Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
09NAPLES64
2009-05-22 19:34:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Consulate Naples
Cable title:  

LAMPEDUSA: THE TINY ITALIAN ISLAND THAT LOOMS LARGE FOR

Tags:  PREF PHUM PREL SMIG PGOV PBTS PHSA UNHCR IT LY 
pdf how-to read a cable
VZCZCXRO1437
RR RUEHAG RUEHAST RUEHDA RUEHDBU RUEHDF RUEHFL RUEHIK RUEHKW RUEHLA
RUEHLN RUEHLZ RUEHPOD RUEHROV RUEHSK RUEHSR RUEHVK RUEHYG
DE RUEHNP #0064/01 1421934
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
R 221934Z MAY 09
FM AMCONSUL NAPLES
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 6403
INFO RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE
RUEHMIL/AMCONSUL MILAN 0164
RUEHFL/AMCONSUL FLORENCE 0136
RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA 0001
RUCNDT/USMISSION USUN NEW YORK 0001
RUEHTRO/AMEMBASSY TRIPOLI 0001
RUEHVT/AMEMBASSY VALLETTA 0004
RUEHNP/AMCONSUL NAPLES 1154
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 NAPLES 000064 

SENSITIVE
SIPDIS

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PREF PHUM PREL SMIG PGOV PBTS PHSA UNHCR IT LY
MT
SUBJECT: LAMPEDUSA: THE TINY ITALIAN ISLAND THAT LOOMS LARGE FOR
MIGRANTS AND REFUGEES

REF: A) TRIPOLI 391 (NOTAL),B) ROME 437, C) ROME 438, D) ROME 439

NAPLES 00000064 001.2 OF 004


Sensitive - Handle Accordingly



UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 NAPLES 000064

SENSITIVE
SIPDIS

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PREF PHUM PREL SMIG PGOV PBTS PHSA UNHCR IT LY
MT
SUBJECT: LAMPEDUSA: THE TINY ITALIAN ISLAND THAT LOOMS LARGE FOR
MIGRANTS AND REFUGEES

REF: A) TRIPOLI 391 (NOTAL),B) ROME 437, C) ROME 438, D) ROME 439

NAPLES 00000064 001.2 OF 004


Sensitive - Handle Accordingly




1. (SBU) Summary: During a May 13 visit to Italy's
southernmost territory, the island of Lampedusa, we observed a
well-run migrant detention center that provides humane
treatment, food and medical care to those who arrive by boat
from North Africa. While the camp has suffered from severe
overcrowding in recent years, the GOI's controversial new policy
of turning migrant boats back to Libya before they reach Italian
waters meant the center had only a couple dozen detainees during
our visit. Housing conditions are austere and in bad shape,
especially following arson by inmates in February that destroyed
over 40 percent of the available beds. The outspoken mayor was
highly critical of the GOI's policies, asserting that
Lampedusans are outraged with Premier Berlusconi. The UNHCR is
extremely critical of the push-back policy, noting that Libya is
not a party to the UN Refugee Convention; authorities told us
that women arrive on Lampedusa asserting they were raped and
mistreated in Libyan detention centers. Following our visit,
DefMin La Russa controversially criticized the UNHCR as
worthless. It is likely that some bona fide refugees will be
unable to have asylum claims processed. Embassy Rome septel
will report on changes to Italian immigration law that will
further affect conditions on Lampedusa and other migrant holding
centers.



An Island Closer to Africa than Europe

-------------- --




2. (U) The tiny, windswept island of Lampedusa is Italy's
southernmost territory. The 9.8-square-mile land mass is only
70 miles from Tunisia and 127 miles from Sicily; geologically,
it is part of Africa. Its 6,720 residents subsist mainly on
fishing and tourism; in recent years, Lampedusa has averaged
100,000 tourists per year. Due to its proximity to North

Africa, it is also an entry point for seaborne migrants. In
2008, around 33,000 arrived by boat, and so far in 2009 there
have been around 6,000 arrivals. Virtually all of those voyages
embarked from Libya. Until 1992, the U.S Navy maintained a
small communications base on the island.



