Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
08LONDON2494
2008-10-01 15:32:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy London
Cable title:
New Chief Regulator Faces Baptism by Fire in Month of
how-toVZCZCXRO6207 PP RUEHAG RUEHDF RUEHIK RUEHLZ RUEHROV DE RUEHLO #2494/01 2751532 ZNR UUUUU ZZH P 011532Z OCT 08 FM AMEMBASSY LONDON TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 9955 INFO RUCNMEM/EU MEMBER STATES COLLECTIVE PRIORITY RUCPDOC/DEPT OF COMMERCE WASHDC PRIORITY RUEATRS/DEPT OF TREASURY WASHDC PRIORITY RUEHBL/AMCONSUL BELFAST PRIORITY 1122 RUEHED/AMCONSUL EDINBURGH PRIORITY 0990
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 LONDON 002494
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ECON EFIN ETRD EINV UK
SUBJECT: New Chief Regulator Faces Baptism by Fire in Month of
Crashes, Bounces and Bailouts
LONDON 00002494 001.2 OF 002
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 LONDON 002494
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ECON EFIN ETRD EINV UK
SUBJECT: New Chief Regulator Faces Baptism by Fire in Month of
Crashes, Bounces and Bailouts
LONDON 00002494 001.2 OF 002
1. (SBU) Summary: The global financial crisis, which has hit the
UK particularly hard, has turned the spotlight on Britain's recently
appointed financial regulator, Jonathan Adair Turner, who succeeded
Callum McCarthy as Chairman of the Financial Services Authority.
Turner's appointment was well-received by banking contacts and
financial experts, who praised his competency and decades-long
experience in working in the financial sector. Less than a month in
his tenure, Turner, whose formal title is Baron Turner of
Ecchinswell, has shown a willingness to aggressively confront
financial sector problems, including implementing a ban on
short-selling of bonds. End Summary.
Baptism by Fire
--------------
2. (U) Within days of succeeding Sir Callum McCarthy as Chairman of
the FSA, Lord Turner issued a temporary ban on the short selling of
financial stocks. The short selling ban, which will initially last
four months, was implemented in an attempt to protect the
fundamental integrity and quality of markets, he argued. Turner
also said the ban was necessary to prevent the short selling from
producing a self-fulfilling downward price spiral.
3. (U) Turner has been tasked by the Chancellor of the Exchequer,
Alistair Darling, to undertake a review of all financial market
regulations - including the operation of the Financial Services
Authority (FSA). He has already begun reviews into aspects of the
credit crunch, including liquidity, banks' remuneration schemes and
capital requirements and has said he expects a more intrusive form
of regulation will be necessary even after the credit crisis
subsides. On remuneration schemes, Turner announced that the FSA
will make banks more accountable for their bonus structures. While
the FSA will not regulate how much is paid, it will compel banks
found to encourage risky actions through their bonus structures to
hold more capital. The FSA is also expected to begin consultation
on plans to increase the deposit protection limit for savers from
GBP 35,000 to GBP 50,000.
4. (U) Following the nationalization of Bradford & Bingley bank,
Lord Turner said he was confident that other UK retail banks were
well-capitalized and in a reasonable position. He added that the
FSA would keep this situation under review and said that it has the
ability, if necessary, to ensure that problems were resolved without
risk to retail depositors. He has acknowledged that the FSA made
serious mistakes in the past with regards to its oversight of the UK
financial system. However, he said that its performance over the
past year, including its supervision of Bradford & Bingley, has been
effective. Lord Turner saw the failure to date of the U.S. Congress
to pass the $700 billion rescue plan as a 'serious setback' but
added that even without the plan, U.S. authorities had enough tools
at their disposal to prevent major bank failures.
Appointment to the FSA
--------------
5. (SBU) In May, Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling
announced that Lord Turner would succeed Sir Callum McCarthy as
Chairman of the FSA. Banking contacts told Econoff that bankers were
extremely pleased by the appointment and that he was the best
possible person for the position. In September, Lord Turner began
his five-year appointment.
