COMMERCIAL LAW DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM (CLDP) ASSISTANCE TO

UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 BAGHDAD 001875 SENSITIVE SIPDIS DEPT FOR INL, NEA/I JUSTICE PASS TO PHIL LYNCH, ANDREW NORMAN E.O. 12958: N/A TAGS: IZ SUBJECT: COMMERCIAL LAW DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM (CLDP) ASSISTANCE TO COME TO IRAQ. ¶1. (U) SUMMARY: On his recent visit, Marc Tejtel, U.S. Department of Commerce Deputy Chief Counsel of the Commercial Law Development Program (CLDP),through discussions and cooperation with CLA, Treasury, ROLC, INL, ECON, and Iraqi officials, initiated project proposals for commercial capacity-building programs in multiple GoI institutions, to include the Higher Judicial Council (HJC),the National Investment Commission (NIC),the Iraqi Ministry of Trade (MOT),the Shura Council, and the Administrative Court. With increased awareness of the convergent interests of various Embassy sections and the interdependency of GOI competencies in contracting, arbitration, legislative drafting, and dispute resolution, CLDP's new Iraq presence holds promise to further Embassy objectives in growing a better foreign investment environment in Iraq. CLDP's activities also help to reinforce our capacity building efforts under the Economic and Energy, as well as the Law Enforcement and Judicial Cooperation Committees (JCC) of the Strategic Framework Agreement. END SUMMARY. BACKGROUND ¶2. (U) Commercial law practices were unpredictable in the prior regime; investments were barred under sanctions and for investors that engaged Iraq prior to 1990, contractual negotiations often fell through, obligations were sometimes not observed, and corrupt practices ensured minimal transparency. In this risky environment, investment and development were stymied, antiquated laws reflecting the needs of an inward-looking socialist system remained on the books, and the expertise of the judiciary in resolving international commercial law suits languished. Furthermore, although Iraq's current oil contracts contain several clauses referring disputes to international arbitration, Iraq still has yet to ratify the International Convention on the Enforcement and Recognition of International Arbitral awards. Failure to ratify this Convention, compounded by the lack of judicial capacity in resolving commercial disputes, poses a serious impediment to investment. ¶3. (U) CLDP has various initiatives throughout the world, including commercial law modernization and judicial capacity building in Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, the UAE, and Yemen. The program has enabled the development of international arbitration procedures in ;Tunisia, Intellectual Property Law development in Manila, fair trade practices in Ukraine, and expanded customs capabilities in Oman, among many other programs. COMMERCIAL LAW COURSES OFFERED TO THE IRAQ JUDICIARY. ¶4. (U) Mr. Tejtel met with Chief Judge Medhat on June 22, 2009 to discuss judicial education opportunities in commercial law. On behalf of CLDP, he proposed a one-year intensive course, with approximately twenty participants, culminating in a study tour to the United States for participants to view the courts of the practitioner instructors. Chief Judge Medhat found this approach appealing and offered classroom space for the program at the Judicial Education Development Institute (JEDI). CLDP will submit a formal proposal for the program within three weeks. At a later meeting with INL and the JEDI curriculum project board, Chief Judge Jaffer of CCC-I Rusafa, submitted a list of HJC priorities in commercial law judicial education, to wit: "international sales, international trade companies and its registrations, banking operations, letter[s] of credit, documentary credit, safe deposit rent, international transportation, arbitration, electronic crimes, Qrent, international transportation, arbitration, electronic crimes, [and] electronic signature." SHURA COUNCIL CAPACITY BUILDING INITIATIVES PROPOSED. ¶5. (U) CLA and Mr. Tejtel discussed the potential for a study tour to France or Tunisia for the Shura Council to see a working model of an organization that reviews laws for constitutionality and coherence. During the study tour, CLDP hopes to arrange a meeting between the head of the Administrative Court of Iraq and experts to explore potential initiatives to strengthen Iraq's administrative law adjudication. STUDY TOUR TO EXPOSE IRAQIS TO UAE INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION CENTER. ¶6. (U) In cooperation