Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
06NEWDELHI2919
2006-04-28 13:30:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy New Delhi
Cable title:  

POST ASSESSMENT: CHEEMA UNLIKELY TO FACE TORTURE

Tags:  CJAN CVIS PTER PREL KCRM PHUM PGOV IN 
pdf how-to read a cable
VZCZCXRO8250
OO RUEHBI RUEHCI
DE RUEHNE #2919/01 1181330
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
O 281330Z APR 06
FM AMEMBASSY NEW DELHI
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 3137
INFO RUEHCI/AMCONSUL CALCUTTA 3449
RUEHCG/AMCONSUL CHENNAI 3342
RUEHBI/AMCONSUL MUMBAI 2614
RUEAWJA/DEPT OF JUSTICE WASHDC
RHEHNSC/NSC WASHDC
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 03 NEW DELHI 002919 

SIPDIS

SIPDIS
SENSITIVE

STATE FOR L/HRR ROBERT HARRIS
STATE FOR CA/VO/F/P JOHN O'MALLEY
STATE FOR DRL

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: CJAN CVIS PTER PREL KCRM PHUM PGOV IN
SUBJECT: POST ASSESSMENT: CHEEMA UNLIKELY TO FACE TORTURE
IF REMOVED TO INDIA (CORRECTED COPY)

REF: A. NEW DELHI 2171

B. 05 NEW DELHI 9513

C. 05 NEW DELHI 4449

UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 03 NEW DELHI 002919

SIPDIS

SIPDIS
SENSITIVE

STATE FOR L/HRR ROBERT HARRIS
STATE FOR CA/VO/F/P JOHN O'MALLEY
STATE FOR DRL

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: CJAN CVIS PTER PREL KCRM PHUM PGOV IN
SUBJECT: POST ASSESSMENT: CHEEMA UNLIKELY TO FACE TORTURE
IF REMOVED TO INDIA (CORRECTED COPY)

REF: A. NEW DELHI 2171

B. 05 NEW DELHI 9513

C. 05 NEW DELHI 4449


1. (U) This is a corrected copy, with changes throughout.


2. (SBU) Summary: As with the pending case involving Kulbir
Singh Barapind (Ref A),Post's assessment is that the law
enforcement climate in India, and specifically in Punjab, has
dramaticalhy improved since Harpal Singh Cheema ("Cheema")
fled India in 1993. At that time, a violent insurgency was
raging across the Punjab and viewed as a serious threat by
the government in Delhi. Tensions rose in 1984 when Sikh
terrorists assassinated the serving PM of India, Indira
Gandhi. Today, Punjab remains one of the richest states in
Indii, with a progressive government whose Chief Minister (a
Sikh) is working to promote harmonious relations among
religious groups and between India and Pakistani Punjab.


3. (SBU) India also remains a robust democracy, and the
Indian government and people are proud of their traditions of
rule of law and protection of human rights. India's free
press, including in Punjab, actively pursues and exposes
government excesses of all varieties, including torture and
corruption. The end of the Punjab insurgency in the 1990s
ushered in a dramatic decline in custodial deaths and torture
allegations. Nor do Sikhs face specific hardships; they are
notably prosperous as a people and fully integrated in Indian
civil society. For example, the current Indian Prime
Minister and Army Chief are Sikhs. Sikhs also enjoy personal
income higher than the national average, assets out of
proportion to their demographic numbers, and a higher
percentage of positions in the Armed Forces, police, and
bureaucracy than their numbers vis a vis the rest of the
population of India. Finally, now Sikhs overwhelmingly
oppose the efforts of Khalistani (pro-insurgency) Sikhs, and
the intensive police and security force anti-insurgency

efforts of the 1980s and 1990s are largely a thing of the
past. While we cannot guarantee absolutely that Cheema would
not face torture or other forms of custodial abuse, this
Mission believes that, for the factors outlined in this
cable, such treatment would be unlikely if Cheema were
removed to India, especially with robust monitoring by human
rights NGOs, local media, and Cheema's extended family. End
Summary.

Improved Conditions for Sikhs
--------------


4. (SBU) Conditions for Sikhs began to improve in the
mid-1990s and progress has been rapid during the past five
years. In order to answer Department of Homeland Security
questions regarding the current treatment of Sikhs in India,
Embassy New Delhi investigators have worked in Punjab and
other Indian states for years to determine the validity of
Sikh asylum applications; to date, we have been unable to
substantiate a single such claim. Conditions since the
mid-1990s have improved so dramatically that, in our view,
there have been no legitimate grounds for such asylum seekers
since that period. Many legitimate asylum seekers who
applied before that period and had already been settled in
the US and other countries have since returned to India and
reassimilated into Indian society. Indeed, recent press
reports have highlighted the cases of "wanted terrorists" who
have since assumed leading positions in the Punjab business
community.

