Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
09BEIJING1520
2009-06-05 11:08:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy Beijing
Cable title:
"ESCORT OF THE YOUTH FLOWERS" - CHINA SEEKS
how-toVZCZCXRO1474 OO RUEHCN RUEHGH RUEHVC DE RUEHBJ #1520/01 1561108 ZNR UUUUU ZZH O 051108Z JUN 09 FM AMEMBASSY BEIJING TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 4354 INFO RUEHOO/CHINA POSTS COLLECTIVE RUEHIN/AIT TAIPEI 7280 RUEHKO/AMEMBASSY TOKYO 2640 RUEHUL/AMEMBASSY SEOUL 1268 RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA 2497 RUEAHLC/DHS WASHDC RUCPDOC/USDOC WASHDC RUEAWJA/DEPT OF JUSTICE WASHDC RHMCSUU/FBI WASHINGTON DC
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 BEIJING 001520
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
State for EAP/CM - SFlatt, JHabjan
State for EEB/CIP - SFlynn, FSaeed, DGross
USTR for Awinter, JMcHale, TWineland, AMain
Commerce for MAC
Commerce for ITA - IKasoff, NMelcher
DOJ for CCIPS - MDubose and SChembtob
FBI for LBryant
State for White House OSTP Ambassador Richard
Russell
NSC for Melissa Hathaway
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ETRD PGOV PHUM SOCI SCUL ECON CH
SUBJECT: "ESCORT OF THE YOUTH FLOWERS" - CHINA SEEKS
TO MANDATE INTERNET FILTERING SOFTWARE IN NEW
COMPUTERS
Ref: Beijing 1206
This cable is sensitive but unclassified. Please
handle accordingly.
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 BEIJING 001520
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
State for EAP/CM - SFlatt, JHabjan
State for EEB/CIP - SFlynn, FSaeed, DGross
USTR for Awinter, JMcHale, TWineland, AMain
Commerce for MAC
Commerce for ITA - IKasoff, NMelcher
DOJ for CCIPS - MDubose and SChembtob
FBI for LBryant
State for White House OSTP Ambassador Richard
Russell
NSC for Melissa Hathaway
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ETRD PGOV PHUM SOCI SCUL ECON CH
SUBJECT: "ESCORT OF THE YOUTH FLOWERS" - CHINA SEEKS
TO MANDATE INTERNET FILTERING SOFTWARE IN NEW
COMPUTERS
Ref: Beijing 1206
This cable is sensitive but unclassified. Please
handle accordingly.
1. (SBU) Summary: China's Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology (MIIT) on May 22 mandated
that all computers sold in China, whether imported
or manufactured domestically, be pre-installed with
"Green Dam - Escort of the Youth Flowers" Internet
filtering software effective July 1, 2009. With
little more than 30 days advance notice, the
announcement offers few details of the technical
implementation and raises transparency and market
access concerns for U.S. companies. Compliance with
this new requirement would in essence make foreign
businesses complicit with China's censorship regime,
and exposes foreign computers to potential
cybersecurity vulnerabilities. Emboffs will meet
with industry representatives on June 8 to hear
their response and proposed actions. There appears
to be early consensus to focus first on delaying the
implementation deadline and pursue discussions with
the Chinese government. End Summary.
2. (SBU) China's Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology (MIIT) on May 22 issued
Circular No. 226, a document mandating the
installation of "Green Dam - Escort of the Youth
Flowers" Internet filtering software on all new
computers, imported or made domestically, that are
sold in China beginning July 1, 2009. According to
company documents, media reports, and conversations
with Beijing-based trade association U.S.
Information Technology Office (USITO),the software
is a commercial application jointly developed by: (1)
a Beijing company that provides text and image
filtering technology for China's Great Firewall, and
(2) a Zhengzhou company with ties to a Peoples'
Liberation Army University. Functioning much like
anti-virus software, the application regularly
connects to the Internet to download a current list
of what content to block.
Protecting the Youth Flowers
--------------
3. (SBU) The Circular says that central government
agencies including MIIT, the Ministry of Finance,
and the Civilization office of the CPC Central
Committee have licensed the software to leverage the
ongoing "Special Campaign to Restore the Internet
from a State of Vulgarity" (see reftel) and to
"build a green, healthy, and harmonious network
environment and to avoid unhealthy information on
the Internet from influencing and hurting the youth."
According to a May announcement by MIIT, Green Dam
filtering software has already been installed in
2.17 million primary and middle schools in China --
80 percent of the nation's total. The mandate for
all schools to install the software, including
detailed instructions on the proper downloading and
installation of the software, was communicated on
April 1 in a joint notice from MIIT, the Ministries
of Education and Finance, and the State Council
Information Office.
