Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
08SANJOSE263
2008-04-07 20:16:00
CONFIDENTIAL
Embassy San Jose
Cable title:  

BERROCAL STEPS DOWN AS MINISTER OF PUBLIC

Tags:  CS PREL PGOV SNAR MASS PINR 
pdf how-to read a cable
VZCZCXYZ0000
OO RUEHWEB

DE RUEHSJ #0263/01 0982016
ZNY CCCCC ZZH
O 072016Z APR 08
FM AMEMBASSY SAN JOSE
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 9581
INFO RUEHZA/WHA CENTRAL AMERICAN COLLECTIVE PRIORITY
RUEHBO/AMEMBASSY BOGOTA PRIORITY 4225
RUEHQT/AMEMBASSY QUITO PRIORITY 1333
RUEABND/DRUG ENFORCEMENT ADMIN HQ WASHINGTON DC PRIORITY
C O N F I D E N T I A L SAN JOSE 000263 

SIPDIS

SIPDIS

DEPT FOR WHA/CEN, WHA/AND, INL AND INR

E.O. 12958: DECL: 04/03/2018
TAGS: CS PREL PGOV SNAR MASS PINR
SUBJECT: BERROCAL STEPS DOWN AS MINISTER OF PUBLIC
SECURITY; ALLEGES FARC TIES TO COSTA RICA

REF: A. 07 SAN JOSE 2073

B. 07 SAN JOSE 1999

Classified By: CDA Peter M. Brennan for reasons 1.4 (d).

C O N F I D E N T I A L SAN JOSE 000263

SIPDIS

SIPDIS

DEPT FOR WHA/CEN, WHA/AND, INL AND INR

E.O. 12958: DECL: 04/03/2018
TAGS: CS PREL PGOV SNAR MASS PINR
SUBJECT: BERROCAL STEPS DOWN AS MINISTER OF PUBLIC
SECURITY; ALLEGES FARC TIES TO COSTA RICA

REF: A. 07 SAN JOSE 2073

B. 07 SAN JOSE 1999

Classified By: CDA Peter M. Brennan for reasons 1.4 (d).


1. (C) SUMMARY. Minister of Public Security Fernando Berrocal
stepped down on March 30 after asserting that the
FARC was connected to elements of the "political sector" in
Costa Rica. Berrocal's comments came in the aftermath of a
March 14 raid on a suspected FARC safe house. His departure
came less than 24 hours before he was to testify on the issue
before the National Legislature, fueling political and media
speculation. In public and private, President Arias and
Minister Arias reiterated that there were no Costa Rican
links to the FARC, that the GOCR had nothing to hide, and
that Berrocal's unfounded comments had gone too far. An
exculpatory letter from President Uribe buttressed their
arguments. This controversy may not die quickly; Berrocal
has provided documents supporting his claims to President
Arias who turned them over to the Legislature. Berrocal
wants to testify as a "private citizen" in mid-April. For
our part, we will engage the new Minister (Janina del
Vecchio, septel) to continue the successful partnership
developed with Berrocal and his ministry. We will also urge
the GOCR to harden the permissive environment which has
tolerated FARC supporters and activities for too long. END
SUMMARY.

=========================================
BERROCAL IS OUT, BUT HE DIDN'T GO QUIETLY
=========================================


2. (SBU) On March 30, Fernando Berrocal stepped down as the
Minister of Public Security, in a not-so-amicable political
divorce from the President and his brother, Minister of the
Presidency Rodrigo Arias. According to Casa Presidencial,
the GOCR did not want to "politicize" the "sensitive"
FARC-Costa Rica issue by having Berrocal testify on the
matter before the Legislature the next day. Berrocal
insisted to the media that he neither resigned nor was asked

to resign. He said that he and President Arias had agreed
that he should leave office "for reasons of state."


3. (SBU) Berrocal ignited this political firestorm on March
15, by asserting publicly that information obtained from
the laptop computer of deceased FARC leader Raul Reyes linked
members of the "Costa Rican political sector" to the
FARC. Led by the PUSC party (part of the Arias
administration's own pro-CAFTA coalition),incensed
legislators summoned Berrocal to appear on March 31 and to
"name names." Berrocal's comments followed a raid on an
alleged FARC safe house near San Jose on March 14, where
$480,000 of FARC cash was found. As the media has widely
reported here, the stashed cash was described in detail by
information obtained from Reyes' laptop, and discovered in
the home of long-time FARC collaborators Francisco Gutierrez
and Cruz Prado.


4. (U) Since his departure, Berrocal has written two letters
to President Arias, which he released to the media and posted
on the internet. In the first letter (dated March 31),which
also ran as an Op-ed in leading daily La Nacion, Berrocal
asked to exercise his "constitutional right" to speak to the
Legislature, anyway, as a private citizen. In the second
letter (dated April 1 and published April 3),Berrocal said
he had documents from the Drug Control Police (PCD),the
intelligence service (DIS),the National Police of Colombia,
and other sources which he planned to share with the
Legislature. Berrocal's document package is to be reviewed
by a special commission (see below).


