AUSTR CUTLER DISCUSSES BILATERAL TRADE AND

C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 TOKYO 002951 SIPDIS STATE FOR EAP/J AND EAP/EP AND AMBASSADOR HASLACH STATE PASS USTR FOR AUSTR CUTLER AND AUSTR WEISEL E.O. 12958: DECL: 10/17/2018 TAGS: ETRD EAGR ECON APEC JP SUBJECT: AUSTR CUTLER DISCUSSES BILATERAL TRADE AND REGIONAL ARCHITECTURE WITH JAPANESE COUNTERPARTS Classified By: Ambassador J. Thomas Schieffer for reasons 1.4 (b),(d) ¶1. (C) Summary: While agreeing on the importance of APEC and on the Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific approach as a long-term vision for achieving trade and investment liberalization through the Asia-Pacific region, Foreign and Trade Ministry interlocutors expressed differing versions to visiting AUSTR Wendy Cutler on how Japan and the United States can most effectively achieve this goal. On bilateral beef trade, Agriculture Ministry officials continued to express opposition to full market opening, arguing for a 30-month reopening for the time being. AUSTR Cutler also emphasized the importance of Japan re-starting tenders for rice imports, although her counterparts could not offer a definitive timeline for when tendering would resume. Her Foreign and Trade Ministry counterparts discussed the need to continue to strengthen bilateral economic and trade relations under a new U.S. administration, including by ensuring the U.S.-Japan Regulatory Reform Initiative (or its successor) remains a key component of our engagement. End summary. ¶2. (SBU) During her October 13-14 visit to Tokyo, Assistant U.S. Trade Representative for Japan, Korea, and APEC Affairs Wendy Cutler raised bilateral and regional issues with Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) Director General for Economic Affairs Yoichi Otabe, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries (MAFF) Director General for International Affairs Kaoru Yoshimura, as well as Vice Minister Hidenori Murakami, Ministry of Economy, Trade, and Industry (METI) Director General for Trade Policy Hideichi Okada, and MOFA Deputy Vice Minister Chikao Kawai. She also met with the Board of Directors of the American Chamber of Commerce in Japan. APEC -------------- ¶3. (C) AUSTR Cutler engaged MOFA's Otabe and METI's Okada on how to set the stage more effectively to make Japan's APEC host year in 2010 and the U.S. host year in 2011 as fruitful as possible. Both agreed with Cutler's view that an excessive focus placed by Japan on the achievement of APEC's Bogor Goals by developed countries before 2010 would sap the ability to use 2010 to move forward on future-oriented work, 
like the Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific (FTAAP). Both also concurred with Cutler on the importance of carefully coordinating bilaterally as we work with other APEC economies in order to be able to set a forward looking agenda for 2010 and 2011. Regional Economic Integration -------------- ¶4. (C) Responding to questions on METI's vision for Asia-Pacific integration, Okada noted a U.S. presence in Asia is necessary, but Japan will continue to engage its trading partners in regional fora such as ASEAN plus 3 and ASEAN plus 6 that do not include the United States. At the same time, he tried to assure AUSTR Cutler that METI Minister Nikai does not intend to exclude the U.S. from regional economic and trade initiatives. There can be no successful regional economic integration without the United States, he stated. Trans-Pacific Strategic Partnership FTA -------------- ¶5. (C) Saying he did not fully understand how the Trans-Pacific Strategic Partnership free trade agreement (or P-4) will benefit the United States, MOFA's Otabe acknowledged broader participation by additional countries might facilitate more meaningful regional trade liberalization. METI's Okada said joining the P-4 was the "right step" for the United States. However, both Otabe and Okada argued Japan is not ready for the P-4, but will continue its discussions with the U.S. about possible future participation. MAFF's Yoshimura said Japan's agriculture industry in particular is not interested in a free trade agreement with New Zealand. Otabe said the GOJ prefers to work with the USG to develop a high standard FTAAP and sees TOKYO 00002951 002 OF 003 the FTAAP as a better vehicle than the P-4 for achieving regional economic integration. He also said Japan would be in a better