Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
05ABUDHABI510
2005-02-05 02:09:00
SECRET
Embassy Abu Dhabi
Cable title:
U/S BOLTON VISITS UAE
how-tonull Diana T Fritz 12/06/2006 03:01:56 PM From DB/Inbox: Search Results Cable Text: S E C R E T ABU DHABI 00510 SIPDIS CXABU: ACTION: AMB INFO: POL ECON DCM DISSEMINATION: AMB CHARGE: PROG APPROVED: AMB:MJSISON DRAFTED: FCS:MEOBRIEN CLEARED: T: JTIMBIE ECON: OJOHN ACURTIS PM:SYORK VZCZCADI665 PP RUEHC RUEHZM RUEHDE RHEHNSC DE RUEHAD #0510/01 0360209 ZNY SSSSS ZZH P 050209Z FEB 05 FM AMEMBASSY ABU DHABI TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 7991 INFO RUEHZM/GULF COOPERATION COUNCIL COLLECTIVE PRIORITY RUEHDE/AMCONSUL DUBAI PRIORITY 4798 RHEHNSC/NSC WASHDC PRIORITY
S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 02 ABU DHABI 000510
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/04/2015
TAGS: ETTC IR IZ KNNP PARM PK TC
SUBJECT: U/S BOLTON VISITS UAE
Classified By: Ambassador Michele Sison for Reasons 1.5(b) and (d)
S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 02 ABU DHABI 000510
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/04/2015
TAGS: ETTC IR IZ KNNP PARM PK TC
SUBJECT: U/S BOLTON VISITS UAE
Classified By: Ambassador Michele Sison for Reasons 1.5(b) and (d)
1. (S) Summary: Under Secretary of State for Arms Control and International Security John Bolton met with UAE officials on January 31 to discuss the status of Iran,s nuclear weapons programs and to present future options for addressing the threat on the UAE,s doorstep, including referral to the U.N. Security Council. UAEG officials were very supportive of continuing diplomatic efforts to eliminate the threat presented to the UAE, the region and the world by an Iranian nuclear weapons program. Defense Minister/Dubai Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid (MbR) strongly supported continuing diplomatic efforts, saying that any use of force against Iran would result in retaliation of one sort or another. In addition, Dubai officials reported progress in closing down Iranian front companies located in Dubai that have assisted in the Iranian WMD acquisition programs.
Minister of Information Abdullah bin Zayed al Nahyan emphasized that 100% of other countries must join in applying pressure to Iran and that anything less would not result in a positive outcome. Sheikh Abdullah also expressed concern that Iran could use its wealth and resources to &buy8 votes in the United Nations. Both MbR and Sheikh Abdullah told U/S Bolton they were pleased that the elections in Iraq had proceeded as scheduled because this dealt a blow to the Iraqi insurgency. End summary.
MbR Urges Continued Pressure on Iran
-------------- --------------
2. (S) In a meeting with UAE Minister of Defense and Dubai Crown Prince Mohammed bin Rashid al Maktoum (MbR),U/S Bolton expressed the USG,s grave concern about Iran,s nuclear weapons and ballistic missile development, stating that the USG believes the threat is sufficient to refer the matter to the UN Security Council, particularly if there is no progress on the diplomatic front over the next few months. U/S Bolton stated that Iran has made a clear strategic decision to acquire nuclear weapons and that when Iran,s nuclear development is combined with their ballistic missile program, Iran,s assertion that their nuclear program is &purely civilian8 is not credible. The Iranians, he continued, burn off as waste enough natural gas to replace the power that would be produced at four nuclear power plants the size of Bushehr. In addition, Iranian scientists are conducting research into how to givethe Shehab missile a nuclear capability. U/S Bolton also pointed out that there is broad concern in the international community, given Iran,s support for terrorist organizations, that Iran could make nuclear materials or nuclear weapons available to terrorist groups.
MbR emphasized that the UAE is also concerned about Iran,s nuclear program but acknowledged that dealing with Iran is difficult. The UAE has talked to the Iranians and he strongly advised that the international community continue to apply diplomatic pressure on Iran. He said he did not think Iran would give up their enrichment program without external pressure.