U.S. Industry Concerns
--------------
BEIJING 00001520 002 OF 004
4. (SBU) Multinational computer manufacturers Apple,
Dell, and HP, and software maker Symantec told USITO
they did not learn of the Green Dam requirement
until May 26, little more than one month prior to
the proposed July 1 implementation date. HP and
Dell said they had been in contact with MIIT's
Software Service Department about the Green Dam
concept in mid-May, but at that point MIIT suggested
the program would be voluntary. The companies said
they did not receive a copy of the Circular on May
22, the publication date printed on the document
itself. Despite commitments to the United States at
the SED to publish for comment all policy documents
affecting economic issues, China has still not
posted the notice on any government website.
5. (SBU) U.S. companies have significant political
concerns that complying with the Chinese
requirements to install Green Dam software would
make them appear complicit with Chinese Government
censorship. In addition, with only 30 days to test
the software and prepare for the implementation of
the measure, U.S. businesses are worried about
apparent technical problems. For example, online
blog reports and initial compatibility tests by U.S.
companies report problems, raising concerns about
who will support users if the software causes their
computers to crash, for example. Furthermore, the
software is not currently available for Apple and
Linux operating systems. While the Circular
announces that the government will "provide free
usage to all of society" for one year, manufacturers
are concerned about who will cover the installation
costs, implementation and customer service costs,
and licensing fees beyond the first year.
6. (SBU) China's proposal to enforce the use of
filtering software violates technology neutrality
principles, reduces incentives for commercial
innovation in the marketplace, and in many cases
causes redundancies with commercial software already
offered for sale with many computers. By
maintaining a potentially constant connection with
the Internet to download software updates, the
software conceivably provides Chinese censors a
finer tool with which to monitor user behavior and
block content. It also creates vulnerabilities in
the form of a "back door" that could expose
computers to covert control by third parties,
malicious attacks, or spying.
Strong Support from Government
--------------
7. (SBU) Based on its meetings with member companies
and with MIIT, USITO tells us there is great
political pressure within the Chinese government to
implement the Green Dam program. This is attributed
partly to support for the new software's
installation by Politburo Standing Committee Member
Li Changchun, who has authority over the regime's
propaganda system.
8. (SBU) Following is an unofficial translation of
the MIIT circular prepared by the U.S. Information
Technology Office:
BEGIN TEXT
Ministry of Industry and Information Technology
BEIJING 00001520 003.2 OF 004
Circular
MIIT Software [2009] No. 226
Notice Concerning the Computer Pre-Installation of
Green Internet Filter Software
To Relevant Agencies/Companies:
In order to build a green, healthy, and harmonious
network environment and to avoid unhealthy
information on the Internet from influencing and
hurting the youth, the Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology (MIIT),the Communist Party
of China Culture and Civilization Office, and the
Ministry of Finance (MOF),in accordance with the
relevant requirements of P.R.C Government
Procurement Law, have applied central finance funds
to purchase the rights for one year usage and
related services of the "Green Dam - Escort of the
Youth Flowers" green Internet filter software
(hereafter referred as "Green Dam" software) to
provide free usage to all of society. Through
general testing and pilot project application, this
software product has proven to be able to
effectively filter unhealthy text and image content
on the internet, thus this software already
possesses the conditions necessary to be pre-
installed by computer manufacturers.
In order to build upon the progress made during the
implementation of the "Special Campaign to Restore
the Internet from a State of Vulgarity," persist in
a combination of "punish and prevent," realistically
protect the healthy upbringing of underage youth,
and push forward in the healthy and orderly
development of the Internet, in accordance with the
general nation-wide deployment of the "Special
Campaign to Restore the Internet from a State of
Vulgarity" , MIIT hereby notifies the specific
requirements for the computer pre-installation of
green Internet filtering software as follows:
1. All computers produced and sold within Chinese
territory shall pre-install the latest available
version of the "Green Dam" software; imported
computers shall pre-install the latest available
version of the "Green Dam" software before they are
sold in China.
2. "Green Dam" software shall be pre-installed in
the computer's hard disk or the DVD included in the
package. It shall be installed in the restore
partition and restore disk of the computer as the
backup file.
3. "Green Dam" software shall adopt active measures
to support the computer manufacturing companies'
pre-installation related work.
4. Computer manufacturing companies shall complete
relevant testing work for pre-installing "Green Dam"
software before the end of June 2009. Computers
manufactured or sold after July 1, 2009 shall be
pre-installed with "Green Dam" software.
5. Computer manufacturers and "Green Dam" software
providers shall report to the Software Service
Department of MIIT the previous month's computer
sales volume on a monthly basis throughout 2009. In
2010, the annual sales data of the preceding year
BEIJING 00001520 004 OF 004
shall be reported no later than the end of February.
For those who do not pre-install after the stated
deadline, those who submit delayed or falsified
reports, or those who refuse to report, MIIT will
order them to take due make-up or correction
measures.
