Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
06MUSCAT1345
2006-09-12 13:45:00
UNCLASSIFIED
Embassy Muscat
Cable title:
MEDIA REACTION: SEPTEMBER 11 FIFTH ANNIVERSARY, ARAB LEAGUE
how-toVZCZCXRO0059 PP RUEHBC RUEHDE RUEHKUK DE RUEHMS #1345/01 2551345 ZNR UUUUU ZZH P 121345Z SEP 06 FM AMEMBASSY MUSCAT TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 7130 INFO RUEHEE/ARAB LEAGUE COLLECTIVE RUEHLO/AMEMBASSY LONDON 0435 RUEHFR/AMEMBASSY PARIS 0327 RHMFISS/CDR USCENTCOM MACDILL AFB FL
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 MUSCAT 001345
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
STATE FOR NEA/ARP, NEA/PPD, NEA/PI, AND INR/R/MR
STATE PASS USTR FOR N. MOORJANI, J. BUNTIN
LONDON FOR TSOU
PARIS FOR ZEYA
USCENTCOM FOR PLUSH
FOREIGN PRESS CENTER FOR SILAS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: OIIP KPAO KMDR MU
SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION: SEPTEMBER 11 FIFTH ANNIVERSARY, ARAB LEAGUE
PEACE PROPOSAL
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 02 MUSCAT 001345
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
STATE FOR NEA/ARP, NEA/PPD, NEA/PI, AND INR/R/MR
STATE PASS USTR FOR N. MOORJANI, J. BUNTIN
LONDON FOR TSOU
PARIS FOR ZEYA
USCENTCOM FOR PLUSH
FOREIGN PRESS CENTER FOR SILAS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: OIIP KPAO KMDR MU
SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION: SEPTEMBER 11 FIFTH ANNIVERSARY, ARAB LEAGUE
PEACE PROPOSAL
1. SUMMARY: Omani press gave wide (and surprisingly acerbic)
coverage to the fifth anniversary of the September 11 attacks.
Columnists in government-owned "Oman" suggested that 9/11 was an
Israeli conspiracy and that the post-9/11 U.S. "adventure" has made
the world less secure. After the recent Arab League ministerial
meeting about the peace process, privately-owned "Al-Watan" wrote
that Israeli invasions and the world's failure to implement UN
resolutions are responsible for the current deadlock. END SUMMARY.
--------------
COVERAGE
--------------
2. Oman's Arabic dailies covered the 9/11 anniversary in different
ways, but in general focused on the tragedy's uncertain legacy. On
September 12, the front page of government-owned "Oman" (circulation
38,000) proclaimed, "On the Anniversary of September 11 the World
Renews its Campaign against Terrorism / Zawahri Singles out the Gulf
and Israel in His Threats," accompanying the headline with color
image of victims' families laying flowers on a memorial pond at the
World Trade Center site in New York. On September 12, private
dailies "Al-Shabiba" (circulation 20,000) and "Al-Watan"
(circulation 42,000) did not front-page 9/11 features, but inside
carried full-page spreads with color photographs and articles about
U.S. memorial ceremonies. On September 11 itself, "Oman" headlined:
"Five Years since September 11, the Anniversary and the Results:
Bin Laden Free and American Difficulties in Iraq and Afghanistan,"
over an article commenting on internal divisions among Americans
concerning how to confront and prevent terrorism. Also on September
11, "Oman" carried inside-page stories headlined : "German Political
Expert: America Changed after 9/11 but Not for the Better / Bush
Failed in Achieving Democracy in Iraq and Afghanistan, and Europe
Works to Carry its Costs," and "The World is as Far as can be from
Security -- Attacks Increased wherever Western Interests are Found."
On September 11, youth-oriented "Al-Shabibah" front-paged AFP
covering quoting the Secretary, "America is Now More Secure; the
Search Continues for Bin Laden." The same AFP piece was carried by
"Al-Watan" in tandem with MCT (former Knight-Ridder) wire coverage
of 9/11's impact on U.S. civil liberties.
