Identifier
Created
Classification
Origin
03ANKARA6279
2003-10-07 11:36:00
CONFIDENTIAL
Embassy Ankara
Cable title:  

NORTHERN IRAQ: PUK "PM" BARHAM SALIH IN TURKEY -

Tags:  PTER PREL MOPS MARR PINR TU IZ 
pdf how-to read a cable
This record is a partial extract of the original cable. The full text of the original cable is not available.
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 ANKARA 006279 

SIPDIS


DEPT. FOR EUR/SE AND NEA/NGA


E.O. 12958: DECL: 10/06/2013
TAGS: PTER PREL MOPS MARR PINR TU IZ
SUBJECT: NORTHERN IRAQ: PUK "PM" BARHAM SALIH IN TURKEY -
SUGGESTS BETTER IF TURKS DON'T SEND TROOPS, OPTIMISTIC
ABOUT FUTURE OF IRAQ, SEES HIS FUTURE IN IRAQI NATIONAL
POLITICS

(U) Classified by DCM Robert Deutsch. Reasons 1.5 b and d.


-------
Summary
-------


C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 ANKARA 006279

SIPDIS


DEPT. FOR EUR/SE AND NEA/NGA


E.O. 12958: DECL: 10/06/2013
TAGS: PTER PREL MOPS MARR PINR TU IZ
SUBJECT: NORTHERN IRAQ: PUK "PM" BARHAM SALIH IN TURKEY -
SUGGESTS BETTER IF TURKS DON'T SEND TROOPS, OPTIMISTIC
ABOUT FUTURE OF IRAQ, SEES HIS FUTURE IN IRAQI NATIONAL
POLITICS

(U) Classified by DCM Robert Deutsch. Reasons 1.5 b and d.


--------------
Summary
--------------



1. (C) Patriotic Union of Kurdistan "Prime Minister" Barham
Salih visited Ankara October 6-7 for talks with Turkish
officials. He met DCM, PolMilCouns and PolMilOff Oct. 6 and
said that while he expected terrorism in Iraq to get worse
before it got better, he was optimistic about the future, and
that improvements in Iraq in general had exceeded his
expectations. None of the "doom and gloom" predictions had
come true. Salih, whose visit received considerable press
coverage, told us that while he believed Iraqi Kurds should
not object to a Turkish troop deployment to Iraq if it meant
fewer US casualties, he worried that the introduction of
Turkish troops would complicate the coalition's task, and
that it would be better to have Iraqis do the job. (Press
headlines read "PUK Doesn't Want Turkish Troops in Iraq.")
Salih told us and the Turks that the PUK wanted PKK/KADEK out
of northern Iraq, and confided to us that this would require
close PUK/Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) cooperation, and
that the PUK and its leader Jalal Talabani would be prepared
to help. He also said that we should not use the military
option against the PKK/KADEK for the time being. He said he
believed that Secretary Powell's six-month timeframe for
completion of an Iraqi constitution was achievable, and that
the problems would not be with treatment of religion or
federalism, but rather with how to re-draw administrative
boundaries, and that this could be left until after
ratification. Salih's term as PUK "PM" will end in January

2004. He told us he will not seek re-election, but rather,
intends to get involved in national politics in Baghdad. End
Summary.


-------------- --------------
Salih Optimistic Long-Term, But Expects Terrorism

-------------- --------------



2. (C) On Oct. 6, DCM, PolMilCouns and PolMilOff met with
visiting PUK "PM" Barham Salih, who was in Ankara for talks
with Turkish officials en route back to Iraq from Washington.
Salih said that he was optimistic about the future of Iraq
and that the situation there was already better than he had
expected before the war. None of the "doom and gloom"
predictions had come true. However, terrorism was polluting
the atmosphere. The "bad guys" smell blood, he cautioned,
and said he expected problems with terrorism to get worse
before they got better.


--------------
Salih on Turkish Troops for Iraq
--------------



3. (C) DCM noted that the USG thought that in the right
conditions the introduction of Turkish troops would
contribute to security and stability in Iraq. Salih replied
that he had told Masoud Barzani that if the introduction of
Turkish troops would reduce the casualties and risk to US
forces, the Iraqi Kurds should not say no, after what the US
had done. He then said that it was doing harm to speak to
the issue as Iraqi Kurds, and that the matter of foreign
troops should be an Iraqi issue at the national/Governing
Council level. Seeming to move away from his original
statement, Salih added that putting in Turkish troops would
complicate the coalition's task, and that it would be better
to have Iraqis do the job. The Turks, he continued, do not
speak the language and unlike the US forces, whom Salih
called extremely impressive, do not appeal to people's
humanity. "You may end up with a problem from this. Be
careful," he said. Salih said he had told MFA Undersecretary
Ziyal that Turkish troops would be deliberately attacked by
former regime loyalists, that Turkish press headlines would
accuse the KDP, PUK or PKK/KADEK of the attacks, and that the
Turkish forces would not exercise the control and composure
of US forces in the situation. All of this, Salih opined,
would amount to political and security liabilities for
Turkey, Iraq and the coalition. (Press play mirrored these
points: Turkish Daily News quoted Salih: "Deployment of
Turkish soldiers or those from other neighboring countries
could harm the security and political environment. This
could be against the interests of the Iraqi people and at the
same time those of Turkey.") The DCM noted that the Turks had
been told that the Sunni Arabs would welcome Turkish troops.
Salih disagreed and said Iraqi Arabs were telling the Turks
what they thought Turkey wanted to hear.