The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology
May 19, 2009
(Official Chop)
Contact Points:
Green Dam Software Project Team
Wu Weiwei (010-88559383)
The Software Service Department of the Ministry of
Industry and Information Technology
Liao Kai (010-68208172)
The Administration Department of MIIT
Released on May 22nd, 2009
END TEXT
Comment
--------------
9. (SBU) We will meet with USITO staff and industry
representatives on June 8 for their more detailed
response to the Green Dam mandate. Multinational
manufacturers clearly face major technical
challenges to properly test and deploy software
within 30 days, a requirement that me be impossible
to meet. That notwithstanding, the political
ramifications of deploying content filtering
software paid for by the Chinese government are even
more serious and complex. USITO's parent companies
will reportedly seek to brief Washington DC-based
officials early in the week of June 8. We will
continue to report on this matter as it develops.
End Comment.
PICCUTA
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
State for EAP/CM - SFlatt, JHabjan
State for EEB/CIP - SFlynn, FSaeed, DGross
USTR for Awinter, JMcHale, TWineland, AMain
Commerce for MAC
Commerce for ITA - IKasoff, NMelcher
DOJ for CCIPS - MDubose and SChembtob
FBI for LBryant
State for White House OSTP Ambassador Richard
Russell
NSC for Melissa Hathaway
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ETRD PGOV PHUM SOCI SCUL ECON CH
SUBJECT: "ESCORT OF THE YOUTH FLOWERS" - CHINA SEEKS
TO MANDATE INTERNET FILTERING SOFTWARE IN NEW
COMPUTERS
Ref: Beijing 1206
This cable is sensitive but unclassified. Please
handle accordingly.
1. (SBU) Summary: China's Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology (MIIT) on May 22 mandated
that all computers sold in China, whether imported
or manufactured domestically, be pre-installed with
"Green Dam - Escort of the Youth Flowers" Internet
filtering software effective July 1, 2009. With
little more than 30 days advance notice, the
announcement offers few details of the technical
implementation and raises transparency and market
access concerns for U.S. companies. Compliance with
this new requirement would in essence make foreign
businesses complicit with China's censorship regime,
and exposes foreign computers to potential
cybersecurity vulnerabilities. Emboffs will meet
with industry representatives on June 8 to hear
their response and proposed actions. There appears
to be early consensus to focus first on delaying the
implementation deadline and pursue discussions with
the Chinese government. End Summary.
2. (SBU) China's Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology (MIIT) on May 22 issued
Circular No. 226, a document mandating the
installation of "Green Dam - Escort of the Youth
Flowers" Internet filtering software on all new
computers, imported or made domestically, that are
sold in China beginning July 1, 2009. According to
company documents, media reports, and conversations
with Beijing-based trade association U.S.
Information Technology Office (USITO),the software
is a commercial application jointly developed by: (1)
a Beijing company that provides text and image
filtering technology for China's Great Firewall, and
(2) a Zhengzhou company with ties to a Peoples'
Liberation Army University. Functioning much like
anti-virus software, the application regularly
connects to the Internet to download a current list
of what content to block.
Protecting the Youth Flowers
--------------
3. (SBU) The Circular says that central government
agencies including MIIT, the Ministry of Finance,
and the Civilization office of the CPC Central
Committee have licensed the software to leverage the
ongoing "Special Campaign to Restore the Internet
from a State of Vulgarity" (see reftel) and to
"build a green, healthy, and harmonious network
environment and to avoid unhealthy information on
the Internet from influencing and hurting the youth."
According to a May announcement by MIIT, Green Dam
filtering software has already been installed in
2.17 million primary and middle schools in China --
80 percent of the nation's total. The mandate for
all schools to install the software, including
detailed instructions on the proper downloading and
installation of the software, was communicated on
April 1 in a joint notice from MIIT, the Ministries
of Education and Finance, and the State Council
Information Office.
U.S. Industry Concerns
--------------
BEIJING 00001520 002 OF 004
4. (SBU) Multinational computer manufacturers Apple,
Dell, and HP, and software maker Symantec told USITO
they did not learn of the Green Dam requirement
until May 26, little more than one month prior to
the proposed July 1 implementation date. HP and
Dell said they had been in contact with MIIT's
Software Service Department about the Green Dam
concept in mid-May, but at that point MIIT suggested
the program would be voluntary. The companies said
they did not receive a copy of the Circular on May
22, the publication date printed on the document
itself. Despite commitments to the United States at
the SED to publish for comment all policy documents
affecting economic issues, China has still not
posted the notice on any government website.
