Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
08KUWAIT1160
2008-11-24 12:56:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy Kuwait
Cable title:
TRIPARTITE COMMISSION: KUWAITI DISAPPOINTMENT
how-toVZCZCXYZ0004 PP RUEHWEB DE RUEHKU #1160/01 3291256 ZNR UUUUU ZZH (CCY AD007B4B MSI9954-695) P 241256Z NOV 08 FM AMEMBASSY KUWAIT TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 2400 INFO RUEHGB/AMEMBASSY BAGHDAD PRIORITY 1323 RUEHLO/AMEMBASSY LONDON PRIORITY 1494 RUEHFR/AMEMBASSY PARIS PRIORITY 1162 RUEHRH/AMEMBASSY RIYADH PRIORITY 2532 RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA PRIORITY 1245 RHEHNSC/NSC WASHDC PRIORITY RUCNDT/USMISSION USUN NEW YORK PRIORITY 3204
UNCLAS KUWAIT 001160
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
C O R R E C T E D COPY CAPTION
NEA/ARP, NEA/I
OSD-DPMO FOR A. CRONAUER, COL D. ELLIS, J. BASHAM
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: MARR PHUM PREL IZ SA KU
SUBJECT: TRIPARTITE COMMISSION: KUWAITI DISAPPOINTMENT
WITH LACK OF PROGRESS ON MISSING
REF: A. KUWAIT 698
B. KUWAIT 1137
UNCLAS KUWAIT 001160
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
C O R R E C T E D COPY CAPTION
NEA/ARP, NEA/I
OSD-DPMO FOR A. CRONAUER, COL D. ELLIS, J. BASHAM
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: MARR PHUM PREL IZ SA KU
SUBJECT: TRIPARTITE COMMISSION: KUWAITI DISAPPOINTMENT
WITH LACK OF PROGRESS ON MISSING
REF: A. KUWAIT 698
B. KUWAIT 1137
1. (U) This is an action request. Please see para 13.
Summary
--------------
2. (SBU) The Kuwaiti delegation made clear during a November
19 Tripartite Commission (TC) meeting that it was
disappointed over the lack of results in the search for
Kuwaitis missing from the 1990 Iraqi invasion of Kuwait.
Despite a commitment to cooperative dialogue in the TC
setting, a clear lack of capacity and coordination among
Iraqi ministries continues to delay the discovery and
exhumation of the mortal remains of some 350 Kuwaitis
believed to have been executed by Iraqi forces. The TC,
chaired by the International Committee for the Red Cross,
revealed no new information on US Navy Captain Michael Scott
Speicher, the one remaining US citizen left unaccounted for
from the 1990 Gulf War. His DNA profile remains in the
Kuwaiti database and continues to be checked against all
newly received profiles. End Summary.
31st Tripartite Commission Update
--------------
3. (U) The International Committee for the Red Cross (ICRC)
chaired the 58th session of the Technical Subcommittee (TSC)
and the 31st Tripartite Commission (TC) respectively on
November 17 and 19. The ICRC updated the TC -- composed of
delegates who manage POW and/or unaccounted-for files from
Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, France, the UK and the U.S. -- on
2008 developments in the quest to locate the mortal remains
of those still missing from the 1990-91 Iraqi invasion and
occupation of Kuwait.
Kuwaiti Frustrations: "2008 was Null and Void!"
-------------- --
4. (SBU) In a departure from previous TC sessions, which
were characterized by a conciliatory, collegial tone, the
Kuwaiti delegation and the ICRC expressed overt frustration
with the lack of progress from the Iraqi side, complaining
that 2008 offered few tangible results in terms of locating
mass graves or other mortal remains in Iraq despite recent
security successes and citing examples of apparent
unwillingness to cooperate by private Iraqi potential
'witnesses.' Based on conclusive DNA testing which dated
back to 2004, the TC closed only three files -- one Saudi and
two Kuwaiti nationals. There were no exhumation activities
conducted by Kuwait in 2008. To increase accountability and
productivity from TSC taskings, ICRC proposed and the TC
agreed that meetings should take place on a bimonthly basis
starting on January 20, 2009; the venue is likely to be a UN
station on the Kuwaiti/Iraqi border.
Successful Saudi/Iraqi Coordination on Repatriating Remains
-------------- --------------
5. (U) A positive and welcome result, but outside of the TC
mandate, was the successful repatriation of 63 mortal remains
from Saudi Arabia, through Kuwait, to Iraq. With these
repatriations, the Saudi delegation declared that all 123
Iraqi files in Saudi Arabia were closed. The ICRC touted
this development and praised the bilateral cooperation
between the Iraqi and Saudi delegations.
