, the ministers focused on issues related to the Arab-Israeli conflict, combating "Islamophobia" and terrorism, the potential for OIC peacekeeping operations, and increasing the Organization's capacity tackle heath issues throughout the Islamic world. All 57 member states dispatched delegations to the conference, though Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Abul Gheit and Qatari Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Ahmed Al-Mahmoud were noticeably absent from the conference; notable attendees included Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottako. Of particular interest, the Saudi delegation proposed a resolution urging OIC member countries to recognize the independence of Kosovo, but the language in the final report fell far short of recognition. The final report also made a point to "express surprise" at the renewal of U.S. sanctions on Syria and called for the Syria Accountability Act to be repealed. President Bashar al-Asad's opening statement took square aim at Israel and the West, blaming Israeli intransigence and Western "denial of the facts" for the current impasse in Arab-Israeli peace negotiations. He exhorted Islamic countries to maintain a strong front in the face of (Western) attacks on Islamic identity, including efforts to equate Islam with terrorism. He urged Muslims to put substance over form in defending their religion and took them to task for not meeting the requirements of the faith, in particular for failing to maintain the unity of the ummah (community of believers). End Summary. ¶2. (U) Under the banner "Towards Promoting Islamic Solidarity," Secretary General Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu presided over the 36th annual ministerial meeting of the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) from May 23-25 in Damascus. Issues ranging from the current status of the peace process in the Middle East to addressing arrears of member states were among the over 70 topics set for discussion on the ambitious agenda. Though Ihsanoglu's opening remarks generally stayed clear of sensitive political issues, he did speak about the "Judaization" of Jerusalem saying, "The city of Al Quds (Jerusalem) and the Holy Mosque of Al Aqsa are also facing an unprecedented vicious attack with the aim of Judaizing them and fully obliterating their Arab-Islamic identity." He then went on to address the situation in Gaza which he decried as "Israeli aggression which included war crimes and the use of internationally prohibited weapons." He added that it was incumbent upon the group assembled to "ensure that the perpetrators of those crimes be brought to justice before the relevant international courts." -------------- ASAD'S REMARKS -------------- ¶3. (U) Syrian President Bashar al-Asad delivered the key-note address as host. His lengthy speech hit on several main themes: the current impasse over Arab-Israeli peace negotiations - with particular blame on Israel and the West, the right of resistance, combating terrorism, the rise of "Islamophobia," and the Muslim world's failure to adhere to the tenants of the faith, with particular focus on the inability of the Muslim world to maintain the unity of the ummah (community of believers). -------------- ISRAEL - NO PARTNER IN PEACE -------------- ¶4. (U) On Israel, Asad said, "We are not talking only about six decades of occupation, but also about seventeen years since the launch of the peace talks in Madrid which led to nothing but harming peace and making it more difficult to achieve." He noted that all of these failed efforts have only served to "expose" and "reveal" the truth of Israel to the world. "This state," he said, "has for decades portrayed itself as an innocent 'lamb' which wants peace with the 'wolves' surrounding it, including the original Palestinian owners of the land. But the failure of this process up till now has starkly shown that Israel is the greatest obstacle to peace." Exhorting the right of resistance, Asad went on to DAMASCUS 00000375 002 OF 003 add, "Today, too, after another experience with Israel, and after the indirect talks through Turkey, this truth has been proven once again, which leads to another truth: Political failure to restore legitimate rights to their owners will give resistance the right to carry out its duty and restore them." Asad questioned how Israel could be a partner for peace while it has "always hindered, implicitly and explicitly, the possibility of reaching any agreement during the whole span of the peace process" and "while it is founded on illegitimate occupation, continuous killing of the indigenous Palestinian people carrying out massacres in Lebanon, the West Bank, and Gaza for decades." Speaking on the "racist segregation wall in the West Bank," the "slow death meted out on Gaza by imposing a blockade," and the "systematic Judization of Jerusalem," Asad said Israel's acts were nothing short of "ethnic cleansing." Asad suggested that any developments in the relationship with Israel must be linked to concrete steps on the part of Israel, including a commitment to a just and comprehensive peace, the return of the legitimate rights, and its withdrawal from the occupied territories in Palestine, the Golan Heights, and southern Lebanon. -------------- THE WEST IS TO BLAME, TOO -------------- ¶5. (U) Asad went on to add that the West, too, was responsible for the "turbulence" in the Middle East, saying, They (the West) used, for years, to deny the facts on the ground and adopted an inverted logic of accusing the resistance of terrorism and depicting them as outlawed gangs who do not belong to represent their people in their struggle against occupation." Taking a clear shot at Western accusations of human-rights abuses in Syria, Asad said, "Such states have further