MEDIA REACTION: 9/11 COVERAGE, AMBASSADOR TIP INTERVIEW,

UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 MUSCAT 000894

SIPDIS

SIPDIS

STATE FOR NEA/ARP, NEA/PPD, NEA/PI, AND INR/R/MR
STATE PASS USTR FOR N. MOORJANI, J. BUNTIN
LONDON FOR TSOU
PARIS FOR ZEYA
USCENTCOM FOR PLUSH
FOREIGN PRESS CENTER FOR SILAS

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: OIIP KPAO KMDR MU
SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION: 9/11 COVERAGE, AMBASSADOR TIP INTERVIEW,
IRAQI RECONCILIATION, FALL PEACE CONFERENCE, ARAB INFIGHTING, U.S.
TROOPS IN IRAQ



1. SUMMARY: All dailies carry Ambassador's 9/11 message;
privately-owned "Al-Watan" and "Oman Tribune" interview Ambassador
about Trafficking in Persons; in an editorial about 9/11, "Al-Watan"
condemns the "beastly acts" of the American army that was unable to
protect Americans despite consuming their tax dollars; "Al-Watan"
says that true reconciliation in Iraq must happen internally;
"Al-Watan" states that Arabs "learned their lesson" from Oslo and
that maintaining a united Arab position on the Peace Process is more
important than attending the fall peace conference; government-owned
"Oman" calls for Arabs to take responsibility for their infighting
and stop blaming others; "Al-Shabiba" says security in Iraq will not
begin until foreign troops withdraw. END SUMMARY

--------------
COVERAGE
--------------


2. Coverage of September 11 was muted in the local press, but all
English and Arabic dailies carried the full text of Ambassador
Grappo's message "September 11, Six Years On" (available on Embassy
Muscat's homepage at
oman.usembassy.gov/september_11_six_years_on. html).


3. Arabic-language "Al-Watan" (privately owned, circulation 42,000)
and its English-language sister publication "Oman Tribune"
(circulation 8,000) featured an interview with Ambassador Grappo
about Oman's Tier 3 ranking in the annual Trafficking in Persons
(TIP) report. Both "Al-Watan" and "Oman Tribune" front paged the
interview above the fold and ran the full text on interior pages
with large color photographs of the Ambassador. "Oman Tribune's"
headline read, "Oman-U.S. Ties Remain Unaffected by Rights Report."
Al-Watan reported the same headline, with an additional quote from
the Ambassador, "We Have Some Infractions."

--------------
BLOCK QUOTES: POST 9/11 "NOTHING BUT LOSSES"
--------------

4. On September 11, "Al-Watan" published an editorial entitled,
"History is the Best Judge:"
"It is not difficult to see that a people can possess the most
powerful army in the modern world, one that uses up hundreds of
billions of dollars of the people's taxes, yet that army can fail to
protect them from something like the September 11 attack... This is
indeed what happened to the United States on that bloody day, and
naturally its leadership looked for an enemy to fight and gain
victory over, in order to treat the psychological shock to the
deepest part of its society... Now, six years after the beastly acts
that the American army committed against innocent civilians, it is
worth it for those who follow these events to review the scenario
that led to the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq and the
preparation to invade Iran, and also to consider the stab of the
Israeli aggression against the Palestinian people, on the pretext
that they are part of the 'terrorist resistance'... Since that day,
the fact is that those who thought they were the most powerful were
not, and armies who thought they could wage lethal attacks that
would not harm civilians proved that this was an illusion. The
politicians thought that force would accomplish their goals, and the
narrow interests of insiders... They were wrong in what they
attempted, which yielded nothing but clear losses... History is the
best judge."
--------------
IRAQI RECONCILIATION TRUE SOURCE OF STABILITY
--------------

5. On Monday, September 10,"Al-Watan" ran an editorial titled,
"Reconciliation Is the Source of Iraqi Stability:"
"At the security conference that was held in Baghdad yesterday the
call prevailed for Iraq's neighbors to make more efforts to stop the
bloodbath in Iraqi towns and cities. The conference also involved a
repetition of previous warnings that internal Iraqi violence could
spread to its neighbors if they do not intervene...but the reality
is that the solution to Iraq must begin inside Iraq itself... The
unlawful marriage between politics and the occupation in Iraq must
end so that all of Iraq's groups and sects can take great steps to
achieve quiet and stability."
-------------- -
ARAB SOLIDARITY MORE IMPORTANT THAN FALL TALKS
-------------- -


6. On Friday, September 14, "Al-Watan" editorialized that "Arab
Coordination Is More Important than the Fall Conference:"
"Little by little the characteristics of the conference about peace

MUSCAT 00000894 002 OF 002


in the Middle East that is set to be held in November are becoming
clear. American President George W. Bush called for it... It gives
the Arabs the impression that their cooperation in solving the
American problem with Iraq and Iran will benefit them when it comes
to the matter of Middle East peace. But Israel's agenda is
completely different from Washington's. Israel has its own private
agenda concerning Iraq and Iran, and Israel's agenda does not
involve bearing the military, political, or economic losses that the
Americans have suffered. The only important thing to the Israelis
is implementing their own ambitions in the area...but the Arabs
learned their lesson from Oslo, which was born under similar
circumstances. And it did nothing to achieve the aspirations of the
Arabs or the Palestinians, as we see and hear about with the
unceasing aggression against the Arab peoples and Arab lands in
Palestine, in Lebanon, and in Syria... Arab solidarity on its
position holds out hope for the future peace of the Middle East, if
the Arabs hold to the roots of the issue and never relinquish any
established rights."
--------------
ARAB INFIGHTING OBLITERATES ALL OPPORTUNITIES
--------------

7. On Sunday, September 16, government-owned "Oman" (circulation
38,000) ran an editorial entitled, "Arab Infighting Obliterates All
Opportunities:"
"The Arab world is experiencing some of its worst and most dangerous
problems up to this point. The cause of this goes back to those
people among the countries and peoples of this region who want to
push it into strife between brothers...which leads to a weakening of
Arabs' power and their capabilities, and confines them to a small
arena of struggle and killing between brotherly sides, which opens
the field to numerous difficulties and differences that surely do
not benefit any Arab side... It is illogical to place the blame for
all of this on the shoulders of others, especially for what we are
doing with our hands."
--------------
NO SECURITY UNTIL WITHDRAWAL
--------------

8. On September 16, privately owned Arabic-language "Al-Shabiba"
(circulation 20,000) and its sister English-language daily "Times of
Oman" (circulation 25,000) ran a front-page article by
editor-in-chief Essa bin Mohammed al Zedjali, in reaction to the
testimony of Ambassador Crocker and General Petraeus:
"The whole world demands that foreign troops pull out from Iraq,
leaving the responsibility of governance to the sons of Iraqi soil.
The reason: they have not achieved the goals for which they came to
Iraq. Killings have become an everyday affair in Iraq. The term
'security' signifies no meaning for the Iraqi citizens...[foreign
troops] entered Iraq with promises of a prosperous and secure life
but unfortunately they have not been translated into reality...Four
years have passed since the entry of foreign troops in Iraq, but
failure is writ large on their faces...opinion polls in most
countries that have troops in Iraq have showed that their citizens
are in favor of early withdrawal...the international
community...looks forward to a total withdrawal of troops, paving
the way for the Iraqis to fill the vacuum and govern their country
with complete freedom."
GRAPPO