6. (U) In his pre-commencement hearing (July 2),Lord Turner told
the Treasury Select Committee that his major objectives in the first
six months would be to play a significant role in international
discussions of key regulatory issues and to foster a close and
effective working relationship with the Bank of England. He said he
was surprised by the failings of the FSA during the crisis at
Northern Rock and concluded that the FSA's formal processes were not
right and that there were fundamental problems, including rapid
staff turnover and a lack of bank visits. However, he praised the
FSA's internal audit report for being open about what went wrong.
In response to a question from the Committee about oil speculation,
he said that there was 'no large accumulation of evidence that
speculation was playing a major role' in the rising price of
commodities. He added that it was difficult for any regulator to
stop speculation as long as it was not market manipulation.
However, he noted that the FSA was keen to expand its resources to
minimize market abuse.
Biographical Detail
--------------
7. (U) Lord Turner grew up in Crawley and East Kilbride and
attended Hutchesons' Grammar School. He attended Glenalmond College
and Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, where he took a double
first in History and Economics and became President of the Cambridge
LONDON 00002494 002.2 OF 002
Union. He was also Chairman of the university's Conservative
Association.
8. (U) His career started at British Petroleum in 1979 and Chase
Manhattan Bank from 1979-82 before he became a Director of McKinsey
& Co. in 1994. From 2000, he joined Merrill Lynch, becoming a
Vice-Chairman. He was Director-General of the Confederation of
British Industry (CBI) from 1995 to 1999.
9. (U) Lord Turner Chaired the Pensions Committee (2003-2006) which
was tasked to review the UK private pension system and long-term
savings. Its controversial final report, the 'Turner Report,'
outlined his recommendations for the future of pensions in the UK.
Key proposals included: increasing the state pension age for men and
women to 68 by 2050; establishing a standing commission to monitor
pension policy; and establishing a new National Pension Savings
Scheme by 2010 in which people who did not have a workplace pension
would be automatically enrolled.
10. (U) He was also Chair of the Low Pay Commission, which advised
the government on minimum wage baselines, from 2002 to 2006. In
January 2008, he was appointed Chairman of the government's Climate
Change Committee, which provides independent, expert advice on how
the UK can best meet its climate change goals. Turner will remain
as Chair until the new year, at which point he will step down. He
lectures part-time at the London School of Economics.
11. (U) In September 2005 he was created a life peer as Baron
Turner of Ecchinswell in the County of Hampshire in recognition of
his public service.
TUTTLE
SENSITIVE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ECON EFIN ETRD EINV UK
SUBJECT: New Chief Regulator Faces Baptism by Fire in Month of
Crashes, Bounces and Bailouts
LONDON 00002494 001.2 OF 002
1. (SBU) Summary: The global financial crisis, which has hit the
UK particularly hard, has turned the spotlight on Britain's recently
appointed financial regulator, Jonathan Adair Turner, who succeeded
Callum McCarthy as Chairman of the Financial Services Authority.
Turner's appointment was well-received by banking contacts and
financial experts, who praised his competency and decades-long
experience in working in the financial sector. Less than a month in
his tenure, Turner, whose formal title is Baron Turner of
Ecchinswell, has shown a willingness to aggressively confront
financial sector problems, including implementing a ban on
short-selling of bonds. End Summary.
Baptism by Fire
--------------
2. (U) Within days of succeeding Sir Callum McCarthy as Chairman of
the FSA, Lord Turner issued a temporary ban on the short selling of
financial stocks. The short selling ban, which will initially last
four months, was implemented in an attempt to protect the
fundamental integrity and quality of markets, he argued. Turner
also said the ban was necessary to prevent the short selling from
producing a self-fulfilling downward price spiral.
