MEDIA REACTION US ANTI-IMMIGRATION LAW THE

UNCLAS BUENOS AIRES 000013 SIPDIS STATE FOR INR/R/MR, I/GWHA, WHA, WHA/PDA, WHA/BSC, WHA/EPSC CDR USSOCOM FOR J-2 IAD/LAMA SIPDIS E.O. 12958: N/A TAGS: KPAO OPRC KMDR PREL MEDIA REACTION SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION US ANTI-IMMIGRATION LAW THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION ARGENTINE-BOLIVIAN RELATIONSHIP WTO AND FARM SUBSIDIES INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS AND GLOBAL CHALLENGES THE KIRCHNER ADMINISTRATION 01/03/05 ¶1. SUMMARY STATEMENT Weekend international stories include: the controversy unleashed by US anti-illegal immigration legislation; the Bush administration's legacy; negotiations related to global farm subsidies; Bolivian President-elect Evo Morales' first trip abroad; the Kirchner administration's performance; the role played by international organizations in dealing with crises; Russia being forced to abandon a gas blockade against Ukraine after European trade partners warned Moscow relations would suffer; Argentines blocking bridges to Uruguay claiming (pulp mill) projects will contaminate their farmlands along the river edge; the war in Iraq and the aftermath of the Asian tsunami being picked in a BBC global poll as the most significant events of 2005; and IRA thanking their members for having accepted the group's landmark decisions to make its ceasefire permanent. ¶2. OPINION PIECES AND KEY STORIES - "Controversy due to US anti-immigration act" Natalia Labruna, columnist of business-financial, center-right "InfoBae," writes (01/02) "Amid anti- terrorist paranoia, a new (US) draft bill seeks to turn illegal immigrants into criminals and build a wall on the US-Mexican border. "The Border Protection, Antiterrorism and Illegal Immigration Control Act of 2005 was passed by the House of Representatives last December with 239 votes versus 182 votes against (which included some Republicans)." - "Bush's debt" Centrist newspaper "Perfil" carries an opinion piece by Christian Riavale, on special assignment in Paris, who writes (12/31) "The US will likely take years to pay back the 'moral debt' that US President George W. Bush will leave when abandoning the White House. ".... Abuses committed in the struggle against terrorism (kidnappings, tortures, clandestine transfers, illegal prisons, phone wiretapping in and outside of the country) are already bringing consequences that could be devastating for the future of the US. "On the one hand, those methods... opened an 'abyss' between the US and Europe... On the other hand, said behavior is undermining the US's world prestige and deepening its isolation. "Even inside the US, those abuses are being criticized by an increasing percentage of public opinion, and, particularly, by political leaders and most judicial officers... ".... History demonstrates that, when the domineering power loses its soul, the world enters a period of turbulence with unpredictable consequences." - "Liberalization or litigation?" Daily-of-record "La Nacion" carries an op-ed piece by Argentine representative to the World Bank, Alieto Guadagni, who writes (01/03) "The WTO called on 149 countries in Hong Kong to make progress with the so- called Doha Development Round, but no significant progress was made on agricultural liberalization, which is promoted by efficient countries that cannot compete in international markets due to farm subsidies. ".... Let's point out that the farm subsidies granted by industrialized countries amount to almost 360 billion dollars per year... ".... According to a recent Cato Institute report, farm subsidies violate WTO rules. If the possibility to negotiate a reform of agricultural policies vanishes, a series of lawsuits could be filed against the US and the EU due to their farm subsidies." - "Evo Morales starts a world tour that will not include Argentina" Natasha Niebieskikwiat, columnist of leading "Clarin," writes (01/03) "Argentina is not among the destinations of Bolivian President-elect Evo Morales before taking office in January 22. By then, he will have been in three continents (Europe, Asia and Africa),in addition to Cuba, Venezuela and Brazil... "The issue is not a minor one if one bears in mind that the Kirchner administration has been a strategic ally in Morales' taking office, and that Argentina and Brazil are the main purchasers of Bolivian gas in the region... "... What calls everyone's attention is that Morales has not left time for a visit to Argentina, which could take him six hours in all. And that he will go around the world instead." - "Morales and his neighbors" Leading "Clarin" carries an opinion piece by its general editor Ricardo Kirschbaum, who opines (01/03) "On his first international trip, brand-new Bolivian President-elect Evo Morales chose Cuba, Venezuela and Brazil as his Latin American destinations... "The question