Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
05TELAVIV4946
2005-08-10 14:16:00
CONFIDENTIAL
Embassy Tel Aviv
Cable title:
NETANYAHU SUPPORTERS SEEK EARLY LIKUD PRIMARIES TO
how-toThis record is a partial extract of the original cable. The full text of the original cable is not available.
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 TEL AVIV 004946
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 08/10/2015
TAGS: PGOV KWBG IS GOI INTERNAL
SUBJECT: NETANYAHU SUPPORTERS SEEK EARLY LIKUD PRIMARIES TO
UNSEAT SHARON; NEW POLLS PLACE NETANYAHU OVER SHARON
REF: TEL AVIV 4879
Classified By: Political Counselor Norman H. Olsen Jr. for reasons 1.4
(b,d).
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 TEL AVIV 004946
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 08/10/2015
TAGS: PGOV KWBG IS GOI INTERNAL
SUBJECT: NETANYAHU SUPPORTERS SEEK EARLY LIKUD PRIMARIES TO
UNSEAT SHARON; NEW POLLS PLACE NETANYAHU OVER SHARON
REF: TEL AVIV 4879
Classified By: Political Counselor Norman H. Olsen Jr. for reasons 1.4
(b,d).
1. (C) SUMMARY: Supporters of Likud MK and party leadership
contender Binyamin Netanyahu who are moving to compel early
party primaries received a morale boost with the publication
this week of poll results showing Netanyahu with a
first-time-ever lead over Prime Minister Sharon in support
from party members. The Ha'aretz poll showed Netanyahu
winning 35 percent/29.1 percent/17.3 percent in a three-way
race with Sharon and arch-disengagement foe Uzi Landau, who
announced his Likud candidacy August 9. The poll showed a
subsequent runoff race giving Netanyahu 47 percent to some 33
percent for Sharon. The Channel 10 poll of a two-way race
gave Netanyahu 42.1 percent to 27.7 percent for Sharon. The
numbers have sent prognosticators runing all over the map.
The head of a leading polling agency told Poloff that, while
Netanyahu now appears to have a better "starting point" for a
primary race, it is too early to tell whether he will keep
his lead over Sharon. Much, she underscored, is contingent
on how smoothly the disengagement plan can be implemented.
Israeli media commentators attribute the shift in Likud views
to the disengagement plan, which many of Likud's right-wing
voters oppose. Some media commentators continue to speculate
on whether Sharon will split Likud to form a new, more
centrist party. END SUMMARY.
--------------
Early Primaries Sought
--------------
2. (C) The Likud internal court is considering a petition
by 20 percent of Likud members to compel a Likud Central
Committee (LCC) meeting that would determine whether the
party should hold early primaries. The court proposed August
9 that the two sides reach an agreed-upon date for convening
the LCC. Netanyahu supporter and Likud MK Gilad Erdan, one
of the so-called Likud "rebels" who has opposed Sharon's
disengagement plan, told Poloff August 9 that he believes
that the Likud court will go farther in the coming days and
decide that the LCC must convene within the next two weeks to
consider a date for party primaries. Erdan said that he and
other Netanyahu supporters would like to see a primary date
set for 60 days after the LCC meeting -- sometime in the
middle of November. Eldan said that the Likud constitution
requires that party primaries be held at least six months
before general elections, now officially scheduled for
November 2006. Eldan predicted that "there will be a big
fight in the LCC" between Sharon and Netanyahu supporters
over when to set primaries, and he speculated that Netanyahu
would cancel his scheduled August 12 trip to the United
States August in order to remain in Israel to rally support
among LCC members.
--------------
Polls Shows Netanyahu in the Lead -- for Now
--------------
3. (C) Netanyahu supporters have been buoyed by two polls
released this week that give Netanyahu a strong lead over
Sharon in Likud primaries. A Ha'aretz poll of Likud voters
conducted some 24 hours after Netanyahu's resignation shows
Netanyahu winning 35 percent/29.1 percent/17.3 percent in a
three-way race with Sharon and arch-disengagement foe Uzi
Landau, who announced his Likud candidacy August 9. The poll
showed a subsequent runoff race giving Netanyahu 47 percent
to some 33 percent for Sharon. The Channel 10 poll of a
two-way race gave Netanyahu 42.1 percent to 27.7 percent for
Sharon. Likud MK Eldan predicted that "Landau will join Bibi
(Netanyahu) in the end." The right wing of Likud "will put a
lot of pressure on Landau" to drop out of the race, Eldan
highlighted.
