Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
09NEWDELHI1328
2009-06-26 12:30:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy New Delhi
Cable title:
WOMEN IN THE LOK SABHA: IS IT A CHAMPAGNE MOMENT?
how-toVZCZCXRO9934 RR RUEHAST RUEHBI RUEHCI RUEHDBU RUEHLH RUEHNEH RUEHPW DE RUEHNE #1328/01 1771230 ZNR UUUUU ZZH R 261230Z JUN 09 FM AMEMBASSY NEW DELHI TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 7139 INFO RUCNCLS/ALL SOUTH AND CENTRAL ASIA COLLECTIVE RUEHBJ/AMEMBASSY BEIJING 7805 RUEHMO/AMEMBASSY MOSCOW 3542 RUEHLO/AMEMBASSY LONDON 6571 RUEHFR/AMEMBASSY PARIS 1808 RUEHRL/AMEMBASSY BERLIN 1396 RUEKJCS/SECDEF WASHDC RUEAIIA/CIA WASHDC RHEHNSC/NSC WASHDC RUEIDN/DNI WASHINGTON DC RHHMUNA/HQ USPACOM HONOLULU HI RUCNDT/USMISSION USUN NEW YORK 8239 RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA 8442 RUEKJCS/JOINT STAFF WASHDC RUMICEA/USCENTCOM INTEL CEN MACDILL AFB FL
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 NEW DELHI 001328
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV PHUM KWMN PINR KDEM IN
SUBJECT: WOMEN IN THE LOK SABHA: IS IT A CHAMPAGNE MOMENT?
REF: A) NEW DELHI 01226 B) NEW DELHI 1062
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 NEW DELHI 001328
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV PHUM KWMN PINR KDEM IN
SUBJECT: WOMEN IN THE LOK SABHA: IS IT A CHAMPAGNE MOMENT?
REF: A) NEW DELHI 01226 B) NEW DELHI 1062
1. SUMMARY: The 2009 parliamentary election highlighted the possible
emergence of women leaders in Indian politics, with the focus on
Meira Kumar as the speaker of the 15th Lok Sabha (lower house of
Parliament) along with a contingent of influential women leaders
vying for parliamentary seats. Fifty-eight of the new Lok Sabha's
543 members are women. The media and public impression is these MPs
represent the aspirations of Indian women, who represent 48 percent
of the total population. It is not clear if the new legislators
will prove to be a formidable force in Indian politics as suggested
by the media. Many of the women are descendents of powerful Indian
political families; others were "handpicked" by Rahul Gandhi and
have established ties with the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. End Summary.
--------------
PARADIGM SHIFT OR MEDIA HYPE?
--------------
2. In the run-up to April-May parliamentary elections, local media
followed closely the campaigns of Indian women leaders, representing
a broad range of experience from established politicians to
fresh-faced youngsters. The media often portrayed these candidates
as symbolizing the rise of India's women, who make up 48 percent of
the country's 1.15 billion population. Some political observers,
however, believe the "women's wave" in the 15th Lok Sabha is simply
media hype, and that the so-called wave will have a minimal effect
on the male-dominated Indian political landscape. While the 58
elected women have breached the ten percent ceiling for the first
time and are more visible in the political arena, the current Lok
Sabha has only 15 more women representatives than the previous one.
3. Prominent women's groups welcomed the election
results, but cautioned against premature jubilation. Well-known
author Shobha De cautioned, "one would like to see this as a
positive change, but it's always not about numbers. It's the
quality and commitment that count." Ranjana Kumari, President of
Women Power Connect, an umbrella organization of several hundred
women NGO's, added the "real test" is if political parties allow
these women to engage in debate on the floor of the Lok Sabha.
Kumari warned that women politicians will remain mere tokens unless
they are "integrated" into the national political mainframe.
--------------
POLITICAL LEGACIES CONTINUE
--------------
4. Most women leaders in the 15th Lok Sabha belong to families with
deep political connections. Speaker Meira Kumar is a daughter of a
former deputy Prime Minister and Dalit leader, while Praneet Kaur,
Minister of State for External affairs, is the wife of a former
Chief Minister of Punjab. Harsimrat Kaur Badal, MP from Punjab is
married to the present Deputy Chief Minister of Punjab. The "voice
of the North-East" Agatha Sangma is the daughter of a former Speaker
of the Lok Sabha and from a prominent political family in Meghalaya.