Mayor: Lampedusans Oppose GOI Policies, Smell a Rat in
Italy-Libya Accord

-------------- --------------
--------------




3. (SBU) The outspoken mayor of Lampedusa, Bernardino De
Rubeis, was highly critical of the GOI's immigration policies
when we met him on the island May 13. Like many Italian
politicians, De Rubeis has changed party affiliation several
times; he is currently a member of the Sicily-based Movement for
Autonomy, which is in alliance with Premier Silvio Berlusconi's
People of Liberty Party. The central government's decision to
toughen immigration laws -- including making irregular
immigration a punishable crime, and extending the allowable
detention time of illegal immigrants from two to six months
(septel) -- has outraged De Rubeis and his fellow Lampedusans.
The mayor recounted that since desperate migrants began arriving
on the island in large numbers seventeen years ago, Lampedusans
have received them with open arms. The government's pursuit of
anti-immigrant policies, spurred by Berlusconi's coalition
partner, the Northern League, is totally at odds with
Lampedusa's tradition of dealing with the humanitarian issue.
Five thousand residents turned out for a recent protest against
the new policies, De Rubeis told us.




4. (SBU) De Rubeis also condemned Libyan leader Muammar
al-Gaddafi as unreliable and irresponsible. He scoffed at an
August 2008 agreement under which Italy and Libya will soon

NAPLES 00000064 002.2 OF 004


begin joint patrols to interdict migrant boats departing Libyan
territory, speculating that al-Gaddafi and Berlusconi had made a
secret deal that such operations would only be enforced until
after the June 6-7 European Parliament elections. (Comment: He
did not elaborate on what benefit al-Gaddafi might obtain from
such a deal. End comment.) De Rubeis also blasted as inhumane
the GOI's new policy of turning interdicted migrant boats back
to Libya before they reach Italian territory (ref A).



Conditions at the Center: Humane, But Housing in Bad Shape

-------------- --------------
--------------




5. (U) The migrant detention center, now designated by the GOI
as a Center for Identification and Expulsion, is overseen by the
Interior Ministry. Most of the migrants arriving on the island
spend less than a week there, after which they are moved to
larger centers in Caltanissetta (Sicily) or Crotone (Calabria).
The majority of arrivals come from Tunisia, Somalia, Eritrea and
Nigeria, though there are also significant numbers from Mali,
Morocco, Algeria, Egypt, Pakistan and India. Around 75 percent
of the arrivals request asylum, and around half of those receive
some form of protection. Economic migrants, once identified,
are presented with orders to voluntarily depart Italy. Few
return to their countries of origin; most move on to other EU
states (particularly France, Germany, Netherlands and
Scandinavian countries),while some stay illegally in Italy.
Forced repatriation is rare, according to the IOM.




6. (U) At times over the past two years, overcrowding at the
detention center has become so severe that states of emergency
were declared, and NGOs severely criticized conditions there.
In January, 2009 the UNHCR expressed concern over the cramped
conditions, noting that many detainees were sleeping on the
ground under plastic sheets, and in March Amnesty International
decried conditions at the center as "inhumane," and charged that
migrants were not getting a fair hearing on refugee claims. Our
visit to the center coincided with the GOI's new policy of
turning back interdicted migrant boats to Libya, so there were
only about two dozen male detainees at the center when we
arrived -- a far cry from only three months ago, when 2,000
people were jammed into a camp built for 850.




7. (U) Care of the inmates has been contracted to a private
organization that provides round-the-clock medical attention and
food. All migrants are screened by physicians on arrival; many
are treated for shock, sunstroke, dehydration and infections
from the voyage. Police are on hand to provide security and to
identify the migrants and their country of origin, a process
that is often unsuccessful. The UNHCR, IOM, Red Cross, Doctors
Without Borders and Save The Children all maintain a presence at
the center. Inmates also receive clothes and a weekly phone
card worth five euros. There are a number of interpreters who
speak Arabic, French, English and other languages.




8. (SBU) Our impression is that migrants are treated humanely.
Women and children are held at a separate center that we did not
see (at the former U.S. Navy base),but the UNHCR and IOM
representatives did not report any problems there. The main
problem with the center is the housing conditions: aluminum
shelters hold around twelve bunk beds with thin foam mattresses
in cramped rooms. Detainees have ripped out lighting fixtures
and covered the walls with graffiti. And in February of this
year, a group of reportedly Tunisian migrants set fire to part
of the camp, destroying a shelter that held 330 beds (now only
473 remain, though the burned pavilion is being rebuilt and
should be completed in July). Occasionally inmates escape from
the center, but return when they realize they are on a small
island and the camp is their only option.