3. (U) Turner has been tasked by the Chancellor of the Exchequer,
Alistair Darling, to undertake a review of all financial market
regulations - including the operation of the Financial Services
Authority (FSA). He has already begun reviews into aspects of the
credit crunch, including liquidity, banks' remuneration schemes and
capital requirements and has said he expects a more intrusive form
of regulation will be necessary even after the credit crisis
subsides. On remuneration schemes, Turner announced that the FSA
will make banks more accountable for their bonus structures. While
the FSA will not regulate how much is paid, it will compel banks
found to encourage risky actions through their bonus structures to
hold more capital. The FSA is also expected to begin consultation
on plans to increase the deposit protection limit for savers from
GBP 35,000 to GBP 50,000.
4. (U) Following the nationalization of Bradford & Bingley bank,
Lord Turner said he was confident that other UK retail banks were
well-capitalized and in a reasonable position. He added that the
FSA would keep this situation under review and said that it has the
ability, if necessary, to ensure that problems were resolved without
risk to retail depositors. He has acknowledged that the FSA made
serious mistakes in the past with regards to its oversight of the UK
financial system. However, he said that its performance over the
past year, including its supervision of Bradford & Bingley, has been
effective. Lord Turner saw the failure to date of the U.S. Congress
to pass the $700 billion rescue plan as a 'serious setback' but
added that even without the plan, U.S. authorities had enough tools
at their disposal to prevent major bank failures.
Appointment to the FSA
--------------
5. (SBU) In May, Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling
announced that Lord Turner would succeed Sir Callum McCarthy as
Chairman of the FSA. Banking contacts told Econoff that bankers were
extremely pleased by the appointment and that he was the best
possible person for the position. In September, Lord Turner began
his five-year appointment.
6. (U) In his pre-commencement hearing (July 2),Lord Turner told
the Treasury Select Committee that his major objectives in the first
six months would be to play a significant role in international
discussions of key regulatory issues and to foster a close and
effective working relationship with the Bank of England. He said he
was surprised by the failings of the FSA during the crisis at
Northern Rock and concluded that the FSA's formal processes were not
right and that there were fundamental problems, including rapid
staff turnover and a lack of bank visits. However, he praised the
FSA's internal audit report for being open about what went wrong.
In response to a question from the Committee about oil speculation,
he said that there was 'no large accumulation of evidence that
speculation was playing a major role' in the rising price of
commodities. He added that it was difficult for any regulator to
stop speculation as long as it was not market manipulation.
However, he noted that the FSA was keen to expand its resources to
minimize market abuse.
Biographical Detail
--------------
7. (U) Lord Turner grew up in Crawley and East Kilbride and
attended Hutchesons' Grammar School. He attended Glenalmond College
and Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, where he took a double
first in History and Economics and became President of the Cambridge
LONDON 00002494 002.2 OF 002
Union. He was also Chairman of the university's Conservative
Association.
8. (U) His career started at British Petroleum in 1979 and Chase
Manhattan Bank from 1979-82 before he became a Director of McKinsey
& Co. in 1994. From 2000, he joined Merrill Lynch, becoming a
Vice-Chairman. He was Director-General of the Confederation of
British Industry (CBI) from 1995 to 1999.
9. (U) Lord Turner Chaired the Pensions Committee (2003-2006) which
was tasked to review the UK private pension system and long-term
savings. Its controversial final report, the 'Turner Report,'
outlined his recommendations for the future of pensions in the UK.
Key proposals included: increasing the state pension age for men and
women to 68 by 2050; establishing a standing commission to monitor
pension policy; and establishing a new National Pension Savings
Scheme by 2010 in which people who did not have a workplace pension
would be automatically enrolled.
10. (U) He was also Chair of the Low Pay Commission, which advised
the government on minimum wage baselines, from 2002 to 2006. In
January 2008, he was appointed Chairman of the government's Climate
Change Committee, which provides independent, expert advice on how
the UK can best meet its climate change goals. Turner will remain
as Chair until the new year, at which point he will step down. He
lectures part-time at the London School of Economics.
11. (U) In September 2005 he was created a life peer as Baron
Turner of Ecchinswell in the County of Hampshire in recognition of
his public service.
TUTTLE