5. Many novice politicians belonging to political families with good
educational backgrounds made it to the 15th Lok Sabha. Their next
elections, as incumbents judged on performance and accomplishments
will be interesting to note. Veteran female politicians like Meira
Kumar, Krishna Tirath and Sushma Swaraj have secured spots as Lok
Sabha speaker, Minister of State (Independent Charge) for Women and
Child Development and Deputy Leader of the Opposition,
respectively.
--------------
SOME FRESH-FACED LEADERS
--------------
6. A small number of women represent their constituencies as
self-made members of parliament (MP). Meenakshi Natarajan, who
lacks an elite political pedigree, is a first time MP from Madhya
NEW DELHI 00001328 002 OF 002
Pradesh (Reftel A and B) and was handpicked by Congress General
Secretary Rahul Gandhi to run for office. Natarajan is passionate
about energizing the youth and students to join politics.. However,
Natarajan's rise from grassroots student politics represents the
exception and not the rule.
--------------
THE NORTH/SOUTH DIVIDE
--------------
7. Despite higher social and educational indicators in South India
(barring Andhra Pradesh),there was a virtual absence of women
candidates or winners from South India. Karnataka exceeds the 30
percent quota for representation of women in Panchayati Raj
institutions (local grassroots governance),but only sent one woman
to the Lok Sabha. Over the last 15 terms of the Lok Sabha, only 11
women MP's from Kerala have been nominated and elected, a clear
indication that high development indicators have not always
translated into gender equity at the political level. Tamil Nadu's
two regional parties, the All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam
(headed by a woman) and the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, nominated two
female candidates, only one of whom won her seat. Tamil freelance
author and journalist Vaasanti noted "male contenders are very
strong and women candidates are simply not allowed to go forward."
8. In comparison, five states from North India have sent 22 women
MPs to the lower house. Uttar Pradesh (U.P.),the largest state in
India and one ruled by a female chief minister, sent 12 women
members to the 15th Lok Sabha. However the role of dynastic
politics is still apparent. Amongst the winners from U.P. are three
widows, two daughters-in-law, three wives, and one daughter from
well-connected political families.
--------------
COMMENT: CAUTIOUS CELEBRATION
--------------
9. Despite the media and public attention surrounding the new batch
of female MPs, most are either handpicked by Congress General
Secretary Rahul Gandhi (Reftels A and B) or are relatives of
powerful politicians, and could simply represent a transfer of power
from within "old guard" Indian politics rather than any substantive
change. Moreover, it is not clear if these new legislators will
prove to be a formidable force in national politics. Unless their
parties give them the same opportunities to lead and participate as
male MPs, these female MPs may just remain "tokens" of the political
establishment. END COMMENT.
BURLEIGH
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV PHUM KWMN PINR KDEM IN
SUBJECT: WOMEN IN THE LOK SABHA: IS IT A CHAMPAGNE MOMENT?
REF: A) NEW DELHI 01226 B) NEW DELHI 1062
1. SUMMARY: The 2009 parliamentary election highlighted the possible
emergence of women leaders in Indian politics, with the focus on
Meira Kumar as the speaker of the 15th Lok Sabha (lower house of
Parliament) along with a contingent of influential women leaders
vying for parliamentary seats. Fifty-eight of the new Lok Sabha's
543 members are women. The media and public impression is these MPs
represent the aspirations of Indian women, who represent 48 percent
of the total population. It is not clear if the new legislators
will prove to be a formidable force in Indian politics as suggested
by the media. Many of the women are descendents of powerful Indian
political families; others were "handpicked" by Rahul Gandhi and
have established ties with the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. End Summary.
--------------
PARADIGM SHIFT OR MEDIA HYPE?