Requests for US Action
--------------
6. (SBU) The ICRC chair recalled for the meeting that, per
the 57th TSC (ref A),a previous review of data provided by
the Kuwaiti delegation, led by Dr. Ibrahim Al-Shaheen, failed
to reveal any indications of mass graves that would warrant
additional excavation; further action by the USG would
require new information to be brought forward by TC members.
In response, the Kuwaiti delegation proposed an exchange of
technical experts with Washington to analyze existing data
and to recommend techniques and options for future
discoveries. Ambassador reiterated for the TC that U.S.
efforts in determining the locations of mass grave sites via
satellite imagery had been exhausted, but she welcomed new
information that might prove useful in aiding analysts in
future searches. She also welcomed the proposal for expert
exchanges, but asked the Kuwaiti delegation to be more
specific in its requests for U.S. assistance. Though
Al-Shaheen was unable to provide immediately details on
desired USG support, he mentioned that Nasseriya, Iraq holds
promising excavation opportunities and requested a positive
US and MNF-I response to future GOI overtures for financial
or technical personnel assistance. (Note: The Saudi lead
delegate, MFA U/S for Political Affairs Prince Turki Bin
Mohammad Bin Saud Al-Kabir, arrived nearly 1.5 hours late to
the session following meetings with GOK FM Dr. Mohammed Al
Sabah. The Saudi Ambassador to Kuwait later confided to
Ambassador that the KSA side believed the chances of
recovering additional remains was little to nil at this
stage. End note.)
Ambassador Tarasov's Call for Capacity Building
-------------- --
7. (SBU) UN High-Level Coordinator Ambassador Gennady Tarasov
conveyed to Ambassador in a November 19 visit to Kuwait his
concerns that poor coordination among Iraqi Ministries
outweighed generally positive attitudes toward coooperation.
He said his report to the UN Secretary General would call for
more unity within the Iraqi government and urge support from
the office of the Iraqi Prime Minister for the Ministry of
Human Rights, headed by a competent, but overtaxed Wijdan
Mikhail Salim. He explained that Salim is tasked with
locating, among other responsibilities, the remains of the
missing from numerous internal and external conflicts, but
has only one 12-member team and little technical equipment
with which to carry out the task. Tarasov opined that
multi-sided political pressures make it extremely difficult
for Salim to allocate her minimal resources to find the
approximately 350 remaining Kuwaiti missing, when so many
thousands of Kurdish, Sunni, and Shi'a Iraqis and Iranians
are still unaccounted for in Iraq.
8. (U) Tarasov noted that the UN has UNAMI funds allocated
for MOHR capacity building in terms of personnel and
equipment and that he would seek additional funds for this
purpose. Ambassador conveyed the latter information to the
TC. His assessment on Iraq was that "not much progress has
taken place, but the quality of efforts has improved," and
stressed that the way forward is to transform the determined
and positive tone of professionals like Salim into practical
deeds.
No Iraqi MFA Involvement in Proceedings
--------------
9. (SBU) Noticeably absent from the proceedings was
representation from the Iraqi Embassy in Kuwait -- despite
the matter being raised at the previous TSC and with the
Iraqi Charge on November 11 (ref B). In response to poloff's
query, an Iraqi delegation member replied that "if you bring
in the Embassy, then you bring in the MFA, and then the
office of the Prime Minister..." implying that GOI
bureaucracy and infighting would squelch progress on TSC
mandates. (Note: All Iraqi delegation members hailed from
the GOI's Ministry of Human Rights. End note).
Witnesses Playing Cat and Mouse
--------------
10. (SBU) Adding to the Kuwaiti frustration was the lack of
success in making contact with witnesses who claim to have
actionable information on mass grave sites:
--A witness with supposed knowledge of grave sites in Kuwait
(AKA "the Jahra witness") previously told TC members that he
would meet them in Syria, then later changed the venue to
Kuwait. He now insists that such a meeting, to be brokered
by the ICRC, must take place in Riyadh. ICRC, in an attempt
to force the meeting, set December 21 as the date, in Riyadh,
in which the meeting must take place.
-- Two recently re-opened files, Mohammed Al-Dakhil and Faleh
Al-Gharib, also produced disappointing results. The Iraqi
delegation had failed to contact a supposed eyewitness, Dr.
