MEDIA REACTION: U.S.-CHINA NAVAL CONFRONTATION, U.S.

UNCLAS AIT TAIPEI 000328

SIPDIS

DEPARTMENT FOR INR/R/MR, EAP/TC, EAP/PA, EAP/PD - NIDA EMMONS
DEPARTMENT PASS AIT/WASHINGTON

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: OPRC KMDR KPAO TW
SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION: U.S.-CHINA NAVAL CONFRONTATION, U.S.
ECONOMIC SITUATION


1. Summary: Taiwan's major Chinese-language dailies focused March
21-23 news coverage on cross-Strait relations and Taiwan's bid to
become an observer in the World Health Assembly in May; on Taiwan's
economic situation; and on the controversy caused by the alleged
anti-Taiwan remarks by a Toronto-based Government Information Office
official. In terms of editorials and commentaries, a column in the
conservative, pro-unification, English-language "China Post"
discussed the recent naval confrontation between the United States
and China in the South China Sea. The article said "the best option
open to Washington is to weaken the leadership role of the PRC,
whose PLA Navy is posing a threat to the security of the ASEAN
countries." A separate "China Post" editorial criticized the way
the Obama administration is handling the financial storm. The
article said "Obama's top economic team is not up to the job of
steering America out of this mess. They've failed to engineer a
bailout plan with performance guidelines and provisions for
transparency." End summary.


2. U.S.-China Naval Confrontation

"The Truth about the South China Sea"

Columnist Joe Hung wrote in the conservative, pro-unification,
English-language "China Post" [circulation: 30,000] (3/23):

"... What's behind this incident in the South China Sea? One thing
is certain: The incident occurred because the U.S. is gathering
information on the new thrust of China's naval power to its 'first
island chain,' which includes Taiwan and all the small archipelagoes
in the South China Sea, under whose waters are rich oil reserves.
The People's Liberation Army (PLA) is boosting its first island
chain defense to back up its leading role in an emerging Asian free
trade zone. The PLA Navy is setting up China's largest submarine
base on Hainan Island and planning to build an aircraft carrier. It
is developing a blue-water navy. Intelligence gathering in the South
China Sea is a must for the U.S. Navy. As a matter of fact, the U.S.
had surveyed the waters around Taiwan exhaustively again not long
before the Impeccable met with the hostile Chinese boats. ...

"Obama needs a rapport with the PRC, particularly at a time Chinese
help is needed to cope with the global economic crisis, triggered by
the U.S. financial meltdown. The U.S. is bitterly offended because
it is excluded from the Asian free trade sphere -- the
ASEAN-plus-One scheduled to come into being on next January 1, and
the ASEAN-plus-Three by 2015 (the zone includes all ten members of
the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and the PRC,
known also as the Ten-plus-One. The other two in the
ASEAN-plus-Three are Japan and South Korea). As the situation now
stands, the best option open to Washington is to weaken the
leadership role of the PRC, whose PLA Navy is posing a threat to the
security of the ASEAN countries. If Manila seeks U.S., all other
ASEAN member states, Vietnam and Indonesia in particular, will
follow suit. The U. S. may revive a SEATO (Southeast Asian Treaty
Organization) and reestablish its strong military presence, which
contributes in no small measure to the defense of vital U.S.
economic interests in the region. What started as a test of Obama's
future China policy led up to the sea incident by accident, which is
being followed up by the U.S. initiative to reassert its leadership
role in Southeast Asia."


3. U.S. Economic Situation

"A+ for Rhetoric, D+ for Execution"

The conservative, pro-unification, English-language "China Post"
[circulation: 30,000] editorialized (3/21):

"The global financial storm sweeping the world is inflicting heavy
casualties on developed and developing countries alike. The United
States, in particular, has been hit hard by a double whammy of
financial pinch and political wrangling. President Barack Obama is
facing a political Katrina of his own. The hurricane is cutting
short his political honeymoon, and here's why: Seat of the pants
governance. AIG has received US$173 billion in bailout funds since
last September when Hank Paulson, George Bush's treasury secretary,
insisted on 'unconditional' rescue of many bankrupt financial
institutions with a US$800 billion rescue fund called Troubled
Assets Rescue Package (TARP). Since then, however, the U.S.
government's pay-now-ask-later attitude has made it painfully clear
that there is no plan. ... What message is Obama's administration
sending to the U.S. public? With February's unemployment rate
hitting 8.1% and banks still as unwilling to lend as when this
crisis started, it's obvious that the economy is still in the ICU.
Up to this point, Americans have seen a lot of their tax dollars
spent with little tangible results, except to directly fill the
wallets of a few executives.

"Americans would probably respect the Obama team a bit more if it

owned up to the fact that it was inept in handling the recovery
plan. Instead, Obama defended Mr. Geithner as 'making all the right
moves in terms of playing a bad hand' and made AIG the scapegoat for
its 'recklessness and greed.' He vowed to 'pursue every single
legal avenue to block those bonuses,' which are but empty words.
It's quite alarming that the Obama administration is still tiptoeing
around the core issue. Liddy and Geithner, had they had the will and
aptitude to do so, could have placed usage conditions on taxpayer
money. For example, without government funding, AIG would have gone
under. Under bankruptcy law, can executives sue for missed
compensation? Don't be silly. Once AIG received government money it
was an end to business as usual. First class passengers should not
expect champagne and a warm towel after their plane goes down and
they're all floating on a life raft. The truth seems plenty clear.
Obama's top economic team is not up to the job of steering America
out of this mess. They've failed to engineer a bailout plan with
performance guidelines and provisions for transparency. ...

"A man of charisma with gifted oratory abilities, President Obama
should stop believing that hopeful rhetoric alone will get the job
done. Five and a half million Americans are unemployed. The Fed, if
it keeps pumping money into the economy in a hopeless effort to
grease lending, runs the risk of stoking stagflation, a scary
scenario of inflation without growth. Obama is expected by many of
his countrymen to be a 21st century F.D.R. by restoring America's
greatness from the ruins wrought by his predecessor. He still has a
chance to become a great American president. So far, however, his
performance is disappointing and the euphoria is evaporating. It's
trite to say every crisis is an opportunity, but now is the moment
for him to tackle the crisis with toughness."

YOUNG