-------------- ---
BLOCK QUOTES: PROBLEMS WITH ARAB LEAGUE PROPOSAL
-------------- ---
3. On September 7, "Al-Watan" (privately owned daily, circulation
42,000) suggested a "New Mechanism to Move the Peace Process
Forward":
"The ministerial council of the Arab League announced that the Arab
countries are going to demand a new mechanism for resuming the
Middle East peace process and define a timeframe for settling the
Arab/Israeli conflict in the Security Council. However, there are a
couple of facts to consider in light of that announcement: first
that a new or an old "mechanism" is irrelevant to the problem at
hand. Instead, we need to end Israel's continuous invasions and
projects to swallow up more Arab territories, actions that are
responsible for the deadlock. The second is that there is a lack of
will on the part of the international community to force Israel's
adherence to Security Council resolutions."
--------------
9/11 IN ISRAEL'S INTEREST
--------------
4. On September 11, government-owned Arabic daily "Oman"
(circulation 38,000) carried an an op-ed piece on "U.S.-Israeli
Disagreement over Priorities in the Region:"
"There have been many efforts to drag America into a clash with
confrontational groups, among them the small cell that helped plan
the 9/11 operations while maintaining ties to Israeli intelligence.
Although this page was closed for a while, it is considered one in
lengthy chain of events that constitute Israeli efforts to draw the
American machine to the Arab region... The Israelis dreamed of
showing [America] as the enemy of the Arabs, so that Israel remains
the only strategic partner, being able to realize all its political
and strategic interests.... However, even if we discard the
conspiracy theory and all Israeli technical contributions to the
9/11 operation, it would be equally true that Israel and its people
in the American administration have worked hard to push America and
its citizens into an open confrontation with Arabs and Muslims in
Afghanistan and Iraq. Washington has realized none of its interests
MUSCAT 00001345 002 OF 002
in these cases; rather, all the war's political and strategic
advantages have gone to Israel. America's fighting on two fronts
has given the Israelis more scope to isolate the Palestinians and
work for international recognition of their security necessities as
an excuse for assassinations, destruction, and arrests, along with
the discarding of any peace projects for the region."
-------------- --------------
WORLD AT RISK AFTER 9/11 DUE TO "AMERICAN ADVENTURE"
-------------- --------------
5. Another columnist for "Oman" wrote about 9/11 as "A Day that
Changed the Course of History":
"This has become a definitive date in the calendar of humanity, such
that events are characterized as pre or post-9/11... Since then,
Afghanistan was attacked and the Taliban was demolished as a
government but not a movement. Then it was Iraq's turn, and
American forces invaded the country under the pretext that it was
providing support and coverage to Al Qaeda. The Americans recently
discovered that the former Iraqi president did not have anything to
do with Al Qaeda... but despite this discovery nobody questioned
America! America's anger increased after 9/11 and brought down
human societies using all the technical and military expertise
available in efforts to eliminate terrorism. However, [America]
could not eliminate the roots of the problem and instead complicated
it. More anti-American movements appeared and extremism increased.
The safety and stability of whole world is endangered because of the
American adventure."
GRAPPO
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
STATE FOR NEA/ARP, NEA/PPD, NEA/PI, AND INR/R/MR
STATE PASS USTR FOR N. MOORJANI, J. BUNTIN
LONDON FOR TSOU
PARIS FOR ZEYA
USCENTCOM FOR PLUSH
FOREIGN PRESS CENTER FOR SILAS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: OIIP KPAO KMDR MU
SUBJECT: MEDIA REACTION: SEPTEMBER 11 FIFTH ANNIVERSARY, ARAB LEAGUE
PEACE PROPOSAL
1. SUMMARY: Omani press gave wide (and surprisingly acerbic)
coverage to the fifth anniversary of the September 11 attacks.
Columnists in government-owned "Oman" suggested that 9/11 was an
Israeli conspiracy and that the post-9/11 U.S. "adventure" has made
the world less secure. After the recent Arab League ministerial
meeting about the peace process, privately-owned "Al-Watan" wrote
that Israeli invasions and the world's failure to implement UN
resolutions are responsible for the current deadlock. END SUMMARY.
