Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
05NEWDELHI282
2005-01-12 08:21:00
CONFIDENTIAL
Embassy New Delhi
Cable title:
PM UPBEAT ON US-INDIA RELATIONS REAFFIRMS EXPORT CONTROL COMMITMENT WITH CODEL FRIST
how-toThis record is a partial extract of the original cable. The full text of the original cable is not available.
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 NEW DELHI 000282
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 01/11/2015
TAGS: PREL ETRD ETTC EAID KDEM IN PK IZ BM CE US
SUBJECT: PM UPBEAT ON US-INDIA RELATIONS REAFFIRMS EXPORT CONTROL COMMITMENT WITH CODEL FRIST
Classified By: Ambassador David C. Mulford, Reason 1.5 (B,D)
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 NEW DELHI 000282
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 01/11/2015
TAGS: PREL ETRD ETTC EAID KDEM IN PK IZ BM CE US
SUBJECT: PM UPBEAT ON US-INDIA RELATIONS REAFFIRMS EXPORT CONTROL COMMITMENT WITH CODEL FRIST
Classified By: Ambassador David C. Mulford, Reason 1.5 (B,D)
1. (C) Summary: Senators Frist, McConnell, DeWine and Coleman discussed a broad range of issues with PM Manmohan Singh during their January 10 meeting, including US-India ties, Tsunami disaster relief, democratization in Burma, HIV/AIDS, trade and the WTO, Iraq, NSSP, Indo-Pak relations, and UNSC reform. The PM remained non-committal regarding expanding Indian involvement in Iraq beyond providing election assistance. End Summary.
Close Bilateral Ties
--------------
2. (C) Emphasizing the importance India places on the US/India relationship, the PM referred to the NSSP, investment, growing trade, and India's desire for FDI from the US, emphasizing specifically bilateral cooperation in counterterrorism, halting WMD proliferation, and working with the US within the WTO to establish a non-discriminatory trading system. Noting that India's relations with the US were ""of the highest priority,"" he expressed his desire to ""deepen and broaden"" ties, especially in the high-tech and defense areas. The PM pointed out that he had met with President Bush in New York on the margins of the UNGA last fall, and was looking forward to seeing him again this year.
Stating that there was a growing convergence between Indian and US interests, based in part on our strong democratic traditions, PM Singh called the US and India ""partners."" He hoped that Indian expertise in IT and biotech would further bilateral cooperation, and explained that the GOI wants to create an ""environment for entrepreneurship in India,"" so that its citizens would no longer have to emigrate. Senator Frist responded by underlining his wish to build on growing US-India ties, which now include a strong Indian-American dimension.
Disaster Relief
--------------
3. (C) After extending condolences regarding the Tsunami disaster, Senator Frist referred to his previous stop in Sri Lanka, where the Sri Lankan President had expressed gratitude to India for its support, noting that New Delhi had gained in respect internationally both as a victim and a donor. The PM thanked the US for its support and assistance to the GOI Tsunami relief effort, adding that he deeply appreciated the
SIPDIS Secretary's visit to the Indian Embassy in Washington. The
SIPDIS PM characterized the establishment of the ""core group"" as a ""good and timely"" step. Noting that for India the suffering was restricted to its South and Eastern islands, the PM hoped that future Indian economic development would take such potential disasters into account.
Democratization in Burma
--------------
4. (C) Senator McConnell asked the PM whether he was troubled by India's ties with the Burmese junta, and how he felt about hosting General Than Shwe last October. PM Singh replied that he holds ASSK in very high regard for the values she promotes, but pointed out that India has a 1400 kilometer land border with Burma, as well as 850 kilometers of shared coastline along the Bay of Bengal, and that the insurgents in some of India's northeastern states take shelter in Burma.
These factors compel India and Burma to talk, he said, and recalled that he had told both General Than Shwe and the Indian Parliament that Burma must do everything possible to honor its own previously stated commitment to restore democracy.
HIV/AIDS
--------------
5. (C) In response to Senator DeWine's question about how India was dealing with HIV/AIDS and the role the international community could play in these efforts, the PM pointed out that there were now five million AIDS sufferers in India. Characterizing AIDS as a ""major national problem,"" he said that it could affect India's economic development, especially because of its impact on the young. Stressing that the GOI takes the problem ""very seriously,"" he noted his engagement with youth in his fight against AIDS. While culture often prevents open discussion of this issue, he had met with the media to enlist their support. The PM expressed appreciation for the support of American and international donor organizations in this battle, and noted that the GOI would commit more resources.