Signatory to CAT, State Party to ICCPR
--------------


5. (U) India signed the UN Convention Against Torture and
Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment
(Convention Against Torture or CAT) in October 1997, over
four years after Cheema fled to Canada, and nearly 10 years
ago. Although not yet ratified, the Indian government
recognizes that "as a signatory, India has good-faith
obligation not to act against the objectives and purposes of
the Convention" (Ref A). India is also a State Party to the
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, Article
7 of which provides that "No one shall be subjected to
torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or
punishment."


NEW DELHI 00002919 002 OF 003


High Profile, High Visibility, High Accountability
-------------- --------------


6. (SBU) Mission is keenly aware of the culture of torture
and extrajudicial punishment in Indian jails, as we have
outlined in successive Human Rights Reports. However,
"Punjabi Kesari" editor Avinash Chopra -- who lost several
relatives to Sikh terrorists in the 1980s-90s -- told us that
the strong presence of human rights activists in Punjab would
help guarantee good behavior by Punjab police toward any
persons returned to India (Ref B). Mission understands only
a handful of Indian criminal and terrorist suspects have been
removed to India from the US since 2000. Mission also notes
the favorable Indian press coverage in late 2005 of the
return of Abu Salem, who was extradited from Portugal last
year for his alleged role as the principal suspect in the
March 12, 1993 Mumbai bombings that killed 250 and injured
more than 700. If Cheema is removed to India, particularly
after the Abu Salem extradition and the recent (and
extensively media covered) historic visit of President Bush,
Mission expects extensive and long-running media coverage
will contribute to guaranteeing good behavior on the part of
Indian officials.


7. (SBU) We are similarly encouraged by the most recent
terrorism case involving Sikh suspects, the May 2005 Delhi
cinema bombings (Ref C). Mission believes the high
visibility of the case helped ensure that police officers in
Delhi, Haryana, and Punjab maintained professional standards.
The investigation into the cinema bombings was marked only
by arrests, not by extrajudicial killings or other police
excesses.


8. (SBU) As noted in the 2005 Human Rights Report, however,
custodial abuse, including sometimes torture, remains a
problem in India, and many alleged police violators,
particularly from earlier, more violent times, have not been
tried for their reported offenses. The Indian media
reported, however, that 59 Punjab police officers were found
guilty of human rights violations in 2004, and the Director
General of Punjab Police reported that criminal proceedings
had begun in the cases of two persons who died in police
custody during the year.

National Human Rights Commission Maturing
--------------


9. (SBU) India's"National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) --
the entity created in 1993 and tasked by law "for better
protection of human rights" -- did not exist when Cheema was
allegedly tortured in 1989 and 1992. It now has over a
decade of experience in investigating and assessing human
rights violations in India. Their mandate includes both
positive human rights violations and "negligence in the
prevention of such violation," according to the Protection of
Human Rights Act (1993). GOI assurances aside, the NHRC is
legally empowered to visit prisoners "in any jail or any
other institution under the control of the State Government"
for this purpose. Their senior officers are empowered to
"enter any building where the Commission has reason to
believe that any document relating to the subject matter of
the inquiry may be found, and may seize any such document."
The NHRC is an active organization that operates
independently of the government and has loudly criticized
some government institutions and actions.

Changed India-US Macro Dynamic
--------------


10. (SBU) The contours of the India-US relationship have
dramatically improved over those in 1990. From a very narrow
and relationship still largely colored by the prism of Cold
War politics, we now have a broad-based and deep-rooted
bilateral agenda on a range of issues, including
counter-terrorism, which was lacking in 1990, and the
historic civil nuclear deal. The GOI would be interested in
maintaining and furthering these relations, including for
future extraditions and removals (several remain pending),
and would be more vigilant about not allowing any missteps
that could lead to a reversal of relations either on removals
and extraditions specifically, or on the India-US
relationship more broadly.


NEW DELHI 00002919 003 OF 003


Other Eyes, Voices, Will Help Ensure Good Behavior
-------------- --------------


11. (SBU) During the Sikh insurgency in the 1980s and 1990s,
police routinely tortured and/or killed terrorists' families
and associates. Today, however, India has numerous activist
human rights NGOs that specialize in assisting victims of
police abuse, including some that focus on Punjab. The free
press is also sensitive to human rights, and the Supreme
Court has recently issued guidelines aimed at preventing and,
if necessary, prosecuting incidence of torture and custodial
abuse.

Overall Post Assessment: Torture Not Likely
--------------


12. (SBU) While we cannot guarantee absolutely that Cheema
would not face torture or other forms of custodial abuse,
this Mission believes that, for the factors outlined above,
such treatment would be unlikely if Cheema were removed to
India, especially with robust monitoring by human rights
NGOs, local media, and Cheema's extended family.
BLAKE