Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
06VIENNA247
2006-01-26 15:50:00
UNCLASSIFIED
Embassy Vienna
Cable title:
AUSTRIA PLANS TO BAN BIOTECH OILSEED RAPE GT73
how-toVZCZCXRO2425 PP RUEHIK DE RUEHVI #0247 0261550 ZNR UUUUU ZZH P 261550Z JAN 06 FM AMEMBASSY VIENNA TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 2186 RUEHRC/USDA FAS WASHDC PRIORITY 1085 INFO RUCPDC/USDOC WASHDC PRIORITY RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA PRIORITY 1277 RUEHBS/USEU BRUSSELS PRIORITY RUCNMEM/EU MEMBER STATES PRIORITY
UNCLAS VIENNA 000247
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
STATE PASS USTR
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EAGR ETRD EUN TBIO AU
SUBJECT: AUSTRIA PLANS TO BAN BIOTECH OILSEED RAPE GT73
REF: 05 VIENNA 3496
UNCLAS VIENNA 000247
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
STATE PASS USTR
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EAGR ETRD EUN TBIO AU
SUBJECT: AUSTRIA PLANS TO BAN BIOTECH OILSEED RAPE GT73
REF: 05 VIENNA 3496
1. During a January 20 press conference on Austria's EU
Presidency health agenda, Minister of Health and Women's
Affairs (MoH),Maria Rauch-Kallat, announced that Austria
plans to issue a government ordinance to implement a
marketing ban on Monsanto's GT73 oilseed rape until the end
of 2008. The EU Commission had authorized GT73 in August
2005 for marketing in the entire EU.
2. Michel Haas, Head of the MoH's Biotechnology Department
subsequently told us that the MoH will circulate a draft
ordinance to various experts and stakeholders (mainly in
other ministries and state governments). The ordinance may
come into effect within four weeks. He noted that the GoA
must notify the EC concerning the ordinance.
3. Rauch-Kallat conceded in her press conference that the
EC might take action against the GoA. However, she
maintained that MoH experts could provide evidence that
rapeseeds have a significantly greater chance of mingling
with other crops than do other seeds, such as maize. She
added that this was a particular concern in Austria's small-
scale agricultural system. According to Rauch-Kallat, the
anticipated damage to conventional and organic food
justifies the ban.
Comment
--------------
4. The 2001 directive on the deliberate release of GMOs
does not foresee national safeguard clauses for new
approvals. Furthermore, Austria has already failed in an
attempt to argue that the small-scale nature of Austrian
agriculture makes it more vulnerable to mingling, and that
national measures are therefore justified (reftel). The EC,
therefore, presumably has ample reason to take action
against this apparent breach of EU regulations on
biotechnology.
5. The Austrian press has noted that Rauch-Kallat's
announcement coincided with Agriculture Minister Josef
Proell's initial appearance in Brussels to present Austria's
agriculture agenda for the Presidency. Some commentators
speculated that Proell, probably the most outspoken opponent
of GMOs in the GoA, "used Rauch-Kallat" to further his
agenda and subtly imply that there are health issues
surrounding GMO use. In any case, Proell has promised to
raise the idea of stricter, EU-wide regulations on GMOs
during two upcoming conferences in Vienna: the April 4-6
"Biotechnology Conference," sponsored by the EC and MoA; and
the April 18-19 conference on "The Role of Precaution in GMO
Policy," organized by the MoH and MoA. End comment.
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
STATE PASS USTR
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: EAGR ETRD EUN TBIO AU
SUBJECT: AUSTRIA PLANS TO BAN BIOTECH OILSEED RAPE GT73
REF: 05 VIENNA 3496
1. During a January 20 press conference on Austria's EU
Presidency health agenda, Minister of Health and Women's
Affairs (MoH),Maria Rauch-Kallat, announced that Austria
plans to issue a government ordinance to implement a
marketing ban on Monsanto's GT73 oilseed rape until the end
of 2008. The EU Commission had authorized GT73 in August
2005 for marketing in the entire EU.
2. Michel Haas, Head of the MoH's Biotechnology Department
subsequently told us that the MoH will circulate a draft
ordinance to various experts and stakeholders (mainly in
other ministries and state governments). The ordinance may
come into effect within four weeks. He noted that the GoA
must notify the EC concerning the ordinance.
3. Rauch-Kallat conceded in her press conference that the
EC might take action against the GoA. However, she
maintained that MoH experts could provide evidence that
rapeseeds have a significantly greater chance of mingling
with other crops than do other seeds, such as maize. She
added that this was a particular concern in Austria's small-
scale agricultural system. According to Rauch-Kallat, the
anticipated damage to conventional and organic food
justifies the ban.
Comment
--------------
4. The 2001 directive on the deliberate release of GMOs
does not foresee national safeguard clauses for new
approvals. Furthermore, Austria has already failed in an
attempt to argue that the small-scale nature of Austrian
agriculture makes it more vulnerable to mingling, and that
national measures are therefore justified (reftel). The EC,
therefore, presumably has ample reason to take action
against this apparent breach of EU regulations on
biotechnology.
5. The Austrian press has noted that Rauch-Kallat's
announcement coincided with Agriculture Minister Josef
Proell's initial appearance in Brussels to present Austria's
agriculture agenda for the Presidency. Some commentators
speculated that Proell, probably the most outspoken opponent
of GMOs in the GoA, "used Rauch-Kallat" to further his
agenda and subtly imply that there are health issues
surrounding GMO use. In any case, Proell has promised to
raise the idea of stricter, EU-wide regulations on GMOs
during two upcoming conferences in Vienna: the April 4-6
"Biotechnology Conference," sponsored by the EC and MoA; and
the April 18-19 conference on "The Role of Precaution in GMO
Policy," organized by the MoH and MoA. End comment.