--------------
COVERAGE
--------------
2. Oman's Arabic dailies covered the 9/11 anniversary in different
ways, but in general focused on the tragedy's uncertain legacy. On
September 12, the front page of government-owned "Oman" (circulation
38,000) proclaimed, "On the Anniversary of September 11 the World
Renews its Campaign against Terrorism / Zawahri Singles out the Gulf
and Israel in His Threats," accompanying the headline with color
image of victims' families laying flowers on a memorial pond at the
World Trade Center site in New York. On September 12, private
dailies "Al-Shabiba" (circulation 20,000) and "Al-Watan"
(circulation 42,000) did not front-page 9/11 features, but inside
carried full-page spreads with color photographs and articles about
U.S. memorial ceremonies. On September 11 itself, "Oman" headlined:
"Five Years since September 11, the Anniversary and the Results:
Bin Laden Free and American Difficulties in Iraq and Afghanistan,"
over an article commenting on internal divisions among Americans
concerning how to confront and prevent terrorism. Also on September
11, "Oman" carried inside-page stories headlined : "German Political
Expert: America Changed after 9/11 but Not for the Better / Bush
Failed in Achieving Democracy in Iraq and Afghanistan, and Europe
Works to Carry its Costs," and "The World is as Far as can be from
Security -- Attacks Increased wherever Western Interests are Found."
On September 11, youth-oriented "Al-Shabibah" front-paged AFP
covering quoting the Secretary, "America is Now More Secure; the
Search Continues for Bin Laden." The same AFP piece was carried by
"Al-Watan" in tandem with MCT (former Knight-Ridder) wire coverage
of 9/11's impact on U.S. civil liberties.
-------------- ---
BLOCK QUOTES: PROBLEMS WITH ARAB LEAGUE PROPOSAL
-------------- ---
3. On September 7, "Al-Watan" (privately owned daily, circulation
42,000) suggested a "New Mechanism to Move the Peace Process
Forward":
"The ministerial council of the Arab League announced that the Arab
countries are going to demand a new mechanism for resuming the
Middle East peace process and define a timeframe for settling the
Arab/Israeli conflict in the Security Council. However, there are a
couple of facts to consider in light of that announcement: first
that a new or an old "mechanism" is irrelevant to the problem at
hand. Instead, we need to end Israel's continuous invasions and
projects to swallow up more Arab territories, actions that are
responsible for the deadlock. The second is that there is a lack of
will on the part of the international community to force Israel's
adherence to Security Council resolutions."
--------------
9/11 IN ISRAEL'S INTEREST
--------------
4. On September 11, government-owned Arabic daily "Oman"
(circulation 38,000) carried an an op-ed piece on "U.S.-Israeli
Disagreement over Priorities in the Region:"
"There have been many efforts to drag America into a clash with
confrontational groups, among them the small cell that helped plan
the 9/11 operations while maintaining ties to Israeli intelligence.
Although this page was closed for a while, it is considered one in
lengthy chain of events that constitute Israeli efforts to draw the
American machine to the Arab region... The Israelis dreamed of
showing [America] as the enemy of the Arabs, so that Israel remains
the only strategic partner, being able to realize all its political
and strategic interests.... However, even if we discard the
conspiracy theory and all Israeli technical contributions to the
9/11 operation, it would be equally true that Israel and its people
in the American administration have worked hard to push America and
its citizens into an open confrontation with Arabs and Muslims in
Afghanistan and Iraq. Washington has realized none of its interests
MUSCAT 00001345 002 OF 002
in these cases; rather, all the war's political and strategic
advantages have gone to Israel. America's fighting on two fronts
has given the Israelis more scope to isolate the Palestinians and
work for international recognition of their security necessities as
an excuse for assassinations, destruction, and arrests, along with
the discarding of any peace projects for the region."
-------------- --------------
WORLD AT RISK AFTER 9/11 DUE TO "AMERICAN ADVENTURE"
-------------- --------------
5. Another columnist for "Oman" wrote about 9/11 as "A Day that
Changed the Course of History":
"This has become a definitive date in the calendar of humanity, such
that events are characterized as pre or post-9/11... Since then,
Afghanistan was attacked and the Taliban was demolished as a
government but not a movement. Then it was Iraq's turn, and
American forces invaded the country under the pretext that it was
providing support and coverage to Al Qaeda. The Americans recently
discovered that the former Iraqi president did not have anything to
do with Al Qaeda... but despite this discovery nobody questioned
America! America's anger increased after 9/11 and brought down
human societies using all the technical and military expertise
available in efforts to eliminate terrorism. However, [America]
could not eliminate the roots of the problem and instead complicated
it. More anti-American movements appeared and extremism increased.
The safety and stability of whole world is endangered because of the
American adventure."
GRAPPO