Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
09DHAKA233
2009-03-04 10:54:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy Dhaka
Cable title:
BANGLADESH: SOME UNREGULATED MADRASSAS OPEN TO
how-toVZCZCXYZ0007 OO RUEHWEB DE RUEHKA #0233/01 0631054 ZNR UUUUU ZZH (CCY AD397558 MSI3944-695) O 041054Z MAR 09 FM AMEMBASSY DHAKA TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 8404 INFO RUCNCLS/ALL SOUTH AND CENTRAL ASIA COLLECTIVE PRIORITY RUCNISL/ISLAMIC COLLECTIVE PRIORITY RUEHLO/AMEMBASSY LONDON PRIORITY 2002 RHHMUNA/CDR USPACOM HONOLULU HI PRIORITY RHHJJPI/PACOM IDHS HONOLULU HI PRIORITY
UNCLAS DHAKA 000233
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
C O R R E C T E D COPY CAPTION
DEPARTMENT FOR USAID
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV PINS PTER EDU BG
SUBJECT: BANGLADESH: SOME UNREGULATED MADRASSAS OPEN TO
GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT
------
SUMMARY
-------
UNCLAS DHAKA 000233
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
C O R R E C T E D COPY CAPTION
DEPARTMENT FOR USAID
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV PINS PTER EDU BG
SUBJECT: BANGLADESH: SOME UNREGULATED MADRASSAS OPEN TO
GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT
--------------
SUMMARY
--------------
1. (SBU) PolOff visited three madrassa religious schools not
regulated by the government on 2/24 and found educators
willing to accept some official oversight. They all expressed
deep concern that without adopting government-approved
curricula their students would continue to fail to qualify
for mainstream institutions of higher education and face
bleak job prospects. The visits suggested that Post's 1207
proposal to support increased government regulation and
oversight of madrassas would have a receptive audience among
the targeted schools. Helping the Government of Bangladesh
introduce an official secular curriculum to non-regulated
religious schools should help reduce the allure of Islamic
extremism by expanding opportunities for students to become
productive members of society.
-------------- -
QUOMI MADRASSAS: FILLING THE GAPS IN EDUCATION
-------------- -
2. (SBU) Qawmi madrassas are non-regulated private religious
schools that do not receive government support, in contrast
to Alia madrassas, which are nominally state-regulated and
receive some state funding. (Note: "Qawmi" is just one of
several alternative spellings for the non-regulated
madrassas. End note.) Estimates of the number of Qawmi
madrassas in Bangladesh range widely from 23,000 to 57,000;
their frequent offers of free room, board and tuition are
hard for many parents in this poverty-stricken country to
turn down. Still, murky funding, sometime inflammatory
teaching materials, and -- in some cases -- connections with
radically conservative elements indicate the Government of
Bangladesh has abdicated an important role by failing to
regulate the Qawmi madrassas. Perhaps even more important,
Qawmi madrassa courses typically do not prepare students with
marketable skills and leave them unqualified to enter
mainstream institutions of higher education.
-------------- --
QAWMI EDUCATORS ACKNOWLEDGE CURRICULUM PROBLEMS
-------------- --
3. (SBU) PolOff on 2/24 visited three all-male Qawmi
madrassas in Rajshahi city and its environs in northwest
Bangladesh. All three campuses appeared tranquil and their
senior educators were exceedingly friendly. The first, Jamia
Islamia Shah Makhdum Madrassa, is in central Rajshahi along
the banks of the slow-moving Padma (Ganges) River. Orphans
and children from poor families account for most of its 232
students; school funding comes from community contributions
and monthly donations from an affiliated, prosperous shrine.
The second, Rajshahi Darul Ulum Madrasa, has only 32
students, a drop from more than 300 caused by a sharp
downturn in support from local benefactors due to tough
economic times. The fish pond and mango grove that provide a
pastoral setting for the rural school, a 10-minute drive
outside Rajshahi, generate income to keep the school from
closing. The third, Kaderia Bakhshia Anwarul Ulum Madrassa,
has 150 students living on its sprawling campus next to a
children's amusement park. Donations from followers of an
Islamic saint buried on the madrassa grounds, including some
from India and Pakistan, supplement student fees of about $6
a month for tuition and food.