adopted the worst form of double standards when they preach sermons about human rights, but when these humans are Arabs or Muslims, death becomes the only right they defend or advocate." The West, he claimed, continued to deny the facts on the ground, "particularly the massive public support which resistance forces have in our region, making them the major elements in any solution and the most important guarantor of the return of rights to their owners." ¶6. (U) Asad noted that the current situation only creates "fertile ground for tension and extremism which breeds terrorism." He suggested that political security is achieved when pending political issues are solved, and by "instilling true faith and sound moral values, and promoting a culture of openness." Asad acknowledged that terrorism had become a "dangerous global phenomenon" but made a clear distinction between terrorism and resistance, saying the West was "mixing cards" with its rhetoric. He rejected "labeling any religion or culture with terrorism, as the situation is for Islam and Muslims." He added that Muslims also have a responsibility to "not confuse defending their religion with defending terrorism, or being committed to their faith and being stringent and fanatical. Confusing our affairs gives others a pretext to confuse them," he argued, "as when some people talk about 'Islamic terrorism.'" -------------- OK, WE BEAR SOME OF THE BLAME -------------- ¶7. (U) Taking his guests to task for not adhering to the teachings of Islam, Asad asked "how can we defend a religion whose obligations we fail to carry out?" He noted that "defending the form has become more important than defending the substance." At times Asad was uncharacteristically introspective in his remarks, saying "We should carry out an honest stock-taking exercise with ourselves," adding, "blaming others is merely an attempt at escaping a reality which we do not see and which we do not want to see." Finally, in what may be characterized as classic projection, Asad said, "we get rid of our inferiority complex when we see the results of our work, instead of compensating for the pride and arrogance towards others in order to have some fake feeling of superiority." ¶8. (U) Full remarks can be read at: http://www.oic.oci.org/36cfm/w/en/Sp-PRES-SYR IA.pdf DAMASCUS 00000375 003 OF 003 -------------- OIC NOTABLE TAKE-AWAYS -------------- ¶9. (U) On the margins of the conference the OIC and the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria signed a memorandum of understanding to enhance the cooperation between member states and to mobilize additional donors to support the Global Fund's program. The OIC Observatory on Islamophobia released its second annual report on what they described as an "unfortunate trend of Islamophobia," detailing causes and solutions for the international community to address. Additionally, a brainstorming session was held on the OIC's future role in maintaining peace and security, and resolving conflicts in member states. -------------- FINAL RESOLUTION -------------- ¶10. (U) The final resolution document contained a liberal helping of demands, condemnations and strong condemnations. In short, the document denounced Israeli practices against the Palestinians, affirmed the right to establish an independent Palestinian state, demanded a halt to construction of Israeli settlements, and called for a continued boycott of Israeli goods. The resolution fell far short of recognizing Kosovo, as called for by a Saudi amendment proposal, and merely reaffirmed the strong interest of the OIC regarding Muslims in the Balkans and took note of the progress made towards strengthening democracy in Kosovo. The final resolution also affirmed the sovereignty of Iraq and supported GOI efforts to preserve the country's security and stability. The ministers denounced linking terrorism with race and religion, and called for a U.N. sponsored conference to identify terrorism. They showed solidarity with Khartoum against "aggressive plots targeting the sovereignty of Sudan," and criticized the International Criminal Court's indictments of Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir. The final statement backed Yemen's unity, denounced recent attacks in Mogadishu, and called for a reactivation of Somalia's OIC membership. The draft resolution also expressed OIC members' concern about Israel's nuclear capabilities and demanded a Middle-East-zone free of nuclear arms. Finally, the resolution "expresses surprise" at the renewal of the sanctions against Syria by the U.S., "especially at a time when the U.S. is attempting to establish relations with Arabs and Muslims in the region," rejects the "so-called Accountability of Syria Bill" and requests the United States to reconsider this law. ¶11. (U) Full resolution on political issues can be read at: http://www.oic-oci.org/36cfm/w/en/res/36CFM-P OL-RES-FINAL.pdf ¶12. (U) The 37th meeting of the OIC ministerial conference will be held in Dushambe, the Republic of Tajikistan in 2010. The ministers expressed support for holding the 38th meeting in Astana, Republic of Kazakhstan in 2011. ¶13. (C) Comment: As an invited observer to the opening remarks it was not lost on us - nor perhaps on most in attendance - that Asad spoke as a Muslim himself, with a blithe disregard for how the Alawi sect is viewed by mainstream Muslims. Asad's attempt to shame fellow Muslims into supporting the failed policies of his state by invoking tenants of the Muslim faith will likely fall flat. Finally, Asad's continued public rhetoric in support of the "resistance" will make walking-back such remarks all the more difficult should the time come for an actual peace agreement. Worse yet, having uttered these kind of remarks enough, he may actually have grown to believe them. CONNELLY