3. (S) U/S Bolton pointed out that interdiction efforts, such as those through the Proliferation Security Initiative, are essential. U/S Bolton told MbR that he appreciates the excellent cooperation of the UAE on interdiction of missile related shipments. MbR responded that he is committed to continuing this cooperation on diversions of proliferation goods through Dubai, as well as cooperating on terrorist financing issues. He cited recent interdictions involving shipments to Iran and Pakistan originating in China and Russia.
4. (S) Dubai State Security Director Mohammed al Qamzi pointed out that it was not in the interest of Dubai to allow proliferation-related trade. The UAE wants to pursue a nonproliferation agenda, he continued, but other countries in the region do not always appreciate these efforts. Al Qamzi reported that the UAEG had identified approximately 15 Iranian front companies that have been involved in transshipment of WMD related goods through Dubai. The UAEG has closed down six of these companies and is working incrementally to close down the others. The Iranians may have figured out what is going on, he said, because Dubai is beginning to see a reduction in such activities.
5. (S) MbR praised the elections in Iraq, saying the vote dealt a setback to the terrorists. He expressed concern about the non-participation of Sunni Muslims in Iraq, saying that if they do not come forward to participate in voting and governing, Iraq will never be safe.
UAE Minister Voices UAE Concerns about Iran
--------------
6. (S) U/S Bolton also met with Minister of Information Abdullah bin Zayed al Nahyan, who hosted a luncheon in U/S Bolton,s honor in lieu of UAE Deputy Prime Minister/ Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Sheikh Hamdan, who was out of the country. U/S Bolton emphasized to Sheikh Abdullah that Iran,s assertion that its nuclear program is for civil power generation is not acceptable, again pointing out that Iran burns off enough natural gas to equal the power that would be produced by the equivalent of four Bushehr nuclear power plants. Sheikh Abdullah was well aware that Iran has substantial oil and gas reserves, pointing out that in recent years Iran,s oil reserves have been revised upward from 89 billion barrels to 128 billion barrels and that Iran,s natural gas reserves now stand at 940 trillion cubic feet.
7. (S) U/S Bolton emphasized that this issue should not be characterized as the U.S. versus Iran but as Iran versus the rest of the world and asked for Sheikh Abdullah,s thoughts and ideas on how to deal with the nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs in Iran. Sheikh Abdullah said that Iran is very different from Iraq and acknowledged the challenge of dealing with Iran. He remarked that the success in dealing with Libya,s nuclear ambitions was due in part to the multilateral sanctions imposed on Libya.. Sheikh Abdullah characterized the threat posed by Iran to the UAE as serious, saying that Iran could harm the national security interests of the U.S. but would destroy the UAE.
8. (S) U/S Bolton told Sheikh Abdullah that it was possible that later in the spring the U.S. Security Council would have to take up the issue of Iran,s nuclear program if diplomatic efforts failed. Sheikh Abdullah wondered if there was a precedent for the IAEA referring a country to the UN Security Council (to which U/S Bolton replied in the affirmative, citing Libya, Romania, and North Korea) and also wondered if a group other than the British, French and the U.S. would have more success in diplomatic efforts. He expressed concern that Iran would use its wealth and enormous energy resources as a way to &buy8 votes in the UN. Sheikh Abdullah said the only way forward was to put pressure on the other parties involved in Iran,s nuclear program (e.g., the Russians and the Chinese) to refrain from participating in the projects. Sheikh Abdullah said he did not believe, however, that the international community could get a commitment from the Iranians that can be trusted. . U/S Bolton passed Sheikh Abdullah two papers, one on &Options for dealing with Iran,s Nuclear Program in the UN Security Council8 and one listing &Unanswered Questions8 on the Iranian nuclear program.
9. (S) Sheik Abdullah asked about the cooperation we were getting from Pakistan in halting their work with Iran. U/S Bolton replied that the AQ Khan network had essentially been destroyed but there is concern some may still be out there, possibly including other customers. U/S Bolton also said that it is important to continue to examine the AQ Khan network to ensure that we know as much as possible about what countries like Iran were able to obtain through the network.