4. (SBU) Principals and headmasters from all three madrassas
decried the dearth of job and education opportunities
awaiting their students. Mufti Shahadat Ali, principal at the
madrassa on the Padma, said most of his graduates became
religious teachers. None had gone on to university except a
few who first attended a government-regulated Alia madrassa.
Principal Saifuddin at the rural madrassah, which provides
education through seventh grade, said the only options for
his students were to move on to another madrassa or become a
religious teacher. "There aren't many choices," he said while
twirling his black-and-gray beard. "Many people are losing
interest in sending their children to Qawmi madrassas," added
Mazhrul Islam, headmaster at the third school. "It's hard to
get jobs."
5. (SBU) All three madrassas have incorporated at least some
non-religious courses into their curriculum, most commonly
Bangla language, English, mathematics, science and social
studies. Jamia Islamia madrassa said it offered
extracurricular computer courses to its eldest students as
well. But the quality of the education appeared suspect at
best. The English textbook for fifth grade students at Jamia
Islamia used colonial-era language and was a jumble of poor
grammar and punctuation. At Kaderia madrassa, a 12-year-old
who said, in Bangla, that his favorite class was English did
not appear to understand simple questions asked by PolOff.
Even when prompted in Bangla, he did not say a single word in
English.
6. (SBU) To varying degrees, educators at all three schools
expressed a desire to come under state guidance. Although
they expressed concern that adopting government curriculum
could dilute the Islamic education, they said they had no
other recourse. "We fear losing some of the emphasis on
religion," acknowledged Mazhrul Islam. Yet he said
administrators of his madrassa decided in January to convert
to a government-regulated Alia school. He explained: "We are
trying to educate our children in the Koran and Hadith (the
words and deeds of the Prophet Mohammad),but we also want
them to get government jobs and other opportunities."
-------------- --------------
CONCLUSION: A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR 1207 SPENDING
-------------- --------------
7. (SBU) While visits to three Qawmi madrassas admittedly can
provide only anecdotal insight, there can be little doubt
that many unregulated religious schools are receptive to
government oversight. Madrassa receptivity to curriculum
reform will be gauged during a March visit by three American
Islamic educators. Post's 1207 proposal is designed to
support increased regulation of Qawmi madrassas by, among
many steps, introducing a minimum secular curriculum and by
training oversight boards. The proposal would focus on the
Rajshahi region, where Islamic extremist groups typically
have made the strongest inroads. Upon leaving the Jamia
Islamia madrassa, PolOff was surprised when the principal
engulfed him in a warm, five-second bear hug. That's at least
one madrassa educator who does not find distasteful the
prospect of USG assistance in helping establish a credible
secular curriculum.
MORIARTY
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
C O R R E C T E D COPY CAPTION
DEPARTMENT FOR USAID
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV PINS PTER EDU BG
SUBJECT: BANGLADESH: SOME UNREGULATED MADRASSAS OPEN TO
GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT
--------------
SUMMARY
--------------
1. (SBU) PolOff visited three madrassa religious schools not
regulated by the government on 2/24 and found educators
willing to accept some official oversight. They all expressed
deep concern that without adopting government-approved
curricula their students would continue to fail to qualify
for mainstream institutions of higher education and face
bleak job prospects. The visits suggested that Post's 1207
proposal to support increased government regulation and
oversight of madrassas would have a receptive audience among
the targeted schools. Helping the Government of Bangladesh
introduce an official secular curriculum to non-regulated
religious schools should help reduce the allure of Islamic
extremism by expanding opportunities for students to become
productive members of society.
-------------- -
QUOMI MADRASSAS: FILLING THE GAPS IN EDUCATION
-------------- -
2. (SBU) Qawmi madrassas are non-regulated private religious
schools that do not receive government support, in contrast
to Alia madrassas, which are nominally state-regulated and
receive some state funding. (Note: "Qawmi" is just one of
several alternative spellings for the non-regulated
madrassas. End note.) Estimates of the number of Qawmi
madrassas in Bangladesh range widely from 23,000 to 57,000;
their frequent offers of free room, board and tuition are
hard for many parents in this poverty-stricken country to
turn down. Still, murky funding, sometime inflammatory
teaching materials, and -- in some cases -- connections with
radically conservative elements indicate the Government of
Bangladesh has abdicated an important role by failing to
regulate the Qawmi madrassas. Perhaps even more important,
Qawmi madrassa courses typically do not prepare students with
marketable skills and leave them unqualified to enter
mainstream institutions of higher education.
