Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
06BRASILIA637
2006-03-31 19:22:00
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Embassy Brasilia
Cable title:  

CODEL GRASSLEY MEETS WITH BRAZILIAN GOVERNMENT

Tags:  ETRD EAGR WTRO ENRG PGOV PREL BR 
pdf how-to read a cable
VZCZCXRO9186
PP RUEHRG
DE RUEHBR #0637/01 0901922
ZNR UUUUU ZZH
P 311922Z MAR 06
FM AMEMBASSY BRASILIA
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 4970
INFO RUCPDO/USDOC WASHDC
RUEHLP/AMEMBASSY LA PAZ 4460
RUEHSO/AMCONSUL SAO PAULO 6656
RUEHRG/AMCONSUL RECIFE 4538
RUEHRI/AMCONSUL RIO DE JANEIRO 1791
RUEHAC/AMEMBASSY ASUNCION 5320
RUEHMN/AMEMBASSY MONTEVIDEO 6146
RUEHBU/AMEMBASSY BUENOS AIRES 3901
RUEATRS/DEPT OF TREASURY WASHDC
RUEHRC/USDA WASHDC
UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 BRASILIA 000637 

SIPDIS


SENSITIVE
SIPDIS

H-PASS
STATE PASS TO USTR FOR MSULLIVAN/KLEZNY
NSC FOR SUE CRONIN
DEPT OF TREASURY FOR FPARODI
USDOC FOR 4332/ITA/MAC/WH/OLAC/JANDERSEN/ADRISCOLL/MWAR D
USDOC FOR 3134/USFCS/OIO/SHUPKA

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ETRD EAGR WTRO ENRG PGOV PREL BR
SUBJECT: CODEL GRASSLEY MEETS WITH BRAZILIAN GOVERNMENT
POLICYMAKERS


UNCLAS SECTION 01 OF 04 BRASILIA 000637

SIPDIS


SENSITIVE
SIPDIS

H-PASS
STATE PASS TO USTR FOR MSULLIVAN/KLEZNY
NSC FOR SUE CRONIN
DEPT OF TREASURY FOR FPARODI
USDOC FOR 4332/ITA/MAC/WH/OLAC/JANDERSEN/ADRISCOLL/MWAR D
USDOC FOR 3134/USFCS/OIO/SHUPKA

E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: ETRD EAGR WTRO ENRG PGOV PREL BR
SUBJECT: CODEL GRASSLEY MEETS WITH BRAZILIAN GOVERNMENT
POLICYMAKERS



1. (SBU) Summary and Introduction. During a March 19-23 trip to
Brazil, a Congressional delegation led by Senate Finance Committee
Chairman, Senator Chuck Grassley (IA),visited Manaus, Santarem
(Para state),Brasilia, Maringa (Parana state),and Sao Paulo. This
cable reports on the Codel's March 21 meetings in Brasilia with
Foreign Minister Amorim, Trade Minister Furlan, and Agriculture
Minister Rodrigues. The delegation's session with Foreign Minister
Celso Amorim focused almost exclusively on the WTO Doha Round trade
negotiations. Amorim declined to provide details of Brazil's next
move in the talks, but reiterated general statements about the GOB's
intent to improve its offers on industrial products (NAMA) and
services. Noting that he agreed with Senator Grassley that time was
running short, Amorim said he saw services and the outline of a
final deal falling into the June/July timeframe rather than the end
of April. Trade Minister Furlan's principal message was that U.S.
agricultural subsidies distort world markets and disadvantage
Brazil. The session with Minister of Agriculture Rodrigues was very
positive, with both sides expressing a desire to cooperate,
particularly on WTO Doha Round issues. Although each meeting was
held separately, the three ministers delivered a coordinated message
that the U.S. and Brazil need to do more to develop third country
markets for renewable fuels such as ethanol. A report on the
meetings in Sao Paulo and Maringa with private sector and NGO
representatives, which covered the same general topics though our
interlocutors there adopted a harsher tone -- will be sent septel.
End Summary and Introduction.

--------------
The Delegation
--------------

2. (U) In addition to Senator Grassley, the delegation consisted
of:
--Senator Mike Crapo (ID),Senate Finance Committee

--Senator Wayne Allard (CO),Senate Appropriations Committee
--Representative Collin Peterson (MN),Ranking Member, House Ag
Committee
--Representative Steve King (IA),House Agriculture Committee
--Representative Phil English (PA),House Ways and Means Committee
--Representative Darrell Issa (CA),House International Relations
Committee
--Representative Russ Carnahan (MO),House Transportation &
Infrastructure Committee
--Everett Eissenstat, Assistant U.S. Trade Representative for the
Americas

--------------
Meeting with the Minister of Foreign Affairs
--------------


3. (SBU) Minister Amorim welcomed the delegation, stating that
relations between Brazil and the United States were good and noting
the excellent chemistry between Presidents Bush and Lula as well as
his own positive relationship with USTR Portman. Amorim
characterized the WTO as a forum for mutual cooperation, although he
described Brazilian and U.S. interests as not identical, but
"concurrent." Specifically, he spoke of the need to identify future
areas of bilateral cooperation, such as assistance to Lusophone
African countries and expansion of ethanol markets (given the
increased interest in the United States in renewable fuels).