Ambassador expressed appreciation for the UAE,s past cooperation on the AQ Khan network and emphasized that we were looking forward to future cooperation so that we would know what the network transshipped through the UAE.
10. (S) Sheikh Abdullah praised the Iraqi elections. He had been very worried about the success of the elections but was glad to see they went well. Sheikh Abdullah thought the voting turnout was a big blow for &Zarqawi and his thugs8, saying also that 90% of all registered Iraqi voters in the UAE cast their ballots. He believed that most Iraqis who did not participate held back out of concerns for their safety.
11. (U) U/S Bolton also met with print journalists in Abu Dhabi and granted an interview to Al Arabiya satellite television. The questions and answers focused on Iran and Iraq.
12. (U) U/S Bolton has cleared this cable.
SISON
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/04/2015
TAGS: ETTC IR IZ KNNP PARM PK TC
SUBJECT: U/S BOLTON VISITS UAE
Classified By: Ambassador Michele Sison for Reasons 1.5(b) and (d)
1. (S) Summary: Under Secretary of State for Arms Control and International Security John Bolton met with UAE officials on January 31 to discuss the status of Iran,s nuclear weapons programs and to present future options for addressing the threat on the UAE,s doorstep, including referral to the U.N. Security Council. UAEG officials were very supportive of continuing diplomatic efforts to eliminate the threat presented to the UAE, the region and the world by an Iranian nuclear weapons program. Defense Minister/Dubai Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid (MbR) strongly supported continuing diplomatic efforts, saying that any use of force against Iran would result in retaliation of one sort or another. In addition, Dubai officials reported progress in closing down Iranian front companies located in Dubai that have assisted in the Iranian WMD acquisition programs.
Minister of Information Abdullah bin Zayed al Nahyan emphasized that 100% of other countries must join in applying pressure to Iran and that anything less would not result in a positive outcome. Sheikh Abdullah also expressed concern that Iran could use its wealth and resources to &buy8 votes in the United Nations. Both MbR and Sheikh Abdullah told U/S Bolton they were pleased that the elections in Iraq had proceeded as scheduled because this dealt a blow to the Iraqi insurgency. End summary.
MbR Urges Continued Pressure on Iran
-------------- --------------
2. (S) In a meeting with UAE Minister of Defense and Dubai Crown Prince Mohammed bin Rashid al Maktoum (MbR),U/S Bolton expressed the USG,s grave concern about Iran,s nuclear weapons and ballistic missile development, stating that the USG believes the threat is sufficient to refer the matter to the UN Security Council, particularly if there is no progress on the diplomatic front over the next few months. U/S Bolton stated that Iran has made a clear strategic decision to acquire nuclear weapons and that when Iran,s nuclear development is combined with their ballistic missile program, Iran,s assertion that their nuclear program is &purely civilian8 is not credible. The Iranians, he continued, burn off as waste enough natural gas to replace the power that would be produced at four nuclear power plants the size of Bushehr. In addition, Iranian scientists are conducting research into how to givethe Shehab missile a nuclear capability. U/S Bolton also pointed out that there is broad concern in the international community, given Iran,s support for terrorist organizations, that Iran could make nuclear materials or nuclear weapons available to terrorist groups.
MbR emphasized that the UAE is also concerned about Iran,s nuclear program but acknowledged that dealing with Iran is difficult. The UAE has talked to the Iranians and he strongly advised that the international community continue to apply diplomatic pressure on Iran. He said he did not think Iran would give up their enrichment program without external pressure.
3. (S) U/S Bolton pointed out that interdiction efforts, such as those through the Proliferation Security Initiative, are essential. U/S Bolton told MbR that he appreciates the excellent cooperation of the UAE on interdiction of missile related shipments. MbR responded that he is committed to continuing this cooperation on diversions of proliferation goods through Dubai, as well as cooperating on terrorist financing issues. He cited recent interdictions involving shipments to Iran and Pakistan originating in China and Russia.