Ibrahim Aqidi (no further information),but renewed a promise
to reach out to him and to other former and current Iraqi
government officials who might have insight into missing
Kuwaitis.
-- The Kuwaiti delegation was particularly indignant over
recent demands for $300,000 by a witness in Ramadi for
information on mass graves. ICRC offered to meet with the
witness, but mentioned that it would explore options to refer
this witness to Iraqi legal authorities if he continued to
withhold relevant information on mass grave sites.
Speicher Update
--------------
11. (U) There was no new information on US Navy Captain
Michael S. Speicher's case. His DNA profile remains in the
Kuwaiti database and continues to be checked against all
newly received profiles. The U.S. delegation renewed its
commitment to continue the effort to resolve Speicher's case.
12. (U) Delegations:
Republic of Iraq
--------------
Mr. Kazem M.K. Al-Anzi
Mr. Yaqoob Kh. Haider
Mr. Hussein Eidi Hassan
Mr. Arkan Abdallah Abdelamir
Mr. Hazem Jassem Yassin
State of Kuwait
--------------
H.E. Dr. Ibrahim M. Al-Shaheen
H.E. Ambassador Khalid M. Al-Maqamis
Mr. Fozan Al-Fozan
Mr. Rabea Al-Adsani
Dr. Mohammad Al-Haddad
Dr. Soltan Al-Khalaf
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
--------------
H.H. Prince Turki Bin Mohammad Bin Saud Al-Kabir
MG Nasser Bin Saad Al-Hmeidan
Mr. Jamal Bin Hossein Akeel
Dr. Zuhair M. Al-Idrissi
Dr. Hussein Zahrani
LTC Khalid Al-Treiri
Mr. Fahad Al-Juraid
Republic of France
--------------
Ambassador Jean-Rene Gehan
United Kingdom
--------------
Charge d,Affaires Tim Stew
Mr. Jonathan Layfield
Ms. Nicola Woodget
United States
--------------
Ambassador Deborah K. Jones
POL Counselor Pete O,Donohue
Poloff Thomas ROSENBERGER
International Committee of the Red Cross
--------------
Mrs. Beatrice Megevand-Roggo, Head of Operations for Middle
East and North Africa
Mr. Jean-Michel Monod, Chairman of the TSC, Regional Delegate
for the GCC Countries
Mr. Juan Pedro Schaerer, Head of Delegation ICRC Iraq
Ms. Jamila Al-Hammami, Delegate for 'Missing' files for Iraq
Mr. John Strick van Linschoten, Protection Delegate, ICRC
Kuwait
Mr. Eissa Mowazi, Protection Department
13. (SBU) Action request: Post would appreciate further
information from USUN and/or the Department regarding the
availability of UNAMI funds for GOI MOHR capacity building
for locating and exhuming human remains, per Ambassador
Tarasov's remarks in para 7.
********************************************* *
For more reporting from Embassy Kuwait, visit:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/nea/kuwait/?cable s
Visit Kuwait's Classified Website:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/nea/kuwait/
********************************************* *
JONES
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
C O R R E C T E D COPY CAPTION
NEA/ARP, NEA/I
OSD-DPMO FOR A. CRONAUER, COL D. ELLIS, J. BASHAM
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: MARR PHUM PREL IZ SA KU
SUBJECT: TRIPARTITE COMMISSION: KUWAITI DISAPPOINTMENT
WITH LACK OF PROGRESS ON MISSING
REF: A. KUWAIT 698
B. KUWAIT 1137
1. (U) This is an action request. Please see para 13.
Summary
--------------
2. (SBU) The Kuwaiti delegation made clear during a November
19 Tripartite Commission (TC) meeting that it was
disappointed over the lack of results in the search for
Kuwaitis missing from the 1990 Iraqi invasion of Kuwait.
Despite a commitment to cooperative dialogue in the TC
setting, a clear lack of capacity and coordination among
Iraqi ministries continues to delay the discovery and
exhumation of the mortal remains of some 350 Kuwaitis
believed to have been executed by Iraqi forces. The TC,
chaired by the International Committee for the Red Cross,
revealed no new information on US Navy Captain Michael Scott
Speicher, the one remaining US citizen left unaccounted for
from the 1990 Gulf War. His DNA profile remains in the
Kuwaiti database and continues to be checked against all
newly received profiles. End Summary.