-------------- --
QAWMI EDUCATORS ACKNOWLEDGE CURRICULUM PROBLEMS
-------------- --
3. (SBU) PolOff on 2/24 visited three all-male Qawmi
madrassas in Rajshahi city and its environs in northwest
Bangladesh. All three campuses appeared tranquil and their
senior educators were exceedingly friendly. The first, Jamia
Islamia Shah Makhdum Madrassa, is in central Rajshahi along
the banks of the slow-moving Padma (Ganges) River. Orphans
and children from poor families account for most of its 232
students; school funding comes from community contributions
and monthly donations from an affiliated, prosperous shrine.
The second, Rajshahi Darul Ulum Madrasa, has only 32
students, a drop from more than 300 caused by a sharp
downturn in support from local benefactors due to tough
economic times. The fish pond and mango grove that provide a
pastoral setting for the rural school, a 10-minute drive
outside Rajshahi, generate income to keep the school from
closing. The third, Kaderia Bakhshia Anwarul Ulum Madrassa,
has 150 students living on its sprawling campus next to a
children's amusement park. Donations from followers of an
Islamic saint buried on the madrassa grounds, including some
from India and Pakistan, supplement student fees of about $6
a month for tuition and food.
4. (SBU) Principals and headmasters from all three madrassas
decried the dearth of job and education opportunities
awaiting their students. Mufti Shahadat Ali, principal at the
madrassa on the Padma, said most of his graduates became
religious teachers. None had gone on to university except a
few who first attended a government-regulated Alia madrassa.
Principal Saifuddin at the rural madrassah, which provides
education through seventh grade, said the only options for
his students were to move on to another madrassa or become a
religious teacher. "There aren't many choices," he said while
twirling his black-and-gray beard. "Many people are losing
interest in sending their children to Qawmi madrassas," added
Mazhrul Islam, headmaster at the third school. "It's hard to
get jobs."
5. (SBU) All three madrassas have incorporated at least some
non-religious courses into their curriculum, most commonly
Bangla language, English, mathematics, science and social
studies. Jamia Islamia madrassa said it offered
extracurricular computer courses to its eldest students as
well. But the quality of the education appeared suspect at
best. The English textbook for fifth grade students at Jamia
Islamia used colonial-era language and was a jumble of poor
grammar and punctuation. At Kaderia madrassa, a 12-year-old
who said, in Bangla, that his favorite class was English did
not appear to understand simple questions asked by PolOff.
Even when prompted in Bangla, he did not say a single word in
English.
6. (SBU) To varying degrees, educators at all three schools
expressed a desire to come under state guidance. Although
they expressed concern that adopting government curriculum
could dilute the Islamic education, they said they had no
other recourse. "We fear losing some of the emphasis on
religion," acknowledged Mazhrul Islam. Yet he said
administrators of his madrassa decided in January to convert
to a government-regulated Alia school. He explained: "We are
trying to educate our children in the Koran and Hadith (the
words and deeds of the Prophet Mohammad),but we also want
them to get government jobs and other opportunities."
-------------- --------------
CONCLUSION: A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR 1207 SPENDING
-------------- --------------
7. (SBU) While visits to three Qawmi madrassas admittedly can
provide only anecdotal insight, there can be little doubt
that many unregulated religious schools are receptive to
government oversight. Madrassa receptivity to curriculum
reform will be gauged during a March visit by three American
Islamic educators. Post's 1207 proposal is designed to
support increased regulation of Qawmi madrassas by, among
many steps, introducing a minimum secular curriculum and by
training oversight boards. The proposal would focus on the
Rajshahi region, where Islamic extremist groups typically
have made the strongest inroads. Upon leaving the Jamia
Islamia madrassa, PolOff was surprised when the principal
engulfed him in a warm, five-second bear hug. That's at least
one madrassa educator who does not find distasteful the
prospect of USG assistance in helping establish a credible
secular curriculum.
MORIARTY