Doha Negotiations
--------------


4. (SBU) Senator Grassley pointed out that timing for completion of
the Doha Round is very tight given expiration of Trade Promotion
Authority (TPA) in mid-2007, adding that the U.S. Congress does not
appear inclined to extend TPA. He emphasized the importance of the
April deadline for decisions on full modalities for agriculture and
NAMA. On the substance of the negotiations, Grassley said the U.S.
is willing to trade subsidies for market access and that the U.S.
should get credit for its good faith effort within its existing
agricultural offer. Now is not the time for the U.S. to make a new
offer, he declared. Should the Doha Round fail, Grassley predicted
that U.S. farm programs would look s they had in the past.

BRASILIA 00000637 002 OF 004




5. (SBU) Amorim agreed that time was short for the Doha
negotiations. He portrayed the Hong Kong Ministerial as an
important step in the process as was WTO Director General Lamy's end
of April deadline, but identified the June/July timeframe for
movement in services and suggested there should be an outline of a
final deal by the beginning of July. To reach a final deal, he
sketched out the major contributions necessary by the main actors:
EU would have to give on market access, Japan on anti-dumping
(rules); the U.S. on domestic support; and Brazil would offer
"something" on NAMA and services.


6. (SBU) Amorim declined to provide greater specificity on the
"something" to be offered in NAMA and services, but commented that
proposed legislation pending in the Brazilian congress would make it
easier for Brazil to improve its offer in mode 3 for services. In
response to a question by Representative English, Amorim argued that
while the Doha negotiations on rules were very important,
specifically zeroing and de minimis provisions within antidumping
proceedings, the outcome on this would not end up being a
deal-breaker.


7. (SBU) Extension of TPA was possible, Amorim opined, though he
acknowledged that it couldn't be counted on. Consistent with public
statements, Amorim portrayed the U.S. agricultural offer as
"important" but "not sufficient," stating that Brazil wants the
elimination of all subsidies, although he acknowledged that
elimination would not be possible without improved market access.
While the U.S. offer is not enough, Amorim said he still prefers to
work quietly through negotiation rather than through litigation,
arguing that if Brazil and the United States couldn't solve trade
issues, how could they solve other troublesome issues such as
efforts to combat terrorism.


8. (SBU) Finally, Amorim remarked that Brazil is not looking for
special and differential (S&D) treatment within agriculture, despite
the fact that rich countries enjoy S&D through their ability to
offer domestic subsidies. He characterized collaboration with the
U.S. to press the EU for improvements in market access as in
Brazil's interest, and suggested that Brazil has the ability to move
India toward greater market access concessions. Potentially
isolated in the end, India would not hold back conclusion of the
Doha Round, Amorim commented. The principal point for him was that
Brazil and the United States need to reach agreement.

FTAA Negotiations
--------------


9. (SBU) Amorim touched briefly on the Free Trade Area of the
Americas (FTAA) negotiations, providing several reasons for why they
have not flourished -- among them that the talks were initiated in a
different context than today, i.e., prior to the launching of the
Doha Round. He also claimed that diversity among the FTAA partners
made a final deal difficult since "what is good for El Salvador may
not be good for Brazil."

Ethanol and Embraer
--------------


10. (SBU) In response to a query from Senator Allard regarding
ethanol, Amorim made a pitch for greater bilateral cooperation in
developing third country markets for Brazilian and US-produced
ethanol. In closing, Amorim complained about USG interference,
which ultimately aborted Embraer's sale of Super Tucano aircraft to
Venezuela.

--------------
Meeting with Minister of Trade
--------------


11. (SBU) Furlan opened the friendly, hour and a half discussion
by stating that Brazil is highly competitive in agribusiness due to
productivity gains made through process improvements and advances in
farming technologies. He recounted his meeting with President Bush

BRASILIA 00000637 003 OF 004


in November, and how he had demonstrated to the latter a strong
connection between Brazilian agriculture and the U.S. economy -
i.e., three of the four major agribusiness conglomerates operating
in Brazil have significant U.S. shareholdings. Furlan stated his
belief that President Bush understands that Brazil is "winning the
war against agricultural subsidies," and that it will be hard for
the United States to compete with Brazil on a level playing field.
Even with the recent outbreaks of bovine hoof-and-mouth disease and
avian influenza, Furlan believes Brazil to be more competitive on
sanitary issues.