4. (S) Dubai State Security Director Mohammed al Qamzi pointed out that it was not in the interest of Dubai to allow proliferation-related trade. The UAE wants to pursue a nonproliferation agenda, he continued, but other countries in the region do not always appreciate these efforts. Al Qamzi reported that the UAEG had identified approximately 15 Iranian front companies that have been involved in transshipment of WMD related goods through Dubai. The UAEG has closed down six of these companies and is working incrementally to close down the others. The Iranians may have figured out what is going on, he said, because Dubai is beginning to see a reduction in such activities.
5. (S) MbR praised the elections in Iraq, saying the vote dealt a setback to the terrorists. He expressed concern about the non-participation of Sunni Muslims in Iraq, saying that if they do not come forward to participate in voting and governing, Iraq will never be safe.
UAE Minister Voices UAE Concerns about Iran
--------------
6. (S) U/S Bolton also met with Minister of Information Abdullah bin Zayed al Nahyan, who hosted a luncheon in U/S Bolton,s honor in lieu of UAE Deputy Prime Minister/ Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Sheikh Hamdan, who was out of the country. U/S Bolton emphasized to Sheikh Abdullah that Iran,s assertion that its nuclear program is for civil power generation is not acceptable, again pointing out that Iran burns off enough natural gas to equal the power that would be produced by the equivalent of four Bushehr nuclear power plants. Sheikh Abdullah was well aware that Iran has substantial oil and gas reserves, pointing out that in recent years Iran,s oil reserves have been revised upward from 89 billion barrels to 128 billion barrels and that Iran,s natural gas reserves now stand at 940 trillion cubic feet.
7. (S) U/S Bolton emphasized that this issue should not be characterized as the U.S. versus Iran but as Iran versus the rest of the world and asked for Sheikh Abdullah,s thoughts and ideas on how to deal with the nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs in Iran. Sheikh Abdullah said that Iran is very different from Iraq and acknowledged the challenge of dealing with Iran. He remarked that the success in dealing with Libya,s nuclear ambitions was due in part to the multilateral sanctions imposed on Libya.. Sheikh Abdullah characterized the threat posed by Iran to the UAE as serious, saying that Iran could harm the national security interests of the U.S. but would destroy the UAE.
8. (S) U/S Bolton told Sheikh Abdullah that it was possible that later in the spring the U.S. Security Council would have to take up the issue of Iran,s nuclear program if diplomatic efforts failed. Sheikh Abdullah wondered if there was a precedent for the IAEA referring a country to the UN Security Council (to which U/S Bolton replied in the affirmative, citing Libya, Romania, and North Korea) and also wondered if a group other than the British, French and the U.S. would have more success in diplomatic efforts. He expressed concern that Iran would use its wealth and enormous energy resources as a way to &buy8 votes in the UN. Sheikh Abdullah said the only way forward was to put pressure on the other parties involved in Iran,s nuclear program (e.g., the Russians and the Chinese) to refrain from participating in the projects. Sheikh Abdullah said he did not believe, however, that the international community could get a commitment from the Iranians that can be trusted. . U/S Bolton passed Sheikh Abdullah two papers, one on &Options for dealing with Iran,s Nuclear Program in the UN Security Council8 and one listing &Unanswered Questions8 on the Iranian nuclear program.
9. (S) Sheik Abdullah asked about the cooperation we were getting from Pakistan in halting their work with Iran. U/S Bolton replied that the AQ Khan network had essentially been destroyed but there is concern some may still be out there, possibly including other customers. U/S Bolton also said that it is important to continue to examine the AQ Khan network to ensure that we know as much as possible about what countries like Iran were able to obtain through the network.
Ambassador expressed appreciation for the UAE,s past cooperation on the AQ Khan network and emphasized that we were looking forward to future cooperation so that we would know what the network transshipped through the UAE.
10. (S) Sheikh Abdullah praised the Iraqi elections. He had been very worried about the success of the elections but was glad to see they went well. Sheikh Abdullah thought the voting turnout was a big blow for &Zarqawi and his thugs8, saying also that 90% of all registered Iraqi voters in the UAE cast their ballots. He believed that most Iraqis who did not participate held back out of concerns for their safety.
11. (U) U/S Bolton also met with print journalists in Abu Dhabi and granted an interview to Al Arabiya satellite television. The questions and answers focused on Iran and Iraq.
12. (U) U/S Bolton has cleared this cable.
SISON