position to take high-level decisions on trade issues in 2010, when it hosts APEC and the Primer Minister's Office focuses on these issues. U.S. Beef -------------- ¶6. (C) Emphasizing the safety of U.S. beef and the strong concern that continues to exist about Japan's reluctance to adopt international standards for beef trade, AUSTR Cutler stressed to her counterparts the need fully to resolve the issue. She added that Ambassador Schwab will soon be in touch with Agriculture Minister Ishiba to seek agreement on basic principles under which we can move forward with solutions to this issue. She stressed the United States continues to look to Japan to agree on a concrete timeline for further opening its market in a manner that will lead to consistency with international (OIE) standards, and pointed to the U.S. agreement with Korea on beef as a model for how we can achieve this goal. ¶7. (C) Reflecting the high degree of incrementalism infecting Tokyo on trade issues in recent months as Japan's political situation evolves, visiting AUSTR Cutler's counterparts failed to move beyond previous positions about how the beef trade issue can be solved. MAFF Vice Minister Murakami conceded resolution of the U.S. beef issue will be "very difficult" given differences of approach on both sides. Both Otabe and Yomishura asserted lingering doubts about the safety of U.S. beef warrants a slower and more measured approach by the GOJ. Yomishura cited research by Japanese scientists that claims prions (infectious agents for BSE) might exist in the neural network outside the spinal cord. AgMinCouns said he was unaware of this research, but noted if confirmed, this discovery will have implications for Japan's own beef industry, which has suffered higher rates of BSE infection in its cattle population. AUSTR Cutler expressed surprise the GOJ still questions the safety of U.S. beef and noted she has been told repeatedly in private conversations Japan's reluctance to reopen fully its market to U.S. beef is motivated by political considerations, not scientific concerns. Rice Tenders -------------- ¶8. (C) Director General Yoshimura claimed MAFF stopped rice tenders in the wake of Japan's incident rice scandal in order to buy the government time to restore consumer confidence. He would not commit to a date by which tenders will resume, but assured AUSTR Cutler every effort would be made to restart the tender process as quickly as possible. MOFA's Otabe speculated rice tenders will resume in December. AUSTR Cutler said U.S. rice is safe and already tested repeatedly by Japan, and has not been implicated in the scandal. She expressed concern further delays in a resumption of rice tenders made it increasingly difficult for the USG to quietly engage the GOJ on this issue. Otabe said MOFA is working with MAFF to resolve the issue and will push for productive discussions in Geneva at the WTO. In particular, Japan will consider how best to use WTO preferential treatment provisions to "make up" for the delayed start to minimum access (MMA) rice tenders for Japan Fiscal Year (JFY) 2008, much as it had done earlier this year to rectify a shortfall of tenders in JFY 2007 (eight tenders in 2007 compared to twice per month as dictated under the terms of the MMA). U.S.-Japan Relations: Future Initiatives -------------- ¶9. (C) Otabe said MOFA and METI have established a study group to develop a set of recommendations for how the next U.S. administration and Japan should cooperate on a range of bilateral and multilateral issues. He has included former METI and MOF officials as a means to better coordinate with other Ministries on his work. Central to these recommendations is the role the ongoing Regulatory Reform TOKYO 00002951 003 OF 003 Initiative should play as a key component of the U.S.-Japan economic and trade relationship, as well as the Trade Forum, which he believes should focus more on exchanging views and information on our respective trade initiatives. Both countries also need to develop and coordinate a common strategy for engaging other countries in the region such as China, India, and possibly Russia. AUSTR Cutler suggested the U.S. and Japan identify discreet issues for collaboration, where both countries can set cutting edge standards and establish models for other economies to follow. ¶10. (U) AUSTR Cutler cleared this message subsequent to her departure from post. SCHIEFFER