--------------
2. In the run-up to April-May parliamentary elections, local media
followed closely the campaigns of Indian women leaders, representing
a broad range of experience from established politicians to
fresh-faced youngsters. The media often portrayed these candidates
as symbolizing the rise of India's women, who make up 48 percent of
the country's 1.15 billion population. Some political observers,
however, believe the "women's wave" in the 15th Lok Sabha is simply
media hype, and that the so-called wave will have a minimal effect
on the male-dominated Indian political landscape. While the 58
elected women have breached the ten percent ceiling for the first
time and are more visible in the political arena, the current Lok
Sabha has only 15 more women representatives than the previous one.
3. Prominent women's groups welcomed the election
results, but cautioned against premature jubilation. Well-known
author Shobha De cautioned, "one would like to see this as a
positive change, but it's always not about numbers. It's the
quality and commitment that count." Ranjana Kumari, President of
Women Power Connect, an umbrella organization of several hundred
women NGO's, added the "real test" is if political parties allow
these women to engage in debate on the floor of the Lok Sabha.
Kumari warned that women politicians will remain mere tokens unless
they are "integrated" into the national political mainframe.
--------------
POLITICAL LEGACIES CONTINUE
--------------
4. Most women leaders in the 15th Lok Sabha belong to families with
deep political connections. Speaker Meira Kumar is a daughter of a
former deputy Prime Minister and Dalit leader, while Praneet Kaur,
Minister of State for External affairs, is the wife of a former
Chief Minister of Punjab. Harsimrat Kaur Badal, MP from Punjab is
married to the present Deputy Chief Minister of Punjab. The "voice
of the North-East" Agatha Sangma is the daughter of a former Speaker
of the Lok Sabha and from a prominent political family in Meghalaya.
5. Many novice politicians belonging to political families with good
educational backgrounds made it to the 15th Lok Sabha. Their next
elections, as incumbents judged on performance and accomplishments
will be interesting to note. Veteran female politicians like Meira
Kumar, Krishna Tirath and Sushma Swaraj have secured spots as Lok
Sabha speaker, Minister of State (Independent Charge) for Women and
Child Development and Deputy Leader of the Opposition,
respectively.
--------------
SOME FRESH-FACED LEADERS
--------------
6. A small number of women represent their constituencies as
self-made members of parliament (MP). Meenakshi Natarajan, who
lacks an elite political pedigree, is a first time MP from Madhya
NEW DELHI 00001328 002 OF 002
Pradesh (Reftel A and B) and was handpicked by Congress General
Secretary Rahul Gandhi to run for office. Natarajan is passionate
about energizing the youth and students to join politics.. However,
Natarajan's rise from grassroots student politics represents the
exception and not the rule.
--------------
THE NORTH/SOUTH DIVIDE
--------------
7. Despite higher social and educational indicators in South India
(barring Andhra Pradesh),there was a virtual absence of women
candidates or winners from South India. Karnataka exceeds the 30
percent quota for representation of women in Panchayati Raj
institutions (local grassroots governance),but only sent one woman
to the Lok Sabha. Over the last 15 terms of the Lok Sabha, only 11
women MP's from Kerala have been nominated and elected, a clear
indication that high development indicators have not always
translated into gender equity at the political level. Tamil Nadu's
two regional parties, the All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam
(headed by a woman) and the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, nominated two
female candidates, only one of whom won her seat. Tamil freelance
author and journalist Vaasanti noted "male contenders are very
strong and women candidates are simply not allowed to go forward."
8. In comparison, five states from North India have sent 22 women
MPs to the lower house. Uttar Pradesh (U.P.),the largest state in
India and one ruled by a female chief minister, sent 12 women
members to the 15th Lok Sabha. However the role of dynastic
politics is still apparent. Amongst the winners from U.P. are three
widows, two daughters-in-law, three wives, and one daughter from
well-connected political families.
--------------
COMMENT: CAUTIOUS CELEBRATION
--------------
9. Despite the media and public attention surrounding the new batch
of female MPs, most are either handpicked by Congress General
Secretary Rahul Gandhi (Reftels A and B) or are relatives of
powerful politicians, and could simply represent a transfer of power
from within "old guard" Indian politics rather than any substantive
change. Moreover, it is not clear if these new legislators will
prove to be a formidable force in national politics. Unless their
parties give them the same opportunities to lead and participate as
male MPs, these female MPs may just remain "tokens" of the political
establishment. END COMMENT.
BURLEIGH