Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
06BERLIN1893
2006-07-06 14:51:00
UNCLASSIFIED
Embassy Berlin
how-toVZCZCXRO0738 RR RUEHAST DE RUEHRL #1893 1871451 ZNR UUUUU ZZH R 061451Z JUL 06 FM AMEMBASSY BERLIN TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC 4082 INFO RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE RUCNFRG/FRG COLLECTIVE
UNCLAS BERLIN 001893
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV GM
SUBJECT: HEALTH "REFORM" SPARKS COALITION CLASH
REF: (A) BERLIN 1822 (B) BERLIN 846
UNCLAS BERLIN 001893
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV GM
SUBJECT: HEALTH "REFORM" SPARKS COALITION CLASH
REF: (A) BERLIN 1822 (B) BERLIN 846
1. (U) After weeks of internal haggling, in the early morning
hours of July 3 Chancellor Merkel announced a compromise
agreement on health care reform, designated a top priority in
last fall's Coalition Agreement. The reform had been
intended to cut medical costs. However, the announced
agreement has drawn widespread criticism for its failure to
achieve this goal. The Coalition had first sought to shift
health care financing from payrolls to tax revenue. However,
after a rebellion from CDU/CSU state leaders against the
necessary new taxes, the coalition decided instead to raise
employee payroll contributions and gradually introduce
tax-based financing of health care for children from 2008.
There were no structural reforms that would reduce
sky-rocketing expenditures and red tape in the system.
2. (U) Critical responses, ranging from the disappointed to
the outraged, were quick to follow. Federal President
Koehler commented that, "laws that are rashly stitched
together often create more problems than they solve." From
the SPD, Chancellor Merkel has faced charges of weakness and
ineffective party management. SPD Bundestag Caucus leader
Struck: "Apparently she had to give in to the pressure from
the Ministers-President. That must not happen so often
again. Really, that shouldn't happen at all." Much
editorial comment tends to agree, seeing Merkel weakened and
more dependent on the demands of regional party leaders.
However, the SPD itself has not emerged unscathed. Within
the party, leftists have reportedly been very critical -- to
the extent that Struck in one paper is quoted as warning
leftist leader Andrea Nahles against giving any "foolish
interviews." CDU/CSU leaders have attacked it for presuming
that "reform" meant higher taxes and that the CDU/CSU had
ever agreed to such an approach.
3. (U) How long the political strife will last is unclear --
although hopes that the minimalist outcome would be obscured
by World Cup success disappeared when Germany lost in the
semi-finals on July 4. One CDU contact was bitter at the
public and media, whose expectations that somehow a Grand
Coalition would mean grand achievements were never realistic.
(He described the outcome as basically leaving current
structures untouched so that after the next election the
winner could move to introduce their desired reforms.)
However, the Chancellor's agenda will move quickly on, first
to the President's visit and then to an "Integration Summit,"
so the public and media will not have much time to linger
over the health care story.
TIMKEN JR
SIPDIS
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: N/A
TAGS: PGOV GM
SUBJECT: HEALTH "REFORM" SPARKS COALITION CLASH
REF: (A) BERLIN 1822 (B) BERLIN 846
1. (U) After weeks of internal haggling, in the early morning
hours of July 3 Chancellor Merkel announced a compromise
agreement on health care reform, designated a top priority in
last fall's Coalition Agreement. The reform had been
intended to cut medical costs. However, the announced
agreement has drawn widespread criticism for its failure to
achieve this goal. The Coalition had first sought to shift
health care financing from payrolls to tax revenue. However,
after a rebellion from CDU/CSU state leaders against the
necessary new taxes, the coalition decided instead to raise
employee payroll contributions and gradually introduce
tax-based financing of health care for children from 2008.
There were no structural reforms that would reduce
sky-rocketing expenditures and red tape in the system.
2. (U) Critical responses, ranging from the disappointed to
the outraged, were quick to follow. Federal President
Koehler commented that, "laws that are rashly stitched
together often create more problems than they solve." From
the SPD, Chancellor Merkel has faced charges of weakness and
ineffective party management. SPD Bundestag Caucus leader
Struck: "Apparently she had to give in to the pressure from
the Ministers-President. That must not happen so often
again. Really, that shouldn't happen at all." Much
editorial comment tends to agree, seeing Merkel weakened and
more dependent on the demands of regional party leaders.
However, the SPD itself has not emerged unscathed. Within
the party, leftists have reportedly been very critical -- to
the extent that Struck in one paper is quoted as warning
leftist leader Andrea Nahles against giving any "foolish
interviews." CDU/CSU leaders have attacked it for presuming
that "reform" meant higher taxes and that the CDU/CSU had
ever agreed to such an approach.
3. (U) How long the political strife will last is unclear --
although hopes that the minimalist outcome would be obscured
by World Cup success disappeared when Germany lost in the
semi-finals on July 4. One CDU contact was bitter at the
public and media, whose expectations that somehow a Grand
Coalition would mean grand achievements were never realistic.
(He described the outcome as basically leaving current
structures untouched so that after the next election the
winner could move to introduce their desired reforms.)
However, the Chancellor's agenda will move quickly on, first
to the President's visit and then to an "Integration Summit,"
so the public and media will not have much time to linger
over the health care story.
TIMKEN JR