with CLA, CLDP is tentatively arranging an "International Arbitration and the Judicial Enforcement of Arbitral Awards" study tour for members of the Shura Council International Arbitration Drafting Committee and key GOI officials in positions to advance legislation that could assure investors that arbitral awards would be recognized in Iraq if merited. The objective of the program is outlined by CLDP's preliminary project proposal : "To help key decision-makers in the Iraqi judiciary and in key ministries reach a consensus on the importance for Iraq of the BAGHDAD 00001875 002 OF 002 judicial enforcement of international arbitral awards, and to pave the way, as a result, towards Iraq's eventual signing of the New York Convention." CLDP has also proposed a DVC on Arbitration with a Tunisian expert judge to dispel any misconceptions held by Iraqis about the international arbitration process and the role of the judiciary. CLA is assessing the implications of the current lack of international arbitral awards recognition dispute resolution capacity within the current Iraqi legal framework. CLDP SUPPORT FOR THE NATIONAL INVESTMENT COMMISSION (NIC) ¶7. (U) CLDP, CLA, and ROLC met with Dr. Sami Al-Araji, Chairman of the National Investment Commission (NIC),who requested CLDP's support in three primary ways. First, he expressed that technical assistance discussed between the Minister of Industry and Minerals and CLDP a year ago is now more urgently needed. Last year, when CLDP met in Dubai with Iraqi's Minister of Industry and Minerals and Dr. Sami, the Minister requested that CLDP train the general counsels of Iraq's State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs). CLDP reports in its Project Proposal Draft that "[t]he Minister envisions joint ventures as the most realistic way for key SOEs, [which currently employ approximately 650,000 Iraqis], to receive the managerial, technological, and capital they desperately need to create jobs in the short term, and to be eventually privatized." CLDP offered to train 10-12 General Counsels in the legal basics of joint-venture formation and negotiation through a series of workshops and seminars taught over a six-month period. Funding is now available and CLDP agreed to provide this assistance, but will be unable to start the program until the fall. ¶8. (U) Dr. Sami also requested Mr. Tejtel's assistance in arranging meetings with potential investors and risk guarantee and financial institutions during his upcoming visit to the States with the Prime Minister. CLDP agreed to facilitate contracts with possible investors. ¶9. (U) NIC is seeking funding to retain the services of an international organization or law firm to prepare tender contracts with selected bidders for a planned Infrastructure Investment Program, which the NIC is currently preparing to submit to the Council of Representatives (COR). CLDP suggested that NIC approach the World Bank as a potential funding source if this program is passed by the COR. MINISTRY OF TRADE COMMERCIAL ATTACHE TRAINING DISCUSSED. ¶10. (U) CLDP initiated discussions with Abdul Hadi K. Al-Hamiri, Director General and Advisor to the Ministry of Trade, who is interested in training for commercial attachs. CLDP offered their expertise in training lawyers and helping develop procedures, processes, and standard documents to ensure that import contracts, as well as government procurement, comply with international best practices. Dr. Al-Hamiri and Mr. Tejtel will continue discussions over email regarding potential training initiatives. ¶11. (U) COMMENT: The CLDP project proposals resulting from the CLDP Deputy Chief Counsel's visit will further Embassy priority objectives and provide synergistic effects. As became evident through meetings with various sections and GOI institutions, lack of capacity in one GOI function, such as dispute resolution, tends to compound difficulties in other GOI functions. Equally, as Iraq continues in its efforts to draft new laws meeting international standards, capacity building can dispel misconceptions and create competencies in areas to facilitate the drafting of more Qcompetencies in areas to facilitate the drafting of more sophisticated provisions, which are needed to give investors and potential trade partners confidence in Iraq's obligations and stability. CLDP's training cross-cuts various ministries, further reinforcing our capacity building message under the Strategic Framework Agreement, including the Economic and Energy and Law Enforcement and Judicial Cooperation JCCs. End comment.