Identifier | Created | Classification | Origin |
---|---|---|---|
06ATHENS1450 | 2006-06-05 14:42:00 | CONFIDENTIAL | Embassy Athens |
VZCZCXRO8681 PP RUEHDBU RUEHFL RUEHKW RUEHLA RUEHROV RUEHSR DE RUEHTH #1450/01 1561442 ZNY CCCCC ZZH P 051442Z JUN 06 ZDK FM AMEMBASSY ATHENS TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 5689 INFO RUEHNC/AMEMBASSY NICOSIA PRIORITY 2558 RUEHAK/AMEMBASSY ANKARA PRIORITY 4142 RUEHBS/USEU BRUSSELS PRIORITY RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE |
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 ATHENS 001450 |
1. (C) SUMMARY: FM Bakoyannis told Ambassador June 5 that she would sound out Turkish FM Gul, at a meeting later this week in Istanbul, on opening up the Turkish Cypriot port of Famagusta for direct trade in return for the nearby area of Varosha being given back to its Greek Cypriot owners. Aware of the potential train wreck with the EU for Turkey's failure to open its ports/airports to Greek Cypriot shipping, she argued this would be a "win-win" situation for all. In the aftermath of the May 23 fighter accident (ref), Bakoyannis said she would also discuss extending a 1988 Greek-Turkish agreement providing for a moratorium on Aegean training flights for the months of July and August, and would ask that the rest of June and September be included. Bakoyannis said the two countries' CHODs were already discussing safer rules of engagement for fighters, and this would be a discussion point with Gul as well. END SUMMARY. FM Agrees on Avoiding Turkey-EU Train Wreck -------------------------- 2. (C) At a June 5 meeting, FM Bakoyannis told Ambassador that Turkey faces a "very difficult" situation both domestically and vis-a-vis the EU regarding Turkey's EU accession prospects. She highlighted, in particular, that French Interior Minister Sarkozy was quite open in expressing opposition to Turkey's potential EU membership, and said she believed if Turkey became an issue in the French election campaign, things would become even more "complicated." The FM agreed with Ambassador that we must find a way out of the potential train wreck this fall if Turkey should fail to implement its promise to open its ports/airports to Greek Cypriot shipping. The idea of postponing this decision via Turkey referring the matter to the ECJ would only make things worse, in the FM's opinion. 3 (C) The FM expressed concern about the situation inside Turkey, and asked for our take. Ambassador responded that it is not as bad as it looks. The recent assassination of the state judge was a serious matter, but our Embassy in Ankara was of the view the government would weather the storm. Ambassador noted that U.S. relations with Turkey in recent months had improved. The FM pointedly responded that Greek-Turkish relations were not better, and that she was worried about Greek public opinion becoming restless with a rapprochement policy that had not produced much. FM To Sell FM Gul on Famagusta-Varosha -------------------------- 4. (C) The FM proposed pitching FM Gul, with whom she'll meet on the margins of a June 9-10 conference in Istanbul, on the well-known offer of opening the port of Famagusta for direct trade (under EU administration) in return for the nearby area of Varosha being given back to its Greek Cypriot owners. She argued this would be a "win-win" for all. To speak just of opening Famagusta without returning Varosha would "be impossible" for Cypriot President Papadopoulos to accept. The FM noted that Greek Cypriot investment could then flow into Varosha, providing jobs for Turkish Cypriots and serving as an example of reunification. Asked whether Ankara could accept returning Varosha right now, since it had always held that it should be a final status issue, the FM responded that just opening Famagusta for direct trade would only strengthen partition because there would be no interlinkage of the two communities. Bakoyannis dismissed the notion of opening trade over the Green Line, saying it would be impractical because of the need for the Greek Cypriots to conduct phytosanitary and other controls on arriving goods, undermining the political benefits. 5. (C) Asked what part of Famagusta, which serves the Turkish military as well, would be left for this activity, Bakoyannis said that the proposal concerns only commercial aspects and that "we are far from discussing" military matters. (Comment: We interpret the FM as signaling that the Greeks envisage a sector of the port being set aside for military cargoes outside of the zone of EU supervision. End Comment.) Asked what next steps would be if Gul expressed interest and what external partners could do to help, Bakoyannis said she would let us know. She noted that Greece is nearly alone within the EU in trying to help Turkey honor its obligations -- most EU members just want Turkey to implement the Protocol, and if that does not happen, then ATHENS 00001450 002.2 OF 002 believe Turkey's application should be postponed. Greek-Turkish Aegean CBMs -------------------------- 6. (C) Set against backdrop of the May 23 fighter accident, which resulted in the death of a Greek pilot (ref A), Bakoyannis said she would also discuss with FM Gul the extension of a 1988 memorandum between the then Greek and Turkish FMs ("Papoulias-Yilmaz understanding") that provided for a moratorium on military training flights in the Aegean during the months of July and August. She added that she would press for this agreement to include the rest of June and September as well. The FM responded positively to Ambassador's suggestion on the need for safer rules of engagement between the sides' fighters, saying the Greek and Turkish CHODs are already talking about this and that it would also be a discussion point with Gul. 7. (C) Ambassador complimented her decision to go ahead with her planned trip to Istanbul, despite negative public opinion fallout from the fighter accident. Smiling wryly and saying she's had enough people tell her not to make the trip to Istanbul, Bakoyannis said she "hopes nothing happens" during visit. In any event, the FM said she believes in having as much face-to-face contact as possible with her Turkish counterpart, since Gul "must know what our position is." Asked about the possibility of a joint Greece-Turkey referral of Aegean disputes to the ICJ, the FM again answered that "we are very far away from that." She said the Turks remain intransigent on this and PM Erdogan is not yet ready to talk. RIES |