5. (SBU) U.S. companies have significant political
concerns that complying with the Chinese
requirements to install Green Dam software would
make them appear complicit with Chinese Government
censorship. In addition, with only 30 days to test
the software and prepare for the implementation of
the measure, U.S. businesses are worried about
apparent technical problems. For example, online
blog reports and initial compatibility tests by U.S.
companies report problems, raising concerns about
who will support users if the software causes their
computers to crash, for example. Furthermore, the
software is not currently available for Apple and
Linux operating systems. While the Circular
announces that the government will "provide free
usage to all of society" for one year, manufacturers
are concerned about who will cover the installation
costs, implementation and customer service costs,
and licensing fees beyond the first year.
6. (SBU) China's proposal to enforce the use of
filtering software violates technology neutrality
principles, reduces incentives for commercial
innovation in the marketplace, and in many cases
causes redundancies with commercial software already
offered for sale with many computers. By
maintaining a potentially constant connection with
the Internet to download software updates, the
software conceivably provides Chinese censors a
finer tool with which to monitor user behavior and
block content. It also creates vulnerabilities in
the form of a "back door" that could expose
computers to covert control by third parties,
malicious attacks, or spying.
Strong Support from Government
--------------
7. (SBU) Based on its meetings with member companies
and with MIIT, USITO tells us there is great
political pressure within the Chinese government to
implement the Green Dam program. This is attributed
partly to support for the new software's
installation by Politburo Standing Committee Member
Li Changchun, who has authority over the regime's
propaganda system.
8. (SBU) Following is an unofficial translation of
the MIIT circular prepared by the U.S. Information
Technology Office:
BEGIN TEXT
Ministry of Industry and Information Technology
BEIJING 00001520 003.2 OF 004
Circular
MIIT Software [2009] No. 226
Notice Concerning the Computer Pre-Installation of
Green Internet Filter Software
To Relevant Agencies/Companies:
In order to build a green, healthy, and harmonious
network environment and to avoid unhealthy
information on the Internet from influencing and
hurting the youth, the Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology (MIIT),the Communist Party
of China Culture and Civilization Office, and the
Ministry of Finance (MOF),in accordance with the
relevant requirements of P.R.C Government
Procurement Law, have applied central finance funds
to purchase the rights for one year usage and
related services of the "Green Dam - Escort of the
Youth Flowers" green Internet filter software
(hereafter referred as "Green Dam" software) to
provide free usage to all of society. Through
general testing and pilot project application, this
software product has proven to be able to
effectively filter unhealthy text and image content
on the internet, thus this software already
possesses the conditions necessary to be pre-
installed by computer manufacturers.
In order to build upon the progress made during the
implementation of the "Special Campaign to Restore
the Internet from a State of Vulgarity," persist in
a combination of "punish and prevent," realistically
protect the healthy upbringing of underage youth,
and push forward in the healthy and orderly
development of the Internet, in accordance with the
general nation-wide deployment of the "Special
Campaign to Restore the Internet from a State of
Vulgarity" , MIIT hereby notifies the specific
requirements for the computer pre-installation of
green Internet filtering software as follows:
1. All computers produced and sold within Chinese
territory shall pre-install the latest available
version of the "Green Dam" software; imported
computers shall pre-install the latest available
version of the "Green Dam" software before they are
sold in China.
2. "Green Dam" software shall be pre-installed in
the computer's hard disk or the DVD included in the
package. It shall be installed in the restore
partition and restore disk of the computer as the
backup file.
3. "Green Dam" software shall adopt active measures
to support the computer manufacturing companies'
pre-installation related work.
4. Computer manufacturing companies shall complete
relevant testing work for pre-installing "Green Dam"
software before the end of June 2009. Computers
manufactured or sold after July 1, 2009 shall be
pre-installed with "Green Dam" software.
5. Computer manufacturers and "Green Dam" software
providers shall report to the Software Service
Department of MIIT the previous month's computer
sales volume on a monthly basis throughout 2009. In
2010, the annual sales data of the preceding year
BEIJING 00001520 004 OF 004
shall be reported no later than the end of February.
For those who do not pre-install after the stated
deadline, those who submit delayed or falsified
reports, or those who refuse to report, MIIT will
order them to take due make-up or correction
measures.
The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology
May 19, 2009
(Official Chop)
Contact Points:
Green Dam Software Project Team
Wu Weiwei (010-88559383)
The Software Service Department of the Ministry of
Industry and Information Technology
Liao Kai (010-68208172)
The Administration Department of MIIT
Released on May 22nd, 2009
END TEXT
Comment
--------------
9. (SBU) We will meet with USITO staff and industry
representatives on June 8 for their more detailed
response to the Green Dam mandate. Multinational
manufacturers clearly face major technical
challenges to properly test and deploy software
within 30 days, a requirement that me be impossible
to meet. That notwithstanding, the political
ramifications of deploying content filtering
software paid for by the Chinese government are even
more serious and complex. USITO's parent companies
will reportedly seek to brief Washington DC-based
officials early in the week of June 8. We will
continue to report on this matter as it develops.
End Comment.
PICCUTA