Trade and the WTO
--------------
6. (C) Senator Coleman then asked how the US and India could work better together on trade/WTO issues, and Senator Frist pointed out that the USG would like to see more GOI action on economic reform, including lower tariffs and improved IPR protection. In response, the PM said that both countries want to improve the WTO, and he wants to ensure that it will provide a rule-based, non-discriminatory framework for international trade. He was pleased with the last round of WTO talks, in which he said the US and India had worked closely together. The PM reiterated that the GOI is committed to moving forward together with the US, has already introduced an ordinance to prevent copyright infringement, and expects to introduce legislation to enshrine these measures into law.
Iraq
--------------
7. (C) Senator Frist noted that it is clear there will be an election in Iraq on January 30, and bringing democracy and stability to Iraq must be a real international effort, given that the outcome there effects everyone, including India.
Responding, PM Singh expressed his support for US efforts in Iraq and agreed that it was crucial that the election be held as scheduled. It was vital, the PM said, that the US succeed in Iraq as it has in Afghanistan, although Iraq is a more complex and dangerous situation. He reiterated India's offer to train election officials for Iraq in India. Senator McConnell pointed out that there are two more elections scheduled in Iraq for 2005, one to ratify the new constitution, and one to elect a new government at the end of the year, and encouraged the PM to help with Iraqi elections running into the future.
NSSP
--------------
8. (C) Emphasizing that the USG would like to reinforce and support the Next Steps in Strategic Partnership (NSSP) and expand talks on Missile Defense, Senator Frist commented that the US and India need to improve export control implementation and enforcement to achieve their joint NSSP goals. The PM replied that India takes its nonproliferation obligations seriously, has strong export controls, and wants to halt the spread of WMD.
India/Pakistan Relations
--------------
9. (C) Commenting that US relations with India and Pakistan were not a ""zero-sum"" game and that they should develop independently, Senator Frist noted that the US fully supports a bilateral Indo-Pak approach to Kashmir. PM Singh responded that India is committed to solving all outstanding issues with Islamabad, although any settlement must be based on ground realities, as India cannot support changes of boundaries, especially when based on religion, as this would undermine India's secular character, and be unacceptable to the public at large. Instead, he noted, people on both sides of the LOC should have greater opportunities to travel and trade. Since India is a ""status quo power,"" it wishes Pakistan well and hopes it can bring its problems with terrorism and extremism under control.
United Nations Reform
--------------
10. (C) Senator Coleman ended the meeting by pointing out that both India and the US want a ""credible, effective, transparent UN,"" and hoped that both countries could work together on UN reform. The PM replied that India agrees that the UN is in need of reform and seeks a permanent seat on the UNSC.
11. (U) Baghdad minimize considered.
MULFORD
SIPDIS
E.O. 12958: DECL: 01/11/2015
TAGS: PREL ETRD ETTC EAID KDEM IN PK IZ BM CE US
SUBJECT: PM UPBEAT ON US-INDIA RELATIONS REAFFIRMS EXPORT CONTROL COMMITMENT WITH CODEL FRIST
Classified By: Ambassador David C. Mulford, Reason 1.5 (B,D)
1. (C) Summary: Senators Frist, McConnell, DeWine and Coleman discussed a broad range of issues with PM Manmohan Singh during their January 10 meeting, including US-India ties, Tsunami disaster relief, democratization in Burma, HIV/AIDS, trade and the WTO, Iraq, NSSP, Indo-Pak relations, and UNSC reform. The PM remained non-committal regarding expanding Indian involvement in Iraq beyond providing election assistance. End Summary.
Close Bilateral Ties
--------------
2. (C) Emphasizing the importance India places on the US/India relationship, the PM referred to the NSSP, investment, growing trade, and India's desire for FDI from the US, emphasizing specifically bilateral cooperation in counterterrorism, halting WMD proliferation, and working with the US within the WTO to establish a non-discriminatory trading system. Noting that India's relations with the US were ""of the highest priority,"" he expressed his desire to ""deepen and broaden"" ties, especially in the high-tech and defense areas. The PM pointed out that he had met with President Bush in New York on the margins of the UNGA last fall, and was looking forward to seeing him again this year.
Stating that there was a growing convergence between Indian and US interests, based in part on our strong democratic traditions, PM Singh called the US and India ""partners."" He hoped that Indian expertise in IT and biotech would further bilateral cooperation, and explained that the GOI wants to create an ""environment for entrepreneurship in India,"" so that its citizens would no longer have to emigrate. Senator Frist responded by underlining his wish to build on growing US-India ties, which now include a strong Indian-American dimension.