4. (C) Mina Zemach, president of the major Israeli polling
agency "Dahaf," told Poloff August 9 that her agency is
conducting its own poll which should be released in the daily
Yedioth Ahronoth on Friday, August 12. She questioned
whether Netanyahu's actual lead is as wide as the polls
indicated. She said that she believes that the Ha'aretz and
Channel 10 polls are "representative and correct," but that
it is still too early to judge whether Netanyahu or Sharon
have a real lead in Likud. She noted that there is still no
date for Likud primaries. "It is better to wait until after
disengagement" to gauge Netanyahu's or Sharon's Likud
standing, Zemach said. Much will depend, she stressed, on
whether the disengagement plan is implemented without major
problems. Zemach also noted that many more right-wing
voters, including settlers, joined the Likud Party in the
recent voter drive, and that this could have buttressed
Netanyahu's standing.
-------------- --------------
Some Observers Already Predicting Political "Big Bang"
-------------- --------------
5. (C) Some media commentators and politicians are
predicting that Sharon's supposed weakened party standing
will prompt him to break with the party and form a new, more
centrist party with like-minded Likudniks and other more
centrist politicians from other parties. This "big bang"
theory arose months aro when fissures deepened in Likud over
Sharon's disengagement plan. Tel Aviv radio reported August
10 that "close confidants" of Sharon are "increasingly in
favor of the option of breaking off from the Likud and of
Ariel Sharon running at the head of a new political party.
MK Eldan noted that the Likud Knesset faction is "quite
divided" and that the number of Likud rebels in the Knesset
has likely swelled from 13 to at least 18. If the total
number of Likud MKs opposing Sharon reaches 20 -- or 50
percent of the Likud MKs -- Erdan noted, Sharon could no
longer take the Likud name with him if he split the party.
Reflecting the range of opinion within political circles MK
Yuval Steinetz told poloff that he was pleased with the poll
results and predicted that Sharon will retire shortly after
disengagement concludes. Shinui MK Ehud Rasabi, on the other
hand, said, "don't write off Sharon," implyig that the Prime
Minister has more than once defied his opponents' best
efforts.
********************************************* ********************
Visit Embassy Tel Aviv's Classified Website:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/nea/telaviv
You can also access this site through the State Department's
Classified SIPRNET website.
********************************************* ********************
KURTZER
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 08/10/2015
TAGS: PGOV KWBG IS GOI INTERNAL
SUBJECT: NETANYAHU SUPPORTERS SEEK EARLY LIKUD PRIMARIES TO
UNSEAT SHARON; NEW POLLS PLACE NETANYAHU OVER SHARON
REF: TEL AVIV 4879
Classified By: Political Counselor Norman H. Olsen Jr. for reasons 1.4
(b,d).
1. (C) SUMMARY: Supporters of Likud MK and party leadership
contender Binyamin Netanyahu who are moving to compel early
party primaries received a morale boost with the publication
this week of poll results showing Netanyahu with a
first-time-ever lead over Prime Minister Sharon in support
from party members. The Ha'aretz poll showed Netanyahu
winning 35 percent/29.1 percent/17.3 percent in a three-way
race with Sharon and arch-disengagement foe Uzi Landau, who
announced his Likud candidacy August 9. The poll showed a
subsequent runoff race giving Netanyahu 47 percent to some 33
percent for Sharon. The Channel 10 poll of a two-way race
gave Netanyahu 42.1 percent to 27.7 percent for Sharon. The
numbers have sent prognosticators runing all over the map.
The head of a leading polling agency told Poloff that, while
Netanyahu now appears to have a better "starting point" for a
primary race, it is too early to tell whether he will keep
his lead over Sharon. Much, she underscored, is contingent
on how smoothly the disengagement plan can be implemented.
Israeli media commentators attribute the shift in Likud views
to the disengagement plan, which many of Likud's right-wing
voters oppose. Some media commentators continue to speculate
on whether Sharon will split Likud to form a new, more
centrist party. END SUMMARY.