4. (C) Salih said that at the end of the day, Iraq needed
Turkey as a partner and a model, even with all of its
shortcomings, but that a Turkish troop deployment would muddy
the waters in this regard, and would push Iraqi nationalists
toward confrontation with the Turks.


--------------
PUK Will Cooperate Against PKK/KADEK
--------------



5. (C) The DCM noted that the US was committed to eliminate
the PKK/KADEK threat in Iraq and that we believed the Turkish
Reintegration Law was an opportunity for most of the
PKK/KADEK elements in Iraq to return and reestablish
themselves in Turkey. Anything the PUK could do to help them
understand that they will not be allowed to remain in Iraq
would be appreciated. Salih answered that he was surprised
by the grip the PKK/KADEK leadership had over the rank and
file, and that getting any significant numbers of them to
return to Turkey would require close PUK-KDP cooperation. He
urged the US to avoid any military engagement with the
PKK/KADEK at this time, as it could unbalance the stability
in the north. Salih added that if the US could convince the
PKK/KADEK rank and file that a good reception with
international monitoring by an NGO, the UN or the US awaited
them if they surrendered, there would be better odds of
getting them back to Turkey. "We don't want them in Iraq
either," he said. "Their leaders are bad guys, and their
followers are blind to reality. I don't trust them. They
are opportunistic liars. If you can get rid of them, it will
be better for us." Salih suggested using the VOA Kurdish
service to broadcast messages about the opportunities
available under the Turkish Reintegration Law. Talabani and
the PUK would cooperate with the US in its effort against the
PKK/KADEK, he promised. He thought Barzani would help as
well, especially if it meant an end to the Turkish troop
presence in northern Iraq, but said Barzani and the KDP would
have to understand that it was not/not useful or helpful to
use the PKK/KADEK presence to pressure Turkey. Salih said
there were people in Europe the PUK could talk to for help
against the PKK/KADEK and that Turkey should try to get
Ocalan to help as well. First, he said, there needs to be
more comfort about the Reintegration Law. "Don't use too
much pressure too early," he counseled, or Kurds generally
will believe that Turkey is pushing the US into a
confrontation to create a schism between the US and the
Kurds.


-------------- --------------
Turkish Concerns - Iraqi Constitution and Ethnicity
-------------- --------------



6. (C) Salih told us that in his meeting with MFA U/S Ziyal
earlier in the day, Ziyal was focused on issues of the Iraqi
constitution, federalism and ethnicity. Salih said he told
Ziyal that the Autonomy Law from the 1970s provided for
autonomy for the Kurdistan region (not for specific ethnic
groups in the region),and would be a basis for discussion in
the constitutional process. He also said that the Iraqi
Kurds would accept a modality to resolve the status of
Kirkuk. Salih asked the Turks to encourage the new Iraqi
Turkmen Front (ITF) leadership to work with the PUK. The
Turks told Salih that Syria and Iran had asked Turkey for a
tripartite meeting about the situation in northern Iraq,
about which both Damascus and Tehran were agitated, but the
Turks refused. Salih told us that he would see TGS reps the
morning of Oct. 7, but that on future visits he would not see
Turkish intelligence (TNIO) or military reps, as the nature
of the relationship had changed and those entities should see
their Iraqi counterparts, while he should confine himself to
political and foreign policy contacts.


-------------- --
Salih on Constitution Timeline, Personal Future
-------------- --

7. (C) Salih told us he believed the Iraqi constitution could
be completed within the six-month timeframe suggested by
Secretary Powell. He was confident the Iraqis could agree on

SIPDIS
language concerning the role of religion and the nature of
federalism. The contentious piece would be the determination
of administrative boundaries, which he said could be deferred
and considered by a "blue ribbon" commission after completion
of the constitution. In any case, he noted, constitutions
have never been very important in the Middle East. Salih
noted that, unlike the KDP, the PUK had decided to fly the
Iraqi flag side-by-side with the Kurdish flag. This was a
particularly hard decision to adhere to when Secretary Powell
visited Halabja, he added, noting that the symbolism of
flying the Iraqi flag over the Halabja cemetery was painful.
The people of northern Iraq, he said, feel increasingly
connected to Baghdad, and that he would like more support
from Baghdad for the administration of Sulaymaniyah. Salih
told us that PUK leader Talabani would visit Ankara on
November 19, while serving as IGC Chairman, at the invitation
of the GOT. Turning to his own political future, he said
that his term as PUK "PM" would end in January and that he
would not seek reelection. He hopes to find a role for
himself in national politics in Baghdad in 2004.



8. (U) Baghdad Minimize Considered.
EDELMAN