Disaster Relief
--------------
3. (C) After extending condolences regarding the Tsunami disaster, Senator Frist referred to his previous stop in Sri Lanka, where the Sri Lankan President had expressed gratitude to India for its support, noting that New Delhi had gained in respect internationally both as a victim and a donor. The PM thanked the US for its support and assistance to the GOI Tsunami relief effort, adding that he deeply appreciated the
SIPDIS Secretary's visit to the Indian Embassy in Washington. The
SIPDIS PM characterized the establishment of the ""core group"" as a ""good and timely"" step. Noting that for India the suffering was restricted to its South and Eastern islands, the PM hoped that future Indian economic development would take such potential disasters into account.
Democratization in Burma
--------------
4. (C) Senator McConnell asked the PM whether he was troubled by India's ties with the Burmese junta, and how he felt about hosting General Than Shwe last October. PM Singh replied that he holds ASSK in very high regard for the values she promotes, but pointed out that India has a 1400 kilometer land border with Burma, as well as 850 kilometers of shared coastline along the Bay of Bengal, and that the insurgents in some of India's northeastern states take shelter in Burma.
These factors compel India and Burma to talk, he said, and recalled that he had told both General Than Shwe and the Indian Parliament that Burma must do everything possible to honor its own previously stated commitment to restore democracy.
HIV/AIDS
--------------
5. (C) In response to Senator DeWine's question about how India was dealing with HIV/AIDS and the role the international community could play in these efforts, the PM pointed out that there were now five million AIDS sufferers in India. Characterizing AIDS as a ""major national problem,"" he said that it could affect India's economic development, especially because of its impact on the young. Stressing that the GOI takes the problem ""very seriously,"" he noted his engagement with youth in his fight against AIDS. While culture often prevents open discussion of this issue, he had met with the media to enlist their support. The PM expressed appreciation for the support of American and international donor organizations in this battle, and noted that the GOI would commit more resources.
Trade and the WTO
--------------
6. (C) Senator Coleman then asked how the US and India could work better together on trade/WTO issues, and Senator Frist pointed out that the USG would like to see more GOI action on economic reform, including lower tariffs and improved IPR protection. In response, the PM said that both countries want to improve the WTO, and he wants to ensure that it will provide a rule-based, non-discriminatory framework for international trade. He was pleased with the last round of WTO talks, in which he said the US and India had worked closely together. The PM reiterated that the GOI is committed to moving forward together with the US, has already introduced an ordinance to prevent copyright infringement, and expects to introduce legislation to enshrine these measures into law.
Iraq
--------------
7. (C) Senator Frist noted that it is clear there will be an election in Iraq on January 30, and bringing democracy and stability to Iraq must be a real international effort, given that the outcome there effects everyone, including India.
Responding, PM Singh expressed his support for US efforts in Iraq and agreed that it was crucial that the election be held as scheduled. It was vital, the PM said, that the US succeed in Iraq as it has in Afghanistan, although Iraq is a more complex and dangerous situation. He reiterated India's offer to train election officials for Iraq in India. Senator McConnell pointed out that there are two more elections scheduled in Iraq for 2005, one to ratify the new constitution, and one to elect a new government at the end of the year, and encouraged the PM to help with Iraqi elections running into the future.
NSSP
--------------
8. (C) Emphasizing that the USG would like to reinforce and support the Next Steps in Strategic Partnership (NSSP) and expand talks on Missile Defense, Senator Frist commented that the US and India need to improve export control implementation and enforcement to achieve their joint NSSP goals. The PM replied that India takes its nonproliferation obligations seriously, has strong export controls, and wants to halt the spread of WMD.
India/Pakistan Relations
--------------
9. (C) Commenting that US relations with India and Pakistan were not a ""zero-sum"" game and that they should develop independently, Senator Frist noted that the US fully supports a bilateral Indo-Pak approach to Kashmir. PM Singh responded that India is committed to solving all outstanding issues with Islamabad, although any settlement must be based on ground realities, as India cannot support changes of boundaries, especially when based on religion, as this would undermine India's secular character, and be unacceptable to the public at large. Instead, he noted, people on both sides of the LOC should have greater opportunities to travel and trade. Since India is a ""status quo power,"" it wishes Pakistan well and hopes it can bring its problems with terrorism and extremism under control.
United Nations Reform
--------------
10. (C) Senator Coleman ended the meeting by pointing out that both India and the US want a ""credible, effective, transparent UN,"" and hoped that both countries could work together on UN reform. The PM replied that India agrees that the UN is in need of reform and seeks a permanent seat on the UNSC.
11. (U) Baghdad minimize considered.
MULFORD