is why Morales will not come to Argentina and whether this omission is related to problems in the (bilateral) relationship... Morales has to negotiate new gas prices with Argentina, which will surely impact on Argentine industrial costs. We do not believe that there are problems in the bilateral relationship but, instead, a loss of concrete influence of Argentina's diplomacy. "Bolivia has always been a country with which Argentina has had strong ties... While there are no signs of a change in this view, the fact that Morales has chosen other destinations for his trip indicates a set of priorities which places Argentina at a different level than in the past. And this is related to one's own mistakes rather than others' decisions." - "The price of so many political mistakes" Joaquin Morales Sola, political columnist of daily-of- record "La Nacion," highlights (12/31) "... Jorge Taiana (who has already met with US Ambassador Lino Gutierrez) is a serious foreign relations expert... "Taiana knows that the most serious case (in Latin America) is that of Bolivia, which is in a position to break peace in Latin America. "As a matter of fact, the conflict in Argentina is not created by ministers but by the President himself. His way of dividing the society and terming independent media as opponents makes him too similar to Hugo Chavez, who rules a country divided into two irreconcilable halves. "Argentina does not deserve to be compared with the Venezuelan political tragedy. And perhaps Kirchner himself does not deserve to be compared with Chavez, something which he hates while promoting. Chavez expresses a nationalistic militarism that Argentina buried many decades ago. "... Nevertheless, the problem posed by Argentina is not that of Venezuela nor are we discussing issues that cannot be solved through a dialogue between the official party and its opponents... Only by making so many mistakes, did Kirchner manage to gather (opponents) that were originally separated." ¶3. EDITORIALS - "The year now leaving" An editorial in liberal, English-language "Buenos Aires Herald" reads (12/31) "Many pundits were expecting the year ending today to contain a before and after on either side of the October 23 midterm elections but President Nestor Kirchner stayed in electioneering mode after the voting was over. Yet the 13 days between the election triumph and the frustrated conclusion of the Fourth Americas Summit in Mar del Plata do seem something of a turning-point because the ouster of Economy Minister Roberto Lavagna..., the choice of new ministers..., and intensified flirtation with Venezuela's firebrand Hugo Chavez all bespoke a shift to the left. The election result itself was a relative mandate... but the opposition can only blame itself for its own disarray if Kirchner could plausibly claim a sweeping triumph... "... While hardly immune from criticism, 2005 was a good year from most points of view - Kirchner seems to have an uncanny ability to get everything right while doing everything wrong.. . "Morally and culturally, there is rather less cause for self-congratulation than politically and economically in Argentina... Emergence from default should be the time for re-entering the world, not xenophobic nationalism, while a rare freedom from political and economic urgencies should permit institution-building and work on a tailspinning education." - "The 2006 big threats and challenges" Leading "Clarin" editorializes (01/02) "2005 has left multiple unstable political, social and environmental scenarios and no global leadership and institutions that can effectively deal with these crises. "... Unluckily, during 2005, international institutions have also suffered blows to their credibility and efficiency to deal with serious conflicts and emergencies. It happened with the UN, which was unable to reform its Security Council due to lack of consensus among several groups of countries. It also happened with the EU, with the French rejection of the constitutional project. By the year- end, the Hong Kong WTO ministerial also brought frustrating consequences for trade and for the prospects of developing countries vis--vis developed countries' protectionism. No progress has been made either on peace and security agendas or on strategies to face major conflicts. "... In brief, great challenges will call for creative and consistent multinational leadership and efforts from both the governments and civil societies and from economic and social protagonists." To see more Buenos Aires reporting, visit our classified website at: http://www.state.sqov.gov/p/wha/buenosaires The Media Reaction Report reflects articles and opinions by the cited news media and do not necessarily reflect U.S. Embassy policy or views. The Public Affairs Section does not independently verify information. The report is intended for internal U.S. Government use only. GUTIERREZ