12. (SBU) The Minister stated that the Brazilian economy continues
to grow, as social development and increased employment under the
Lula administration have led to increased consumption. Industrial
goods account for 55% of Brazilian exports, and Brazil actively
seeks to diversify its products and export markets. With a US$45
billion dollar trade surplus and a strengthening currency, Furlan
said that he worries that Brazil is not importing enough inputs.

WTO Talks
--------------


13. (SBU) In response to a question from Senator Allard, Furlan
responded that, for the most part, he believed that Brazil was
aligned with the United States on most WTO issues. He stated that
since the United States agreed to reduce agricultural subsidies on
the condition that the EU do the same, this shows that the U.S.
recognizes that the current system is unsustainable in the long
term. He also went on to say that Brazil understands that it needs
to open it own markets, and not be as defensive on services. He
thought that Brazil could compete fairly on services, particularly
banking, e-commerce and e-government applications.


14. (SBU) Rep. English mentioned that the USG was pleased with the
constructive role Brazil played during the December Hong Kong
meeting, and asked how Furlan thought the WTO Doha Round would
evolve and whether he envisioned further opportunities for finding
common ground. Furlan commented that since the Uruguay round,
multilateral trade negotiation meetings have largely been a waste of
time. In his view, all depended upon major moves coming from the US
and EU. He felt that the formation of the G-20 was useful, because
it helped define common ground between smaller countries which were
similarly aligned.

Biotech
--------------


15. (SBU) On the issue of biotech labeling requirements, Furlan
stated his belief that Brazil was one of the few countries in the
world that knows how to properly segregate GMO crops, and said that
Brazilian farmers will continue to produce whatever the market
dictates. Furlan went on to compare cattle production in Brazil and
the United States, likening U.S. feed lots to "cattle hotels," while
Brazilian cattle were pasture-fed the "old-fashioned way" with
natural grasses.

Flex-fuel Vehicles
--------------


16. (SBU) Furlan praised Brazil flex-fuel vehicle programs and
opined that Brazil sees increasing ethanol consumption not only as a
future commodity, but as a way to improve air quality around the
planet. He stated that flex-fuel cars represent 70% of GM's
Brazilian production, adding that in Brazil the difference in price
between flex and non-flex vehicles is much smaller than in the U.S.
because of less complicated technology.


17. (SBU) The meeting ended with Furlan sending his regards to
Senator Grassley (who was unable to attend the meeting) and
expressing his desire to meet with him during the Minister's next
trip to Washington. In addition, the Minister stated that he is
looking forward to hosting visits by USTR Portman, Energy Secretary
Bodman, and Commerce Secretary Gutierrez in the near future.


BRASILIA 00000637 004 OF 004


--------------
Meeting with Agriculture Minister
--------------


18. (SBU) In the session with Minister of Agriculture Rodrigues,
Senator Grassley reiterated the point that TPA expires soon and that
without greater market access opportunities it will be difficult to
get any Doha Round accord through Congress. For his part, Rodrigues
said he had participated in the recent London meetings and that
there appears to be little flexibility in current negotiating
positions. Like ForMin Amorim, he conceded that Brazil must offer
more on industrial products and services in order to gain improved
market access for agriculture.


19. (SBU) Turning to other issues, Minister Rodrigues, as did
Amorim and Furlan, emphasized that Brazil and the US should
cooperate on biofuels, thus providing a model for the world to
follow. When queried about prospects for biotech soybeans, the
Minister said that the current crop is about 20 percent biotech and
that within a few years it will increase to 50 percent. Both
Rodrigues and the Codel felt that there was room for Brazil-U.S.
cooperation on biotech, especially with regard to the EU. Senator
Grassley mentioned the need for Brazil to ensure adequate IPR
protection for GMO soybeans, acknowledging that progress has been
made but that additional GOB enforcement efforts would help.


20. (SBU) Finally, Rep. English invited Rodrigues to visit Capitol
Hill, citing the ongoing work being done in the Congressional Brazil
Caucus. From the Senate side, Senator Grassley extended a similar
invitation. (Rodrigues is scheduled to visit Washington April 25 and
is seeking a meeting at that time with Secretary Johanns.) Overall,
Rodrigues and his team felt that the meeting was a good step forward
in improving the bilateral relationship.


21. (U) This cable was cleared by Codel Grassley prior to
transmission.

Linehan