31st Tripartite Commission Update
--------------
3. (U) The International Committee for the Red Cross (ICRC)
chaired the 58th session of the Technical Subcommittee (TSC)
and the 31st Tripartite Commission (TC) respectively on
November 17 and 19. The ICRC updated the TC -- composed of
delegates who manage POW and/or unaccounted-for files from
Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, France, the UK and the U.S. -- on
2008 developments in the quest to locate the mortal remains
of those still missing from the 1990-91 Iraqi invasion and
occupation of Kuwait.
Kuwaiti Frustrations: "2008 was Null and Void!"
-------------- --
4. (SBU) In a departure from previous TC sessions, which
were characterized by a conciliatory, collegial tone, the
Kuwaiti delegation and the ICRC expressed overt frustration
with the lack of progress from the Iraqi side, complaining
that 2008 offered few tangible results in terms of locating
mass graves or other mortal remains in Iraq despite recent
security successes and citing examples of apparent
unwillingness to cooperate by private Iraqi potential
'witnesses.' Based on conclusive DNA testing which dated
back to 2004, the TC closed only three files -- one Saudi and
two Kuwaiti nationals. There were no exhumation activities
conducted by Kuwait in 2008. To increase accountability and
productivity from TSC taskings, ICRC proposed and the TC
agreed that meetings should take place on a bimonthly basis
starting on January 20, 2009; the venue is likely to be a UN
station on the Kuwaiti/Iraqi border.
Successful Saudi/Iraqi Coordination on Repatriating Remains
-------------- --------------
5. (U) A positive and welcome result, but outside of the TC
mandate, was the successful repatriation of 63 mortal remains
from Saudi Arabia, through Kuwait, to Iraq. With these
repatriations, the Saudi delegation declared that all 123
Iraqi files in Saudi Arabia were closed. The ICRC touted
this development and praised the bilateral cooperation
between the Iraqi and Saudi delegations.
Requests for US Action
--------------
6. (SBU) The ICRC chair recalled for the meeting that, per
the 57th TSC (ref A),a previous review of data provided by
the Kuwaiti delegation, led by Dr. Ibrahim Al-Shaheen, failed
to reveal any indications of mass graves that would warrant
additional excavation; further action by the USG would
require new information to be brought forward by TC members.
In response, the Kuwaiti delegation proposed an exchange of
technical experts with Washington to analyze existing data
and to recommend techniques and options for future
discoveries. Ambassador reiterated for the TC that U.S.
efforts in determining the locations of mass grave sites via
satellite imagery had been exhausted, but she welcomed new
information that might prove useful in aiding analysts in
future searches. She also welcomed the proposal for expert
exchanges, but asked the Kuwaiti delegation to be more
specific in its requests for U.S. assistance. Though
Al-Shaheen was unable to provide immediately details on
desired USG support, he mentioned that Nasseriya, Iraq holds
promising excavation opportunities and requested a positive
US and MNF-I response to future GOI overtures for financial
or technical personnel assistance. (Note: The Saudi lead
delegate, MFA U/S for Political Affairs Prince Turki Bin
Mohammad Bin Saud Al-Kabir, arrived nearly 1.5 hours late to
the session following meetings with GOK FM Dr. Mohammed Al
Sabah. The Saudi Ambassador to Kuwait later confided to
Ambassador that the KSA side believed the chances of
recovering additional remains was little to nil at this
stage. End note.)
Ambassador Tarasov's Call for Capacity Building
-------------- --
7. (SBU) UN High-Level Coordinator Ambassador Gennady Tarasov
conveyed to Ambassador in a November 19 visit to Kuwait his
concerns that poor coordination among Iraqi Ministries
outweighed generally positive attitudes toward coooperation.
He said his report to the UN Secretary General would call for
more unity within the Iraqi government and urge support from
the office of the Iraqi Prime Minister for the Ministry of
Human Rights, headed by a competent, but overtaxed Wijdan
Mikhail Salim. He explained that Salim is tasked with
locating, among other responsibilities, the remains of the
missing from numerous internal and external conflicts, but
has only one 12-member team and little technical equipment
with which to carry out the task. Tarasov opined that
multi-sided political pressures make it extremely difficult
for Salim to allocate her minimal resources to find the
approximately 350 remaining Kuwaiti missing, when so many
thousands of Kurdish, Sunni, and Shi'a Iraqis and Iranians
are still unaccounted for in Iraq.
8. (U) Tarasov noted that the UN has UNAMI funds allocated
for MOHR capacity building in terms of personnel and
equipment and that he would seek additional funds for this
purpose. Ambassador conveyed the latter information to the
TC. His assessment on Iraq was that "not much progress has
taken place, but the quality of efforts has improved," and
stressed that the way forward is to transform the determined
and positive tone of professionals like Salim into practical
deeds.
