Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
08HILLAH76
2008-09-05 15:45:00
CONFIDENTIAL
REO Hillah
Cable title:
BABIL PROVINCIAL COUNCIL LIFTS PRT BOYCOTT: FROM SHUNNING TO
how-toVZCZCXRO6394 PP RUEHBC RUEHDE RUEHDIR RUEHKUK DE RUEHIHL #0076 2491545 ZNY CCCCC ZZH P R 051545Z SEP 08 FM REO HILLAH TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 1108 INFO RUCNRAQ/IRAQ COLLECTIVE RUCNIRA/IRAN COLLECTIVE RUEHIHL/REO HILLAH 1175
C O N F I D E N T I A L HILLAH 000076
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 9/5/2018
TAGS: PGOV PINR IZ
SUBJECT: BABIL PROVINCIAL COUNCIL LIFTS PRT BOYCOTT: FROM SHUNNING TO
EMBRACE (MAYBE)
CLASSIFIED BY: Kenneth Hillas, PRT Leader, Babil PRT, Dept of
State.
REASON: 1.4 (b),(d)
1 (C) In a September 4 special session, the Babil Provincial
Council (PC) decided to lift its boycott of the PRT after CF had
advised Governor Salim two days earlier that former Iraqi
detainee Ahmed Zaki was being returned to Iraqi custody. (Note:
Ahmed Zaki, who had been awaiting trial on multiple murder
charges from 2006, is a Sunni from North Babil and his victims
were Shia.) At the PC's invitation, the PRT Leader addressed
the Council, emphasizing that this case had been resolved in
acordance with Iraqi law through discussions with Babil Chief
Judge Thamir and High Judcial Council Chair Judge Medhat.
Lavishing praise on the PRT in an effort to restore PRT-PC good
relations, Chairman Mohammed Al Massoudi expressed satisfaction
with the news. Several speakers, including Deputy PC Chair (and
Dawa Deputy Party Chair) Dr. Ne'ama and Murtada Kamil (Sadrist
Trend and a recent IVLP selectee) and others, echoed the PC
Chair's remarks and stressed the importance of restoring PRT-PC
cooperation.
2. (C) The PC did not actually vote, but there were no
dissenting voices to Chairman Mohammed, who three times
pronounced that the boycott was to be lifted. In the course of
the PC session, Governor Salim arrived, bringing his own media
retinue and armed bodyguards into the PC Chambers (the latter
for the first time). In contrast to all other interventions by
PC members, Governor Salim and Badr Deputy Chief Hassan Al-Hamza
largely skipped over the Zaki case and leveled continued
criticism of CF. Without providing specifics, the Governor
accused the CF of actions that were having a "negative impact."
It was Hassan Al-hamza, however, who launched into a diatribe
about CF raids in the sub-district of Qassem, which he asserted
had targeted political offices and which he termed illegal.
Throwing fuel on the fire, he alleged that one such raid
"almost" entered a holy shrine in Qassem. In a demonstration of
his real power, Hassan Al-Hamza waved off the PC Chair's efforts
to cut him off, concluding that the Ahmed Zaki case represented
a "serious breach of Iraqi law." He also suggested that there
continues to be an underlying problem.
3. (SBU) In subsequent media interviews in the Council Chambers
with Al-Furat TV, Al- Iraqiya TV, and Al-Masar TV, the PRT
Leader emphasized the important role of the Iraqi judiciary and
the US commitment to resolving, in accordance with Iraqi law,
queestions related to the handling of detainees. At the end of
his own interview with Al-Masar, Governor Salim brought the PRT
Leader before the camera and proceeded to scold him that the US
"should not defend or support one side of the people and neglect
the rest of the society" -- a clear effort to exploit Shia/Sunni
divisions. The Governor quickly broke off the interview and
departed when the PRT Leader began to praise the Governor's
cooperation with Coalition, confirming suspicisons that he views
such expressions as the political kiss of death. Leapfrogging
from shunning to embrace, the PC Chair Mohammed had a list of PC
Committee Chairs provided to the PRT along with the request for
them to have weekly meetings with their PRT counterparts..
SIGNATURE
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 9/5/2018
TAGS: PGOV PINR IZ
SUBJECT: BABIL PROVINCIAL COUNCIL LIFTS PRT BOYCOTT: FROM SHUNNING TO
EMBRACE (MAYBE)
CLASSIFIED BY: Kenneth Hillas, PRT Leader, Babil PRT, Dept of
State.
REASON: 1.4 (b),(d)
1 (C) In a September 4 special session, the Babil Provincial
Council (PC) decided to lift its boycott of the PRT after CF had
advised Governor Salim two days earlier that former Iraqi
detainee Ahmed Zaki was being returned to Iraqi custody. (Note:
Ahmed Zaki, who had been awaiting trial on multiple murder
charges from 2006, is a Sunni from North Babil and his victims
were Shia.) At the PC's invitation, the PRT Leader addressed
the Council, emphasizing that this case had been resolved in
acordance with Iraqi law through discussions with Babil Chief
Judge Thamir and High Judcial Council Chair Judge Medhat.
Lavishing praise on the PRT in an effort to restore PRT-PC good
relations, Chairman Mohammed Al Massoudi expressed satisfaction
with the news. Several speakers, including Deputy PC Chair (and
Dawa Deputy Party Chair) Dr. Ne'ama and Murtada Kamil (Sadrist
Trend and a recent IVLP selectee) and others, echoed the PC
Chair's remarks and stressed the importance of restoring PRT-PC
cooperation.
2. (C) The PC did not actually vote, but there were no
dissenting voices to Chairman Mohammed, who three times
pronounced that the boycott was to be lifted. In the course of
the PC session, Governor Salim arrived, bringing his own media
retinue and armed bodyguards into the PC Chambers (the latter
for the first time). In contrast to all other interventions by
PC members, Governor Salim and Badr Deputy Chief Hassan Al-Hamza
largely skipped over the Zaki case and leveled continued
criticism of CF. Without providing specifics, the Governor
accused the CF of actions that were having a "negative impact."
It was Hassan Al-hamza, however, who launched into a diatribe
about CF raids in the sub-district of Qassem, which he asserted
had targeted political offices and which he termed illegal.
Throwing fuel on the fire, he alleged that one such raid
"almost" entered a holy shrine in Qassem. In a demonstration of
his real power, Hassan Al-Hamza waved off the PC Chair's efforts
to cut him off, concluding that the Ahmed Zaki case represented
a "serious breach of Iraqi law." He also suggested that there
continues to be an underlying problem.
3. (SBU) In subsequent media interviews in the Council Chambers
with Al-Furat TV, Al- Iraqiya TV, and Al-Masar TV, the PRT
Leader emphasized the important role of the Iraqi judiciary and
the US commitment to resolving, in accordance with Iraqi law,
queestions related to the handling of detainees. At the end of
his own interview with Al-Masar, Governor Salim brought the PRT
Leader before the camera and proceeded to scold him that the US
"should not defend or support one side of the people and neglect
the rest of the society" -- a clear effort to exploit Shia/Sunni
divisions. The Governor quickly broke off the interview and
departed when the PRT Leader began to praise the Governor's
cooperation with Coalition, confirming suspicisons that he views
such expressions as the political kiss of death. Leapfrogging
from shunning to embrace, the PC Chair Mohammed had a list of PC
Committee Chairs provided to the PRT along with the request for
them to have weekly meetings with their PRT counterparts..
SIGNATURE