5. (U) The second letter, titled "The Country Must Know",
described the FARC as having made Costa Rica a "safe haven"
for their operatives, and stressed that the FARC and
narcotrafficking were one and the same, at least since 2000.
While Costa Rican contact with the FARC before that date was
part of the country's long tradition of offering asylum and
political refuge, contact after the FARC turned to
narcotrafficking reflected "unacceptable indifference,"
"ingenuity" or "virginal complicity," according to Berrocal.
His letter insisted that he never claimed to have a specific
"list" of Costa Rican politicians with links to the FARC.

============================================
ARIAS BROTHERS: BERROCAL WENT TOO FAR, AGAIN
============================================


6. (C) During his April 1 meeting with visiting WHA DAS
Kirsten Madison, President Arias denied there was any list
of Costa Rican politicians associated with the FARC, despite
Berrocal's assertions. Arias said that Berrocal is welcome
to testify to the Legislature as a private citizen, but not
as Minister. Minister Arias and the President echoed a
similar message all week, in press releases, press
conferences and interviews. Both reiterated that the there
were no Costa Rican political links to the FARC, that the
GOCR had nothing to hide, and that Berrocal stepped down
because the GOCR did not share his "unfounded" views, which
"raised false expectations," and "jeopardized current and
future investigations." Minister Arias has also stressed
publicly that Berrocal was set to leave government on May 1,
anyway; all the Arias administration did was accelerate his
departure by a few weeks.


7. (U) On April 2, President Arias told a press conference
that he had called Colombian President Uribe, generating a
letter from Uribe denying that any material discovered from
the Reyes's laptop "up to now" linked the FARC to Costa Rican
politicians. Arias' comments and the text of the Uribe
letter have received wide media coverage. So have comments
by Colombian VP Santos, insisting to a Costa Rican journalist
that the FARC is a "real threat" to Costa Rica, suggesting
that the GOC may discover additional information about
FARC-Costa Rican ties in the future, and labeling the FARC a
threat to the entire continent. Meanwhile, the GOCR
dispatched a delegation including VP (and Justice Minister)
Laura Chinchilla, FonMin Bruno Stagno and Attorney-General
Francisco Dall'Anese on a fact-finding mission to Bogota
April 4.

===============
THIS AIN'T OVER
===============


8. (SBU) This controversy may not die quickly. The special
legislative commission formed to investigate Berrocal's
allegations and hear his testimony intends to meet. Berrocal
has announced he would be available to appear before the
Legislature in mid-April. A skeptical media has focused on
the "up to this point" caveat of Uribe's letter, while
opinion polls taken the week of March 31 depict a suspicious
public. Over 75 percent in one poll believe Berrocal's exit
was wrong and do not believe they have the full story yet
about his departure. Over 90 percent believe the
Attorney-General should fully investigate the entire affair.


9. (C) PUSC and opposition PAC legislators have been asking
in public and private for more information, while Berrocal's
predecessor as minister, Rogelio Ramos, has asked to meet
with the Embassy. (A PUSC party member, Ramos's activities
while minister have been regularly questioned by Berrocal,
the media and others.) President Arias publicly acknowledged
that Ramos came to see him the day before Berrocal was
sacked. Ramos has threatened to us that if the GOCR (or we)
criticize his performance, he will publicize dirt he has on
the Arias Administration.

=======
COMMENT
=======


10. (C) Both sides have mishandled this affair. Berrocal's
poorly-timed and unsupported allegations of FARC links to
Costa Rica apparently were the last straw for the Arias
brothers. The ex-minister's talk-first, think-later approach
on sensitive law enforcement and counter-narcotics issues had
gotten him in trouble before. On the other hand, if the
Arias administration team hoped the furor would fade quickly
and quietly, they have thus far been proved wrong.


11. (C) There may be some truth on both sides, however.
Berrocal is correct, in our view, to highlight the
permissive, it-can't-happen-here atmosphere that has allowed
FARC ties to continue for years, including direct contact
with left-of-center political elements in the country. The
brothers Arias were probably also correct in assuming that
the political distraction from Berrocal's testimony would be
harder to manage than the fallout from his hasty departure.
At least one PUSC legislator reportedly was conditioning his
continued support for CAFTA on the GOCR not permitting
Berrocal to testify as minister and/or his removal from
office.


12. (C) We will quickly engage with new Minister del Vecchio

to maintain the excellent counter-narcotics and law
enforcement cooperation set in motion by Berrocal. It took
some time to overcome his skepticism about confronting the
international drug trade, but he became a full and successful
partner in the end. We will also urge the GOCR to stand firm
against the FARC. Gutierrez and Prado may have violated
Costa Rican money laundering laws, for example, in their
house purchase. Vice Minister of Public Security Lascarez
told us (during DAS Madison's visit/call last week) that he
felt this provided grounds for prosecution. Media reports
over the April 5-6 weekend suggest Bogota may ask for
extradition of the couple. New terrorism financing
legislation, which might have been more easily used against
them, has not been passed, however. This affair strengthens
our regularly-repeated argument that the GOCR needs to
improve its counter terrorism laws.
BRENNAN