No Iraqi MFA Involvement in Proceedings
--------------
9. (SBU) Noticeably absent from the proceedings was
representation from the Iraqi Embassy in Kuwait -- despite
the matter being raised at the previous TSC and with the
Iraqi Charge on November 11 (ref B). In response to poloff's
query, an Iraqi delegation member replied that "if you bring
in the Embassy, then you bring in the MFA, and then the
office of the Prime Minister..." implying that GOI
bureaucracy and infighting would squelch progress on TSC
mandates. (Note: All Iraqi delegation members hailed from
the GOI's Ministry of Human Rights. End note).
Witnesses Playing Cat and Mouse
--------------
10. (SBU) Adding to the Kuwaiti frustration was the lack of
success in making contact with witnesses who claim to have
actionable information on mass grave sites:
--A witness with supposed knowledge of grave sites in Kuwait
(AKA "the Jahra witness") previously told TC members that he
would meet them in Syria, then later changed the venue to
Kuwait. He now insists that such a meeting, to be brokered
by the ICRC, must take place in Riyadh. ICRC, in an attempt
to force the meeting, set December 21 as the date, in Riyadh,
in which the meeting must take place.
-- Two recently re-opened files, Mohammed Al-Dakhil and Faleh
Al-Gharib, also produced disappointing results. The Iraqi
delegation had failed to contact a supposed eyewitness, Dr.
Ibrahim Aqidi (no further information),but renewed a promise
to reach out to him and to other former and current Iraqi
government officials who might have insight into missing
Kuwaitis.
-- The Kuwaiti delegation was particularly indignant over
recent demands for $300,000 by a witness in Ramadi for
information on mass graves. ICRC offered to meet with the
witness, but mentioned that it would explore options to refer
this witness to Iraqi legal authorities if he continued to
withhold relevant information on mass grave sites.
Speicher Update
--------------
11. (U) There was no new information on US Navy Captain
Michael S. Speicher's case. His DNA profile remains in the
Kuwaiti database and continues to be checked against all
newly received profiles. The U.S. delegation renewed its
commitment to continue the effort to resolve Speicher's case.
12. (U) Delegations:
Republic of Iraq
--------------
Mr. Kazem M.K. Al-Anzi
Mr. Yaqoob Kh. Haider
Mr. Hussein Eidi Hassan
Mr. Arkan Abdallah Abdelamir
Mr. Hazem Jassem Yassin
State of Kuwait
--------------
H.E. Dr. Ibrahim M. Al-Shaheen
H.E. Ambassador Khalid M. Al-Maqamis
Mr. Fozan Al-Fozan
Mr. Rabea Al-Adsani
Dr. Mohammad Al-Haddad
Dr. Soltan Al-Khalaf
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
--------------
H.H. Prince Turki Bin Mohammad Bin Saud Al-Kabir
MG Nasser Bin Saad Al-Hmeidan
Mr. Jamal Bin Hossein Akeel
Dr. Zuhair M. Al-Idrissi
Dr. Hussein Zahrani
LTC Khalid Al-Treiri
Mr. Fahad Al-Juraid
Republic of France
--------------
Ambassador Jean-Rene Gehan
United Kingdom
--------------
Charge d,Affaires Tim Stew
Mr. Jonathan Layfield
Ms. Nicola Woodget
United States
--------------
Ambassador Deborah K. Jones
POL Counselor Pete O,Donohue
Poloff Thomas ROSENBERGER
International Committee of the Red Cross
--------------
Mrs. Beatrice Megevand-Roggo, Head of Operations for Middle
East and North Africa
Mr. Jean-Michel Monod, Chairman of the TSC, Regional Delegate
for the GCC Countries
Mr. Juan Pedro Schaerer, Head of Delegation ICRC Iraq
Ms. Jamila Al-Hammami, Delegate for 'Missing' files for Iraq
Mr. John Strick van Linschoten, Protection Delegate, ICRC
Kuwait
Mr. Eissa Mowazi, Protection Department
13. (SBU) Action request: Post would appreciate further
information from USUN and/or the Department regarding the
availability of UNAMI funds for GOI MOHR capacity building
for locating and exhuming human remains, per Ambassador
Tarasov's remarks in para 7.
********************************************* *
For more reporting from Embassy Kuwait, visit:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/nea/kuwait/?cable s
Visit Kuwait's Classified Website:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/nea/kuwait/
********************************************* *
JONES