UNHCR Blasts Push-Back Policy

NAPLES 00000064 003.2 OF 004



--------------




9. (SBU) The IOM and UNHCR representatives told us that there
are no incentives to keep illegal economic migrants from
entering Italy. Many of those who arrive on Lampedusa are never
positively identified, and the diplomatic and consular officials
of the countries of origin are generally uncooperative. As
noted above, when their detention period is over (two months
until now),most migrants ignore expulsion orders and disappear
-- many to other EU countries, some to other parts of Italy. A
number of unaccompanied minors (virtually all males between 16
and 18 years old) also vanish; while some NGOs have expressed
concern about this, IOM is convinced that these young people
flee to find work and are probably not victims of traffickers.
Forced repatriation is rare due to budget constraints and the
difficulty in determining nationalities.




10. (SBU) The UNHCR is deeply concerned over the new policy of
turning migrant boats back to Libya, noting that Libya is not a
party to the 1951 United Nations Refugee Convention and does not
have a national asylum policy in place. Both Italian
authorities at the camp and UNHCR/IOM personnel told us that
many women arrive on Lampedusa complaining they had been raped
and/or mistreated at Libyan migrant detention facilities. A few
days after our visit, the head of the UNHCR office in Rome,
Laura Boldrini, condemned the new policy and complained that the
High Commission's unofficial representatives in Libya do not
have access to all of Libya's holding camps. DefMin Ignazio La
Russa responded publicly during a May 17 visit to Tripoli that
the UNHCR "is not worth a dried fig," and accused Boldrini of
being an "inhuman or criminal Communist." This prompted the UN
High Commissioner, Antonio Guterres, to blast La Russa for an
"unacceptable personal attack." This was followed by
Berlusconi's assertion to the media May 19 that it is more
humane to push the migrants back to Libya because Italian
holding centers are "like concentration camps." The Vatican has
also criticized the push-back policy, and publicly expressed its
concern over the scourge of human trafficking.



Coast Guard Has Saved Thousands

--------------




11. (U) Our final meeting on Lampedusa was with the local Coast
Guard commander, Achille Selleri, who after two years in his
post was clearly overwhelmed by the human tide that had arrived
in his corner of the world. "I have seen things I never
imagined," he told us, referring to the desperation of the
thousands of people whose lives he and his subordinates had
saved on the high seas. He observed that 95 percent of the
Coast Guard's operations in Lampedusa involved humanitarian
rescue. He refused to opine on the political decision to turn
migrant boats back, but he was clearly proud of his team's
rescue of over 44,000 seaborne migrants in the past two years,
almost all of whom he believed would otherwise have perished in
unseaworthy vessels and dinghies. He said it was impossible to
know how many people drown trying to make the voyage, but
guessed that there were a lot who went undetected and never made
it to shore. Selleri noted that he had no direct contact with
his Maltese counterpart; all such contact takes place through
higher channels. Comment: This is an issue because Malta and
Italy have frequently argued over which country is responsible
for receiving migrants that are rescued in one or the other's
agreed-upon search-and-rescue (SAR) area. Only a week prior to
our visit, the GOI blocked a Maltese vessel carrying rescued
migrants from docking at Lampedusa, and a diplomatic spat ensued
in which each country asserted that the other should receive the
migrants (who were picked up in Malta's SAR zone but were closer
to Lampedusa).




12. (SBU) Comment: Embassy Rome is preparing a septel on the
implications of the GOI's new immigration policies. Since the
recent push-back of migrant boats to Libya, there have been no

NAPLES 00000064 004.2 OF 004


further embarkations toward Lampedusa. If nothing else, this
will give the holding center the opportunity to repair and
rebuild the damage from the February riots. Nonetheless, no one
on Lampedusa supports the push-back policy or the proposals to
change immigration laws. Most believe that the EU needs to
develop a common policy for dealing with seaborne migrants and
to allocate funding to deal with the phenomenon. In the
meantime, it is possible that people fleeing war and persecution
will be unable to find asylum. And pushing migrants back to
Libya may turn out to be akin to trying to turn back the ocean
tides.
TRUHN