--------------
Early Primaries Sought
--------------
2. (C) The Likud internal court is considering a petition
by 20 percent of Likud members to compel a Likud Central
Committee (LCC) meeting that would determine whether the
party should hold early primaries. The court proposed August
9 that the two sides reach an agreed-upon date for convening
the LCC. Netanyahu supporter and Likud MK Gilad Erdan, one
of the so-called Likud "rebels" who has opposed Sharon's
disengagement plan, told Poloff August 9 that he believes
that the Likud court will go farther in the coming days and
decide that the LCC must convene within the next two weeks to
consider a date for party primaries. Erdan said that he and
other Netanyahu supporters would like to see a primary date
set for 60 days after the LCC meeting -- sometime in the
middle of November. Eldan said that the Likud constitution
requires that party primaries be held at least six months
before general elections, now officially scheduled for
November 2006. Eldan predicted that "there will be a big
fight in the LCC" between Sharon and Netanyahu supporters
over when to set primaries, and he speculated that Netanyahu
would cancel his scheduled August 12 trip to the United
States August in order to remain in Israel to rally support
among LCC members.
--------------
Polls Shows Netanyahu in the Lead -- for Now
--------------
3. (C) Netanyahu supporters have been buoyed by two polls
released this week that give Netanyahu a strong lead over
Sharon in Likud primaries. A Ha'aretz poll of Likud voters
conducted some 24 hours after Netanyahu's resignation shows
Netanyahu winning 35 percent/29.1 percent/17.3 percent in a
three-way race with Sharon and arch-disengagement foe Uzi
Landau, who announced his Likud candidacy August 9. The poll
showed a subsequent runoff race giving Netanyahu 47 percent
to some 33 percent for Sharon. The Channel 10 poll of a
two-way race gave Netanyahu 42.1 percent to 27.7 percent for
Sharon. Likud MK Eldan predicted that "Landau will join Bibi
(Netanyahu) in the end." The right wing of Likud "will put a
lot of pressure on Landau" to drop out of the race, Eldan
highlighted.
4. (C) Mina Zemach, president of the major Israeli polling
agency "Dahaf," told Poloff August 9 that her agency is
conducting its own poll which should be released in the daily
Yedioth Ahronoth on Friday, August 12. She questioned
whether Netanyahu's actual lead is as wide as the polls
indicated. She said that she believes that the Ha'aretz and
Channel 10 polls are "representative and correct," but that
it is still too early to judge whether Netanyahu or Sharon
have a real lead in Likud. She noted that there is still no
date for Likud primaries. "It is better to wait until after
disengagement" to gauge Netanyahu's or Sharon's Likud
standing, Zemach said. Much will depend, she stressed, on
whether the disengagement plan is implemented without major
problems. Zemach also noted that many more right-wing
voters, including settlers, joined the Likud Party in the
recent voter drive, and that this could have buttressed
Netanyahu's standing.
-------------- --------------
Some Observers Already Predicting Political "Big Bang"
-------------- --------------
5. (C) Some media commentators and politicians are
predicting that Sharon's supposed weakened party standing
will prompt him to break with the party and form a new, more
centrist party with like-minded Likudniks and other more
centrist politicians from other parties. This "big bang"
theory arose months aro when fissures deepened in Likud over
Sharon's disengagement plan. Tel Aviv radio reported August
10 that "close confidants" of Sharon are "increasingly in
favor of the option of breaking off from the Likud and of
Ariel Sharon running at the head of a new political party.
MK Eldan noted that the Likud Knesset faction is "quite
divided" and that the number of Likud rebels in the Knesset
has likely swelled from 13 to at least 18. If the total
number of Likud MKs opposing Sharon reaches 20 -- or 50
percent of the Likud MKs -- Erdan noted, Sharon could no
longer take the Likud name with him if he split the party.
Reflecting the range of opinion within political circles MK
Yuval Steinetz told poloff that he was pleased with the poll
results and predicted that Sharon will retire shortly after
disengagement concludes. Shinui MK Ehud Rasabi, on the other
hand, said, "don't write off Sharon," implyig that the Prime
Minister has more than once defied his opponents' best
efforts.
********************************************* ********************
Visit Embassy Tel Aviv's Classified Website:
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/nea/telaviv
You can also access this site through the State Department's
Classified SIPRNET website.
********************************************* ********************
KURTZER